World Cup: 4 Nations Tournament- Team USA (2025)
- Thread starter AmericanDream
- Start date
-
Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
If Harley was unavailable to Canada right now I would have no isssues. But the fact that he still is, means they effectively have one more extra player than we do. That is what makes it unfair.
Last edited:
William H Bonney
Registered User
Dirtyclapper
Registered User
Send in Hughes lol we aren't making a run with pettersson anyway
All good Canadian fans cheer for their American athletes to get a hat trick (and lose in OT).
ORRFForever
Registered User
- Oct 29, 2018
- 20,730
- 11,856
Last edited:
The spirit of this tournament is best on best, Quinn Hughes is the best, the idea that he shouldn't play at all if he regains the ability to is insane to me. I say that as a Canadian.
Hell let Petro play if he wants to, but it sounds crazy to me to watch a lesser product and have worse competition just because. It's a stupid rule to begin with and I'm never in favor of stupid rules being enforced.
Let the teams name a good chunk of players and obviously if the best are hurt others go in, but the idea that the best would get left off when they can play is crazy to me.
Canadians complaining about Binnington. Americans upset about Canadians having an extra dman. Looks like both sides have their excuses ready to go.
Forget Petro...Canada needs Logan Thompson if we're letting anyone join.
Dirtyclapper
Registered User
I was literally just thinking about how much I hate having Binnington in net lol, just watching overdrive on YouTube. It is what it is I won't use it as an excuse, I'm just happy to have the international game back. He won't even make the team next time though I don't get the thought process but listening to the podcast they're saying why all the red tape let the best go at it which I agree with. First tournament in forever, next one will be more thought outCanadians complaining about Binnington. Americans upset about Canadians having an extra dman. Looks like both sides have their excuses ready to go.
...so the rule was followed...Canada just hit it first...no rule was added, bent or broken...so the issue is that Canada hit that critical point before anyone else did...as I stated PAGES AGO...timing...
Matthews has the chance to do something he's never done, be a leader. Sit out, get Hughes into the lineup (put Sanderson on 4th line wing or whatever). It's not like USA would miss their 4th or 5th best C anyway
Winner take all game.. I'd have more confidence in the guy who's won a cup (with a great SCF game 7) going up against the guy who's shit the bed the last 2 playoffsCanadians complaining about Binnington. Americans upset about Canadians having an extra dman. Looks like both sides have their excuses ready to go.
SanDogBrewin
Righteous bucks!
Lasch is always ready to push the US over the top.
SanDogBrewin
Righteous bucks!
Harley was also cleared to play against Finland regardless of the status of Cale Makar, according to Friedman (Makar ended up playing and Harley sat in the press box though). I don't see why Harley wouldn't be clear to play tomorrow night, also regardless of the status of Makar.
I agree the rules should be different and they should make those changes for the next iteration.
Terrier
Registered User
Scotty Bowman discusses the 4 Nations and U.S. hockey.
OBF: Spice on ice for US vs. Canada
The Cold War hasn’t been this hot since Lake Placid. Team USA vs. the Big Red Machine. This Red menace has nothing to do with Johnny Bench, Pete Rose, or the Soviet Union. Instead of Moscow, hockey…
www.bostonherald.com
JediOrderPizza
Registered User
The media will be the media, I guess. Much ado about nothing. I still have yet to see a source stating that USA Hockey has even asked the NHL if Hughes could be added to the roster with the loss of McAvoy. I admit I haven't been looking very hard, but I'm also under the assumption that if that had actually happened, it would have been posted here very quickly.
Sullivan opened his mouth before knowing what the rules were.
Rob Brown
Way She Goes
- Dec 17, 2009
- 17,539
- 14,678
Yes, I said that when it was reported that he was heading to Boston, which all of you were talking up as if the US was going to fake an injury to get him in. You know that the back and forth we had yesterday was when we all thought Hughes was going to Boston.
They have 6 healthy D and Canada didn't, hence the Harley call-up. Sounds like the rules are pretty consistent to me despite you stating otherwise.
Also sounds to me like they could call Hughes up but he couldn't play despite an injury, and he just doesn't want to fly across the continent for no reason.
Feel like we're debating different things at this point so all good.
Last edited:
WarriorofTime
Registered User
- Jul 3, 2010
- 33,232
- 23,532
I'm going to say if a player is initially listed on a roster, then needs to get replaced, but during the time of the tournament becomes healthy enough to play they should be allowed to play, but that they should automatically take the spot of whichever player was named as the injury replacement (unless of course that injury replacement is taking the spot of a different injured player).
So the initial 7 for USA were: Faber, Fox, Hanifin, Q. Hughes, McAvoy, Slavin, Werenski.
Q. Hughes injured, replaced by Sanderson.
Then if Q. Hughes subsequently healthy, he can replace Sanderson. But with McAvoy now injured, Sanderson stays and replaces McAvoy.
This I think avoids any shenanigans of teams having roster decision regret, which I think is the scenario you would most like to avoid, while still ensuring healthy roster players are able to play. Essentially keeps the spirit of the injury replacement rule.
So the initial 7 for USA were: Faber, Fox, Hanifin, Q. Hughes, McAvoy, Slavin, Werenski.
Q. Hughes injured, replaced by Sanderson.
Then if Q. Hughes subsequently healthy, he can replace Sanderson. But with McAvoy now injured, Sanderson stays and replaces McAvoy.
This I think avoids any shenanigans of teams having roster decision regret, which I think is the scenario you would most like to avoid, while still ensuring healthy roster players are able to play. Essentially keeps the spirit of the injury replacement rule.
Beau Knows
Registered User
Next time the NHL needs to iron out the rules before the tournament starts.
Is Hughes not being added to the roster though? Like Sullivan said? He’s aloud to be there as a 7 Dman but he can’t play unless someone else is out. Just like Harley , Canada can only play him if someone else is out
Ad
Upcoming events
-
-
-
CHAMPIONSHIP - Canada vs United States - TD Garden, BostonWagers: 35Staked: $220,103.00Event closes
- Updated:
-
-
