Toggle sidebar

24/25 Waivers/Rumors/TDL Thread.

RedHawkDown said:
Dude said "if the news we got is true". No need to go at him when the actual opening night roster has been bad for 3 years straight. It's not a stretch to think it'll happen again lmao.

I don't get it. So many other teams manage to extract massive value out of trades and waiver wire/offer sheet/etc pickups. Holloway/Broberg, Suzuki trade, Fabbro, ugh.

I'm just praying every night that Buch in fact does become Panarin 2.0.
Click to expand...
Because the tweet has zero information. It’s absolutely clickbaiting. Especially because it requires the Red wings making some definitive statement about next season, which is highly unlikely.

Fans will likely be upset about something with the opening night roster so then they can pretend they were right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SirloinUB
datsyukfan said:
What 4 are you exactly talking about. It’s laughable that you think Copp and Compher are AHL level players. I get you don’t like them but come on
Click to expand...
Why are Copp or Compher NHL players??

-They can't kill penalties.
-They aren't physical, at all.
-Neither are scoring threats.
-Neither seems to have exercised in the summer since getting their deals.

They both bring nothing. Nothing. 50 guys in the AHL and Europe who could bring 3 of those 4 things.

Just wasted minutes.

..........

The other two were Holl and Gustafsson. Neither of whom would even be top-pair AHL players on AHL playoff teams.
 
RedHawkDown said:
Yeah sorry I also consider myself a pessimist around these parts but this is just delusional. Andrew Copp has played 700 NHL games. To suggest he’s an AHL vet is simply jsut objectively false.
Click to expand...
Why are Copp or Compher NHL players TODAY??

-They can't kill penalties.
-They aren't physical, at all.
-Neither are scoring threats.
-Neither seems to have exercised in the summer since getting their deals.

They both bring nothing. Nothing. 50 guys in the AHL and Europe who could bring 3 of those 4 things.

Just wasted minutes.
 
ElProfessor said:
Why are Copp or Compher NHL players TODAY??

-They can't kill penalties.
-They aren't physical, at all.
-Neither are scoring threats.
-Neither seems to have exercised in the summer since getting their deals.

They both bring nothing. Nothing. 50 guys in the AHL and Europe who could bring 3 of those 4 things.

Just wasted minutes.
Click to expand...

Unfortunately AHLers can't even provide the ~10 goals and ~20 assists that Copp/Compher provide. The best that guys like Motte and Watson can do is 15 points in a career year. One of the reasons why the team is sucking is because Copp is injured. He was playing 2C, though we all know he's 3C at best.

Mind you, I hate both players, but even I will acknowledge that they are better than having AHLers on the team. Shine has 1 assist in 9 games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SirloinUB and Winger98
Gniwder said:
Unfortunately AHLers can't even provide the ~10 goals and ~20 assists that Copp/Compher provide. The best that guys like Motte and Watson can do is 15 points in a career year. One of the reasons why the team is sucking is because Copp is injured. He was playing 2C, though we all know he's 3C at best.

Mind you, I hate both players, but even I will acknowledge that they are better than having AHLers on the team. Shine has 1 assist in 9 games.
Click to expand...
Would replacing Copp/Compher w 2 AHL vets who get you ~5 goals and ~10 assists while being strong penalty killers and make-you-think-twice physical presences make this team better??

Absolutely. Copp/Compher aren't even as useful as good AHL'ers.

rAss, Berggren, Tarasenko, Holl, Gus, Motte (Fischer, Veleno, Lyon) all in the exact same boat.

We're essentially 10 NHL players and a (bad) AHL team.
 
Last edited:
Buffalo has 4 solid RFAs this year.

McCloud
Peterka
Quinn
Byram

Byram and Peterka aren’t getting less than 6 mil a season so I’d advise them but I think one of McCloud and Quinn can be stolen for 4.5 and only cost a second rounder. That would be great value.
 
ElProfessor said:
Why are Copp or Compher NHL players??

-They can't kill penalties.
-They aren't physical, at all.
-Neither are scoring threats.
-Neither seems to have exercised in the summer since getting their deals.

They both bring nothing. Nothing. 50 guys in the AHL and Europe who could bring 3 of those 4 things.

Just wasted minutes.

..........

The other two were Holl and Gustafsson. Neither of whom would even be top-pair AHL players on AHL playoff teams.
Click to expand...
They do a ton of little things throughout the course of a game that help you win.

The fact that people are still shitting on Copp when it’s been pretty obvious we really miss having a player like that in our middle 6 over this recent stretch is hilarious.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SirloinUB, Rzombo4 prez, SantosHalper and 6 others
ElProfessor said:
Would replacing Copp/Compher w 2 AHL vets who get you ~5 goals and ~10 assists while being strong penalty killers and make-you-think-twice physical presences make this team better??

Absolutely. Copp/Compher aren't even as useful as good AHL'ers.

rAss, Berggren, Tarasenko, Holl, Gus, Motte (Fischer, Veleno, Lyon) all in the exact same boat.

We're essentially 10 NHL players and a (bad) AHL team.
Click to expand...

No because that doesn't exist.

You are way underdoing Copp and Compher and I am not even a fan of either really. You really just make yourself look bad and like you don't even have a clue suggesting either are anywhere near close to AHL players. You have seen Shine and Watson right? Those are AHL players.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SirloinUB, Rzombo4 prez and Lazlo Hollyfeld
Frk It said:
They do a ton of little things throughout the course of a game that help you win.

The fact that people are still shitting on Copp when it’s been pretty obvious we really miss having a player like that in our middle 6 over this recent stretch is hilarious.
Click to expand...

Agreed. People often underestimate the talent gap between even a mediocre NHL player and an AHLer.

If Copp and Compher could be easily replaced by an AHL player, they would've been.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FMichael and Winger98
OgeeOgelthorpe said:
Buffalo has 4 solid RFAs this year.

McCloud
Peterka
Quinn
Byram

Byram and Peterka aren’t getting less than 6 mil a season so I’d advise them but I think one of McCloud and Quinn can be stolen for 4.5 and only cost a second rounder. That would be great value.
Click to expand...
You don't think Buffalo matches at $4.5? I would honestly go bigger at Byram if we are offer sheeting a Sabre (which I am totally on board with)
 
Rzombo4 prez said:
You don't think Buffalo matches at $4.5? I would honestly go bigger at Byram if we are offer sheeting a Sabre (which I am totally on board with)
Click to expand...
I think the concern in Buffalo is that they'll cap limit themselves a bit and have a hard time matching whatever RFA are unsigned longest. I assume Byram would be a priority for them but maybe he'll just refuse to sign.
 
Rzombo4 prez said:
You don't think Buffalo matches at $4.5? I would honestly go bigger at Byram if we are offer sheeting a Sabre (which I am totally on board with)
Click to expand...
Think sabres match . I haven’t looked at any teams cap numbers but I don’t know if there’s a team out there like edm were. Broberg woulda been nice .... doubt it happens but if leafs sign Tavares and marner before knies he could be an option? Doubt they’re dumb enough to not sign him first

Ducks could be a good partner to trade with. Underachieving team with loads of kids
 
OgeeOgelthorpe said:
Buffalo has 4 solid RFAs this year.

McCloud
Peterka
Quinn
Byram

Byram and Peterka aren’t getting less than 6 mil a season so I’d advise them but I think one of McCloud and Quinn can be stolen for 4.5 and only cost a second rounder. That would be great value.
Click to expand...

I don't think Buffalo lets McLeod go for 4.5.
 
ElProfessor said:
Would replacing Copp/Compher w 2 AHL vets who get you ~5 goals and ~10 assists while being strong penalty killers and make-you-think-twice physical presences make this team better??

Absolutely. Copp/Compher aren't even as useful as good AHL'ers.

rAss, Berggren, Tarasenko, Holl, Gus, Motte (Fischer, Veleno, Lyon) all in the exact same boat.

We're essentially 10 NHL players and a (bad) AHL team.
Click to expand...

You're delusional. Berggren was a top AHL player, and he's not that useful in the NHL. A "good" AHLer would be even worse. Plus Ras and Holl were realgud AHLers. If you don't understand the level difference between the AHL and NHL, just look at Burger stats.

Motte is an AHLer, Tank's effort level won't do much in any league, and Gus apparently left his brain on a bus somewhere.

Copp/Compher? I'll take them over a good AHLer, though I absolutely hate both contracts. I'd like them much better at half the cost.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SirloinUB
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom