Red Sox/MLB 2024 Playoffs: Dodgers win the World Series

JRull86

Registered User
Jan 28, 2009
27,774
15,814
South Shore
I don't believe potential impact bats should be dealt for pitching basically ever. There's way too much volatility with pitching now.

Use Sale as an example. That trade worked for BOS because they clearly didn't believe in Moncada and dealt the right guy. But imagine if they dealt Devers++ for Sale instead.

You potentially don't win the WS in 18 without Devers at 3B, and you gave up a 30/100 guy for two years of Sale, and then 4 injured years years before dealing him.

If their target is Crochet, there is no acceptable scenario that Anthony should be involved in that deal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CDJ and EverettMike

JRull86

Registered User
Jan 28, 2009
27,774
15,814
South Shore
This Soto stuff is hilarious

Steve Cohan wants him it’s done


You falling for Soto

There is 0.0 chance the Red Sox sign him
Not getting my hopes up, but outside of money, why on earth would Soto go to the Mets over Yankees or even Boston?

He's the face of the franchise if he goes to Sox, strong DR roots and history, they'll be competitive starting this season assuming all the talk is for real.

Yankees, he has easily the next 3-4 season of being a legit contender every year in the AL, they always spend.

Mets outside of Lindor have no value to him besides Cohen offering money.
 

yazmybaby

Registered User
Sep 13, 2015
2,684
2,292
Brampton ON, Canada
I don't believe potential impact bats should be dealt for pitching basically ever. There's way too much volatility with pitching now.

Use Sale as an example. That trade worked for BOS because they clearly didn't believe in Moncada and dealt the right guy. But imagine if they dealt Devers++ for Sale instead.

You potentially don't win the WS in 18 without Devers at 3B, and you gave up a 30/100 guy for two years of Sale, and then 4 injured years years before dealing him.

If their target is Crochet, there is no acceptable scenario that Anthony should be involved in that deal.
Anthony does not have to be included in a trade for Crochet.
We are the envy of many teams and have the talent to get him if we want.
Abreu is expendable, so is Crawford and some lower level prospects should get the deal done.
I agree with you, no way I am trading an impact bat, like RA ( everyday player) for a pitcher that has had one good year in the majors.
 

Mr Cartmenez

Registered User
May 15, 2009
5,073
1,843
Mannheim
  • Like
Reactions: Seidenbergy

EvilDead

Shop smart. Shop S-Mart.
Nov 6, 2014
9,849
8,374
Taiwan
Sincere question.

How accurate do you feel his assessment is?

His much is an old guy being pissed about how different a young guy is handling something that his generation would have.

There’s got be some truth in both.

Hirooka was the man who revolutionized how training in NPB is done and has trained/developed some of the best players in NPB when managing the Saitama Lions' dynasty of the 80s and early 90s. He's also seen it all when it comes to players going over from Japan to the States. He has knowledge about how this will all go, typically speaking.

edit: I hate my phone
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: sarge88

EvilDead

Shop smart. Shop S-Mart.
Nov 6, 2014
9,849
8,374
Taiwan


1731715867035.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: GatorMike

Chevalier du Clavier

Écrivain de ferrage
Jul 20, 2005
4,639
3,616
As soon as that pipe dream Soto has passed, they should quickly shift their focus on to Snell and Fried. I'd take both, but Frieds GB tendencies gives me a little pause considering the bad IF-defense behind him. If they were to sign him and Bello in the same rotation, they should seriously re-consider their IF structure.

Might be awhile.

 
  • Like
Reactions: bbfan419

DKH

Worst Poster/Awful Takes
Feb 27, 2002
76,685
57,746
If Henry blows this opportunity I'm going to never forgive this franchise
What opportunity?

Scott Boras is involved

Zzzzzzzzero.zero

There are a couple of owners without budgets - actually maybe one: Steve Cohen

This is coming down to Mets & Yankees

I’d skip on Soto & sign Burnes

I would rather have a top of the rotation top pitcher then Soto with where they are at
 
  • Like
Reactions: GatorMike

DKH

Worst Poster/Awful Takes
Feb 27, 2002
76,685
57,746
He's on the record saying he's been a Sox fan his entire life. Big Manny and Papi fan.

But money talks.

And the Sox ain't gonna pony up
This guy is just screwing around but he did pay to get the check mark
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad