Chipchura was a potential top 5-10 pick before his draft year. I don't think that's remotely true. His draft season lagged a little because he played on a shit team. He was supposed to be the best center available after Malkin. None of his team mates, even goalies, made a full-time NHL roster. Not even one.
Bear is floating in the 15-18 range even before this news; though some were extremely bullish on him. There's not really a big difference in pre-draft hype.
Either you guys weren't following prospects back then or you're trying to compare 2024 numbers to 2004 numbers like there's any merit to it. Like the NHL, CHL scoring is massively up in the past few years. Chipchura was expected to become essentially what Patrice Bergeron became.