This keeps coming up in different forms so I figured I'd create it's own thread for it here.
The Canadiens came into this season pretty confident that Dach would be their number two. So far it hasn't worked out that way and as a result the entire lineup seems off. Posters seem split on what to do with Dach himself but while he works to get his confidence back, we still remain without a true number two center. So what route do we take?
Option 1. Stay the course. Wait for Dach to find his game and tough it out. This likely results in a high pick anyway so there's an extra benefit from going this route.
Option 2. Trade for a temporary fix. We could trade for a Monahan/Malkin type and ride them for a couple of years. We'd probably go up in the standings but they could help the youngters develop.
Option 3. Trade for a more permanent solution. In this scenario we get somebody who can fill in for years at the position.
In all of these scenarios, I like the idea of keeping Dach. I think he'll regain his form even if it takes time. At the very least he'd be great to have for center depth.
I agree that we have to ride out the year with Dach. In his first year with us he got better as the season progressed, even finding his shot which a centre needs to have in order to have a good passing game. He was promising that year and unfortunately last year was a disaster. So I think he has the ability to be a 2C , he needs to get himself together mentally.
The 2C we want is ideally a young guy but of course every team wants a young and good 2C. So we need a guy who has at least 3-4 good years left so we can compete in these next 4 years.
A reason to give Dach the year is, why not ? We are not going for any Cup and while I want us to start being more competitive, its important to not give up assets for a legit 2C if we dont have to make such a trade. Why ? Aside from perhaps a starting goalie, the most significant other piece we need is a top D man, no offense to Matheson. I think Hutson is a sure no.#3 but dont know about him as top pairing. Guhle as no.2. The no.4D spot needs replacing soon as Savard is likely gone.. I dont see anybody in the system for that spot in the short term, especially the RHD. An injured Reinbacher and a year of lost development really hurts.
To get both a 2C and a top D man is very costly. So give Dach the shot, hope he figures it out as I think we will have to trade for a top RHD.