Prospect Info: 2024 June - Who is Detroit's #1 prospect?

[Henkka]

Okay.

Now let's start this again.

I'll do this by adding Top4 guys from the latest rank + Brandsegg-Nygård.

After one wins, the next round will work as adding the next best on the candidates.

Tomorrow we have also rest of the 2024 draftees, to add on mix.

Click to read more...

 

[jaster]

Edvinsson.

 

[izlez]

Already can’t vote for the guy I want. Upping the chaos levels. Love it.

 

[Winger98]

didn't we just do this?

 

[Shaman464]

didn't we just do this?

There's a new name now tho!

 

[RRhoads]

Can't we just do one thread where we rank our top 10? It will be more accurate

 

[Our Lady Peace]

Edvinsson

 

[RedWingzz]

other- Simon Edvinsson

 

[HisNoodliness]

Presumably Edvinsson's absence is because he's considered graduated.

I voted ASP actually because I think his season was a step above Danielson's. They're neck and neck for me though.

I'm going to have a really hard time slotting Kasper and MBN. I liked Kasper more at the time of their drafts and Kasper has had solid but somewhat disappointing development since. He's older with a lot more certainty, but that certainty almost hurts him as I see less boom potential. I think I'm leaning MBN, but I also maybe expect that to have changed by the end of Kasper's preseason.

 

[Frk It]

Prospect poll reeeeeeeemix

 

[JediOrderPizza]

Danny Nate.

 

[Steve Yzerlland]

Edvinsson is not a prospect anymore guys.Will never play in GR ever again. Never ever never ever never never ever.

 

[tabness]

ASP is gonna turn out to be better than Makar BOOK IT

 

[Pavels Dog]

Edvinsson is not a prospect anymore guys.Will never play in GR ever again. Never ever never ever never never ever.

So Celebrini isn't a prospect? Cool.

 

[Peter Tosh]

Most prospects never make it. And most of the ones who make it will have a low impact on team success. Therefore, these lists tend to get very academic in ranking players who will never be Red Wings in real life. In reality, it's more accurate to list them in these categories:

High chance of making a long term impact
Danielson
Sandin-Pellikka
Brandsegg-Nygård

High chance of making the team at some point
Albert Johansson (will make the team this fall, but might be just a 7D)
Wallinder(will get the chance, but might be a bust)
Marco Kasper (will get the chance, but might be a bust)
Cossa (will get the chance, but might be a bust, like all goalies)
Augustine (will get the chance, but might be a bust, like all goalies)

Will probably never make the team on a regular basis
Söderblom (plays extremely soft and passive for a guy that size)
Buchelnikov (stuck in Russia)
Mazur (see Mitch Callahan)
Ryschlovsky (see Ilari Filppula)
Lombardi (see Taro Hirose)
Tuomisto, Viro, McIsaac, Hanas, Gettinger, Finnie (Nah)

Guys drafted this year = IDK
The finn traded from NAS = IDK

 

[Steve Yzerlland]

So Celebrini isn't a prospect? Cool.

Celebrini is on the Wings? What are you even trying to say dude?

 

[Pavels Dog]

Celebrini is on the Wings?

*the point*







*your head*

 

[Steve Yzerlland]

*the point*







*your head*

You have no point. Stop quoting me.

 

[lilidk]

Can't we just do one thread where we rank our top 10? It will be more accurate

And we should do it after development camp is over

 

[RRhoads]

And we should do it after development camp is over

Yeah, agreed.

 

[lilidk]

Danielson has everything to be our #1 prospect, but is he the one. Put him in NHL tomorrow and he will struggle. Kasper and MBN are NHL ready, can any of them be first line upside? New 20 year old guy or Buchelnikov or Plante could be something special. We don't know yet. But I know , you could play MBN tomorrow in NHL , so he's my choice

 

[Steve Yzerlland]

Danielson has everything to be our #1 prospect, but is he the one. Put him in NHL tomorrow and he will struggle. Kasper and MBN are NHL ready, can any of them be first line upside? New 20 year old guy or Buchelnikov or Plante could be something special. We don't know yet. But I know , you could play MBN tomorrow in NHL , so he's my choice

They will all be top 9 forwards max. I don't see any of them being stars unfortunately.

 

[ricky0034]

Danielson has everything to be our #1 prospect, but is he the one. Put him in NHL tomorrow and he will struggle. Kasper and MBN are NHL ready, can any of them be first line upside? New 20 year old guy or Buchelnikov or Plante could be something special. We don't know yet. But I know , you could play MBN tomorrow in NHL , so he's my choice

MBN wasn't even in the top Swedish league this year and you think he's ready to slot into the NHL tomorrow?

 

[lilidk]

MBN wasn't even in the top Swedish league this year and you think he's ready to slot into the NHL tomorrow?

He could easily replace Fabbri on fourth line.

 

[Holden Caufield]

ASP is gonna turn out to be better than Makar BOOK IT

I don’t know about that. Better then Danielson is a safe bet though. I have ASP as our #1.