2024 Offseason Goalie Rankings #1

[Boreal01]

Bringing this back from a few years ago

Vote for the best goalie from this list using whatever criteria you'd like to employ

Feel free to offer recommendations as to who should be added next

Click to read more...

 

[Ignite111]

Igor

 

[SnowblindNYR]

Shesty is a weird one, has been very up and down in the regular season and even though I've had issues with him in the playoffs still is probably the best playoff goalie currently.

 

[Regal]

Probably between Helly and Shesty unless Vasi shows strong again. Voted Shesterkin because of their playoffs.

 

[Sasha Orlov]

Shesterkin easily

 

[dirtydanglez]

hellebuycks playoffs tipped this in shesterkins favor.

 

[MasterMatt25]

Add Adin Hill

 

[bobholly39]

Probably between Helly and Shesty unless Vasi shows strong again. Voted Shesterkin because of their playoffs.

I voted Shesterkin. Helle is probably #2.

I'm disappointed with Vasi - that's 2 years in a row he hasn't been very good, including playoffs. I gave him benefit of the doubt going into last year and still ranked him #1, but not anymore this year as I no longer have him #1.

He's young to already be declining, so I hope he finds a way to bounce back, He hasn't been bad per se - but he seems just kind of average lately. Reliable enough for a #1 goalie for sure, just not best in league anymore.

OP - are you planning on running similar polls for other positions too, or just goalies?

 

[Mrb1p]

I voted Shesterkin. Helle is probably #2.

I'm disappointed with Vasi - that's 2 years in a row he hasn't been very good, including playoffs. I gave him benefit of the doubt going into last year and still ranked him #1, but not anymore this year as I no longer have him #1.

He's young to already be declining, so I hope he finds a way to bounce back, He hasn't been bad per se - but he seems just kind of average lately. Reliable enough for a #1 goalie for sure, just not best in league anymore.

OP - are you planning on running similar polls for other positions too, or just goalies?

Vasis not declining, the Tampa team defense has massively declined. People who thought he was some kind of superhuman goaltenders are just bad talent evaluator.

 

[Boreal01]

I voted Shesterkin. Helle is probably #2.

I'm disappointed with Vasi - that's 2 years in a row he hasn't been very good, including playoffs. I gave him benefit of the doubt going into last year and still ranked him #1, but not anymore this year as I no longer have him #1.

He's young to already be declining, so I hope he finds a way to bounce back, He hasn't been bad per se - but he seems just kind of average lately. Reliable enough for a #1 goalie for sure, just not best in league anymore.

OP - are you planning on running similar polls for other positions too, or just goalies?

Figured I'd just start with goalies for now to avoid overpopulating the polls section as we'll also have prospect rankings going at the same time

I could run defencemen in August and forwards in September but someone else is more than welcome to run it if they'd like

 

[amnesiac]

add Andersen, Jarry