24/25 Waivers/Rumors/TDL Thread.

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
  • We are currently aware of "log in/security error" issues that are affecting some users. We apologize and ask for your patience as we try to get these issues fixed.
Could improve, dont think he'll be a 70-85 pt forward. Probably be in the 40-55 most his career. Dont think he'll ever be "the guy"

23 more pts in the last 3 seasons... you'd think hed have 100 more pts. Yes I know you can't only evaluate on pts , again it's not much. That's just your take, I'm sure alot of ppl around the league would say hes better. Not many would say hes far much better

Anyways
Check the top prospect lists and see where Stankoven was listed vs where Plante has been listed (hint: he’s not listed). They’re not even remotely the same level of prospect.

23 more points while scoring like 50-30pts more than his next closest teammate. Rantanen wa she third best on his own team.

Again, Pastrnak is a much better player
 
Check the top prospect lists and see where Stankoven was listed vs where Plante has been listed (hint: he’s not listed). They’re not even remotely the same level of prospect.

23 more points while scoring like 50-30pts more than his next closest teammate. Rantanen wa she third best on his own team.

Again, Pastrnak is a much better player
No one ever said they were the same player. Your also making him out to be more special than he is. Dallas got rantanen signed and got 2 1sts and stankoven. 1st + nygaard is essentially 2 1sts throw in a plante +johansson or kiiskinen whatever, and a 2nd if need be its essentially the same offer

Again no team is offering up a raymond seider edvinsson type roster player for pastrnak. Nobody.... nobody is offering a #1level prospect like asp in a deal . Nobody...teams that would get him they're #1 prospect wouldn't be as good as a rebuilding teams

Whatever you say dude , agree to disagree
 
Ya I dont think hes going anywhere cause they wont be able to get a top ufa like him. They'll just role the dice with the cap going up hoping they'll get a better roster
Sure the cap is going up but Marner isn't giving them a hometown discount. If the Leafs give him top money, 16 mil or more, they can't have much left to ice a complete roster.

If I'm Yzerman I pay whatever it takes knowing it will be an overpayment.
 
No one ever said they were the same player. Your also making him out to be more special than he is. Dallas got rantanen signed and got 2 1sts and stankoven. 1st + nygaard is essentially 2 1sts throw in a plante +johansson or kiiskinen whatever, and a 2nd if need be its essentially the same offer

Again no team is offering up a raymond seider edvinsson type roster player for pastrnak. Nobody.... nobody is offering a #1level prospect like asp in a deal . Nobody...teams that would get him they're #1 prospect wouldn't be as good as a rebuilding teams

Whatever you say dude , agree to disagree
Teams are, without a doubt, offering prospects like ASP for a 27yo top 10 player in the NHL.

That’s ridiculous to say otherwise. Even more ridiculous to say Stankoven isn’t an A level prospect, he has been rated that by about every ranking out there.
 
Last edited:
Teams are, without a doubt, offering prospects like ASP for a 27yo top 10 player in the NHL.

That’s ridiculous to say otherwise. Even more ridiculous to say Stankoven isn’t an A level prospect, he has been rated that by about every ranking out there.

28 going on 29

We'll just have to agree to disagree and see what the trade return is when it happens
 
Sure the cap is going up but Marner isn't giving them a hometown discount. If the Leafs give him top money, 16 mil or more, they can't have much left to ice a complete roster.

If I'm Yzerman I pay whatever it takes knowing it will be an overpayment.
There's zero chance in hell I give marner anything close to 16 mill this isn't the nba where you can give 2 guys 35-40 mill and expect to win

Only McDavid I'd reluctantly give 16 but that's it . Marner's leafs have always been a dud in the playoffs

Id rather give ehlers 9 mill even though I think hes closer to 8 and have 7 mill to use towards another player. I think chychrun returns to Washington but I'd rather get ehlers 9 mill and chychrun 8 for 17 million than marner 16 million

No thanks
 
There's zero chance in hell I give marner anything close to 16 mill this isn't the nba where you can give 2 guys 35-40 mill and expect to win

Only McDavid I'd reluctantly give 16 but that's it . Marner's leafs have always been a dud in the playoffs

Id rather give ehlers 9 mill even though I think hes closer to 8 and have 7 mill to use towards another player. I think chychrun returns to Washington but I'd rather get ehlers 9 mill and chychrun 8 for 17 million than marner 16 million

No thanks
While I agree that I'd rather get two guys at the prices you losted. This is Detroit. They will have to overpay. Rantenen just set the market.he got 8 yrs 12 mil. Marner is a better player and more teams will be bidding driving g the price up.

I think marner gets 7 years 14 mil at least. Mcdavid might get 20 mil when his deal is up.
 

Ad

Ad