Prospect Info: [2024 - 5th] Ivan Motherbleeping Demidov (RW), SKA St. Petersburg (MHL)

[Kudo Shinichi]

This is why I never understood why "Scouts/GMs" get accolades for obvious no brainers... i mean if there is something Hugo actually did to make Demidov fall to #5 then I stand corrected, otherwise any Russian and his pet bear could have made that selection.
This is not the same as making the Rainmkr pick, that was GMing. Demidov is in a different stratosphere (as it relates to Habs core) vs Michkov, sure their skill might wow us equally but Demi has the personality that works in MTL.

That makes no sense. If the habs had drafted Michkov, you wouldve said it was a no brainer. If you were a ducks, jackets, or hawks fan, you wouldve said that Demidov was a no brainer at their pick. Yet, those teams passed on him.

The fact of the matter is there's a lot more that goes into picking a player than just looking at their upside.

From the last few drafts, Bedard and Celebrini were the only complete no brainer picks. There weren't any argument for not picking them. For Demidov and others, there were arguments to not pick them.

 

[themilosh]

That makes no sense. If the habs had drafted Michkov, you wouldve said it was a no brainer. If you were a ducks, jackets, or hawks fan, you wouldve said that Demidov was a no brainer at their pick. Yet, those teams passed on him.

The fact of the matter is there's a lot more that goes into picking a player than just looking at their upside.

As it relates to our team and needs.. CHI was 50/50 could have gone either way.. Levshunov is a stud 1RD very rare.
Anaheim is the surprise but i understand their logic as it relates to their needs. Remember, US teams face a lot more public scrutiny for "Russians" bc of the war (it's something to consider).
CLB clearly valued the big hulking 1C (though more volatile).

What other player could the Habs have taken here (instead of Demi)? Tij, Buium?

Ps. I didn't want Michkov.. so im happy with Reinbacher..

 

[Habssince89]

Demidov on the other hand has what I’d classify as two elite traits (hands, vision) and then even his lesser traits are still good to great (good size, good to great skating and shot)… from a pure trait perspective he’s gotta be one of the highest graded guys I’ve seen enter the draft (Celebrini pretty similar this year).

well said. I would add that the lesser traits are technical (shot, skating) and its not unreasonable for those tools to improve. His Hands and Vision are unreal.

 

[Kudo Shinichi]

As it relates to our team and needs.. CHI was 50/50 could have gone either way.. Levshunov is a stud 1RD very rare.
Anaheim is the surprise but i understand their logic as it relates to their needs. Remember, US teams face a lot more public scrutiny for "Russians" bc of the war (it's something to consider).
CLB clearly valued the big hulking 1C (though more volatile).

What other player could the Habs have taken here (instead of Demi)? Tij, Buium?

Ps. I didn't want Michkov.. so im happy with Reinbacher..

None of those are good reasons to pass on Demidov from a fan pov. Why is Chicago, who has good depth on D and very little at forward, passing on the perfect partner for Bedard?

Why is Anaheim reaching for a less good and risker prospect just because he's right handed instead of left handed?

Why is Columbus passing on a potential Kucherov for a player with back problem?

If the habs had passed on Demidov, the narrative would've been that Demidov presented too much risks (re-signing in Russia, having only played against low level competition, not many players had success in the nhl with his skating style, etc.), and there were safer player with good upside available (Iginla, Catton, Dickinson, Buium). You can make up plenty of reasons for passing on a player...

 

[HabsWhiteKnightLOL]

people are still shocked we drafted a potential superstar forward , they forgot how it feels

it's alright , next season everyone will be happy

#Demichad

 

[Spearmint Rhino]

Spent the last hour drinking Old Fashions and watching Demidov highlights

Haven’t had a feeling like this watching a show on TV since I saw Wild Things for the first time

 

[Guess]

Ivan Demidov - A dynamic superstar

A Demigod amongst men

sammcgilligan.substack.com

Leaving this here as it deals with my favourite part of demidov’s game, his skating style. I can’t wait to see it game after game. It explains why demidov is the first prospect to perfect the “Mohawk” skating style and why:

“if it all works out, he can push whatever team he plays for down a path that may just change the game forever.”

Speaking of, that same blogger made a post where he had Michkov falling due to big worries in his game:

The Conundrum of Matvei Michkov

 

[Twisted Sinister]

Spent the last hour drinking Old Fashions and watching Demidov highlights

Haven’t had a feeling like this watching a show on TV since I saw Wild Things for the first time

A man of culture I see.

 

[Habs Halifax]

Wait what? Who deserves credit is BS? Weren't you the one who posted the comparison between MB and KH? And made it a competition by saying KH is now winning by selecting Demidov?!? lol

C'mon man.

And nope, I wouldn't call HuGo geniuses for selecting Demidov. That's which they were supposed to pick at #5 if he was available. Just like MB with Caufield.

It's simple. It's a list of players acquired by each GM. Sorry, I don't buy the "credit" thingy by saying he shouldn't get credit for drafting Caufield.

 

[Kennerback]

This is why I never understood why "Scouts/GMs" get accolades for obvious no brainers... i mean if there is something Hugo actually did to make Demidov fall to #5 then I stand corrected, otherwise any Russian and his pet bear could have made that selection.
This is not the same as making the Rainmkr pick, that was GMing. Demidov is in a different stratosphere (as it relates to Habs core) vs Michkov, sure their skill might wow us equally but Demi has the personality that works in MTL.

There’s luck involved for sure. In the two draft we picked 3OA, there was no elite forward available at our picks even if with the benefit of hindsight we picked the best. We got Galchenyuk and KK. The others available were Hertl, Forsberg and Brady Tkachuk. Tkachuk would have been a much better pick but he’s more in the Slafkovsky Power Forward mold. Not an elite skilled forward.

How much was Hugo’s decision gamesmanship? Was it only luck? As regards elite forwards, we’ve had no luck for 53 years at the draft table. As a fan I don’t care how smart and shrewd the draft teams have been. I never had all their data when they make their picks. Not getting the job done, they get judged harshly. Conversely, positive vibes follow getting that elite forward.

 

[DAChampion]

This is why I never understood why "Scouts/GMs" get accolades for obvious no brainers... i mean if there is something Hugo actually did to make Demidov fall to #5 then I stand corrected, otherwise any Russian and his pet bear could have made that selection.
This is not the same as making the Rainmkr pick, that was GMing. Demidov is in a different stratosphere (as it relates to Habs core) vs Michkov, sure their skill might wow us equally but Demi has the personality that works in MTL.

If Demidov was such an obvious choice he wouldn't have been available at #5, so yes if he does well in a few years HuGo will deserve the credit.

 

[HabzSauce]

I go to bed thinking about Demigod, I wake up thinking about demigod, and now I'm dreaming about demigod. Had a great dream lol all I remember is him walking into the arena in an all white suite with a white hat, eating a slice of pizza. There was a big game going on but I forget what happened - was mad hype though.

More I watch and read about him, more hyped I get. I genuinely think this guy will surpass expectations as crazy as that sounds. We're all talking about his all world skill but for me it's also his mentality and compete that will make him one of the best players in the whole league. That combo of skill and drive is SO rare these days, even in other sports. He's perfect

His floor is superstar and ceiling is franchise player. Going all in with the hype on this guy

 

[Habs Halifax]

Been waiting since the Kovalev and then Subban era for this, feels like a new era when we get to see Demidov and Hutson play.
Hopefully the Habs market these guys well.

Habs fans right now after adding Demidov. I dare you say our pool lacks quality now!

 

[crosbyshow]

Imagine the power play guys in 2 years.....!!!!

-Hutson as the chief orchestra
-Demidov on the right circle as a great passer and he is lefty

- Caufield on the left side for one timer

- Suzuki at the goal red line on the left side like this year.

- Slaf at bumper or Dach but I can see Slaf cause he will be also a presence in front of the net.


In French we say...: Le puck va se promener en calvaire!!!


I can see a top 5 pp in the league !!

