Prospect Info: 2024 Ducks Prospect Rankings #2
- Thread starter MMC
- Start date
- Status
Ducks DVM
sowcufucakky
Since we are going for projection at this point, Luneau, because I’ll value a #1 RD over a top line wing.
Edit - stupid citrus autocorrect
Edit - stupid citrus autocorrect
Last edited:
Zellweger over Sennecke. I know he hasn't really been as good as he could become yet, but he still has the tools to become a stud.
Rooch
Registered User
- Jul 22, 2021
- 494
- 1,046
Zellweger for me as well. Sennecke's not as close physically. He'll need a couple of years to fill out that frame.
Yeah I think I'm going Zellweger here. Then a toss up between Luneau and Sennecke. Depends on Luneau's ability to recover from all that missed time but he showed really promising tools and game sense in his brief stint.
Hockey Duckie
Registered User
Based upon projections and potentials, I like Luneau over Sennecke at the moment. Luneau earned the QMJHL DotY while not having regained his burst in his D+1 season. If Luneau's workouts have improved his burst, then that's an added element to his potential.
Luneau was projected to be in the talent range of Korchinsi-Mintyukov-Mateychuk in his draft year. We don't know how high Luneau's ceiling could have been. We know that his mobility in his knee has recovered well enough to win DotY in the Q for his D+1 season. If Luneau can regain that initial burst in his skating due to continued training and added leg muscles, then we could have a different beast on our hands.
Luneau was projected to be in the talent range of Korchinsi-Mintyukov-Mateychuk in his draft year. We don't know how high Luneau's ceiling could have been. We know that his mobility in his knee has recovered well enough to win DotY in the Q for his D+1 season. If Luneau can regain that initial burst in his skating due to continued training and added leg muscles, then we could have a different beast on our hands.
I like Zelly at this point. He's NHL caliber already. Sennecke is a long ways away from reaching his ceiling, even though it's higher. I'd like to see some progress before he's moved up.
Dr Johnny Fever
Eggplant and Teal
Z2 for me. Sennecke is a long way from reaching the ceiling so many project for him. I certainly hope he gets there, but until he starts putting on muscle and showing progress toward that goal, I can't vote on ceiling alone.
Last edited:
MMC
Global Moderator
Arthuros
Registered Snoozer
Vaakou
Registered User
I mean it better be Sennecke, or they made a mistake.
Sennecke
Please add:
Colangelo
Pettersson
Sidorov
Dionico
Clara
Suchanek
After the top 5, it‘s really hard to rank the other prospects. All of the six above can be argued for a top-10-spot
Please add:
Colangelo
Pettersson
Sidorov
Dionico
Clara
Suchanek
After the top 5, it‘s really hard to rank the other prospects. All of the six above can be argued for a top-10-spot
Hockey Duckie
Registered User
MMC
Global Moderator
? I never told anyone not to post or vote or anyone, just think the discrepancy is funny
Goose of Reason
El Zilcho
- May 1, 2013
- 9,668
- 9,296
While i think it would be fair to give both Zell and Luneau consideration here, I think Sennecke's upside is ridiculous and have to go with him
Last edited:
GunnarStahl
Let’s go shake their hands
- Oct 13, 2020
- 2,072
- 2,888
I went Sennecke, high upside but margin of error for his final product is still very high.
The next vote is where it gets really tough. Luneau, Solberg, and Zellweger are all kinda neck and neck for me.
Luneau might have taken the lead if his year went how it should have. Show promise in his NHL stint, be a leader for team Canada and likely their best Dman. Go to Q and lead a team on a playoffs run. Unfortunately his year got cut short and it’s hard to tell what the fallout will be. That’s further hampered by the fact he has had hurdles in his development previous. He’s one of those players where the potential is so obvious but circumstances have held him back.
Zellweger has done just about everything he can to prove himself but the size does still raise questions. And that’s not to say he can’t be an impact players, more so, how much of one. And what does his playoff performance look like. Is he going to be a Sam Girard or a Quinn Hughes/Jared Spurgeon.
And then Solberg is exactly what this team needs and every team covets. Might not ever win a Norris or even be a go to PP1 guy, but there is some offensive room for growth in his game and he will anchor a PK and keep net fronts clear. His game is still a bit raw but some time in a more reputable pro league will do wonders.
The next vote is where it gets really tough. Luneau, Solberg, and Zellweger are all kinda neck and neck for me.
Luneau might have taken the lead if his year went how it should have. Show promise in his NHL stint, be a leader for team Canada and likely their best Dman. Go to Q and lead a team on a playoffs run. Unfortunately his year got cut short and it’s hard to tell what the fallout will be. That’s further hampered by the fact he has had hurdles in his development previous. He’s one of those players where the potential is so obvious but circumstances have held him back.
Zellweger has done just about everything he can to prove himself but the size does still raise questions. And that’s not to say he can’t be an impact players, more so, how much of one. And what does his playoff performance look like. Is he going to be a Sam Girard or a Quinn Hughes/Jared Spurgeon.
And then Solberg is exactly what this team needs and every team covets. Might not ever win a Norris or even be a go to PP1 guy, but there is some offensive room for growth in his game and he will anchor a PK and keep net fronts clear. His game is still a bit raw but some time in a more reputable pro league will do wonders.
Sennecke's potential and upside is too much to ignore. Gauthier #1 and Sennecke #2. IMO, Zellweger/Luneau are the clear #3-4. I think there's a strong argument for both. Zellweger just keeps proving himself and it's hard to ignore. Luneau plays that coveted position of RD and has so much potential, but injury issues.
Without injuries, Luneau for sure. But with how well Zellweger played in the NHL at the end of the season, I think he edges Luneau out until he has a chance to prove himself again. Although, I can be convinced to go the other way if someone has a good enough argument before next vote.
1) Gauthier
2) Sennecke
3) Zellweger
4) Luneau
Without injuries, Luneau for sure. But with how well Zellweger played in the NHL at the end of the season, I think he edges Luneau out until he has a chance to prove himself again. Although, I can be convinced to go the other way if someone has a good enough argument before next vote.
1) Gauthier
2) Sennecke
3) Zellweger
4) Luneau
WhatTheDuck
9 - 20 - 8
I was all set to decide between Zell and Luneau but then I got watching development camp videos...
FiveTacos
Registered User
Wait I thought pornhub took all those "development camp videos" down.
No kink shaming here though. This is a safe space. Carry on!
- Jul 25, 2012
- 41,409
- 37,490
MMC
Global Moderator
Can’t say I understand people having Luneau over Zellweger
- Status
Ad
Latest posts
-
-
-
Confirmed Trade: [BUF/EDM] Ryan McLeod and Tyler Tullio for Matt Savoie
- Latest: Hasekperreault23
-
Upcoming events
-
-
Wimbledon Gentlemen's SEMIFINAL - Daniil Medvedev vs Carlos AlcarazWagers: 5Staked: $6,537.00Event closes- Updated:
-
Wimbledon Gentlemen's SEMIFINAL - Lorenzo Musetti vs Novak DjokovicWagers: 3Staked: $3,797.00Event closes
- Updated:
-
BET ON ONLY ONE HORSE WATCH LIVE - SARATOGA RACE 1 - FS2Wagers: 1Staked: $200.00Event closes- Updated:
-