FWIW I do think they can go wrong with Pasta.
It’ll be an unpopular opinion but IMO Marchand does a lot of things I wouldn’t necessarily want from a captain. Slow, lazy changes, stupid penalties, etc. I love the player and have no issue with him as captain given our choices, but Id much rather it be a player like Bergeron still.
So IMO, pasta has similar issues. Questionable commitment to defense, lazy penalties, etc.
I’d vote McAvoy, with the caveat that he’s also a guy I’d trade since it seems like he’s stalled as a player. He gives you glimpses but it’s just not going the way we’d hoped.
Overall I think this organization is in trouble in the leadership department and I think it absolutely shows. From the top down.