 

[CaptnNemo]

I go to bed thinking about Demigod, I wake up thinking about demigod, and now I'm dreaming about demigod. Had a great dream lol all I remember is him walking into the arena in an all white suite with a white hat, eating a slice of pizza. There was a big game going on but I forget what happened - was mad hype though.

More I watch and read about him, more hyped I get. I genuinely think this guy will surpass expectations as crazy as that sounds. We're all talking about his all world skill but for me it's also his mentality and compete that will make him one of the best players in the whole league. That combo of skill and drive is SO rare these days, even in other sports. He's perfect

His floor is superstar and ceiling is franchise player. Going all in with the hype on this guy

I agree..I dream about this everyday and can foresee him being more than we expect and even more than other team's fans expect.

I would dare to say that with the way HuGo are building this team...I can see us winning the cup 3-4 times in the next 10 to 12 years

Maybe a damn good dream or I'm way off but nonetheless it makes me really happy and positive right now and that's what's important! Loll

 

[salbutera]

There are numerous variables involved - Demigod isn’t a Verbeek type of player, Hawks desperately need a top pairing RD prospect, Sens are very weary of drafting NCAA players given recent history of exercising clout which puts small Cdn markets at more peril. Then there’s the whole owner factor.

It only took 10-years to reveal, Edm scouts absolutely wanted nothing to do with Yakupov but were overruled by their owner …

 

[Jaynki]

Such a treat to restudy Demidov now with the knowledge that he’s ours. The thing that really stands out is how great his tools are across the board. I’ve graded a lot of players over the years, and usually guys (talking first rounders here) have maybe one elite trait, and then are generally average elsewhere, or they are kind of above average across the board but lacking a standout trait.

Demidov on the other hand has what I’d classify as two elite traits (hands, vision) and then even his lesser traits are still good to great (good size, good to great skating and shot)… from a pure trait perspective he’s gotta be one of the highest graded guys I’ve seen enter the draft (Celebrini pretty similar this year).

That all said, it really is hard to project guys beyond who they share the ice with and the fact he was stuck in Russia makes stat projections difficult.

But to me though I’d feel pretty confident projecting him as a top line ppg winger and if things really come together he could be even better than that.

It’s honestly gonna be a long year lol can’t wait until he’s making his debut my god it will be electric.

His skating, precisely his mohawk or 10-2 style is also not only elite, but also unique, in the same way that Bedard release is. I have notice that it open the plays like i have rarely seen in the o-zone but also gives a sincere edge in the d-zone and in board battle.

 

[Jaynki]

There are numerous variables involved - Demigod isn’t a Verbeek type of player,

By wanting to go big brain, Verbeek showed us that he was the most stupid man in the room.

May they enjoy Sennecke.

KK level blunder.

Imagine having a type of player and letting franchise talent go away.

Who can sincerely and genuinely watch Demidov and say he is not my type of player?

Its a complete non-sense.

Has good size. He is gritty, gives an excellent two way effort and fight like a dog in the corner. Thats on top of displaying absolute elite talent.

Its more about that they havent scouted him live and havent met him and they p***yed out.

 

[Skip Bayless]

Is there any NHL potential with Demidov's linemate Romanov? Watching highlights it seems they have pretty good chemistry but at 19 he is on the older side for the MHL.

He sticks out in a good way on those highlights.

 

[Nico Cauzuki]

If Habs makes the playoffs we can see him this season

 

[zzoo]

Not sure how true is this: I've heard that Demidov is only the 2nd player that gets 2 ppg in MHL. The first player is Gusev who accomplished that at age of 20, and with help of a young Kucherov.

Only 2 players having 2 ppg in MHL history !

 

[salbutera]

By wanting to go big brain, Verbeek showed us that he was the most stupid man in the room.

May they enjoy Sennecke.

KK level blunder.

Imagine having a type of player and letting franchise talent go away.

Who can sincerely and genuinely watch Demidov and say he is not my type of player?

Its a complete non-sense.

Has good size. He is gritty, gives an excellent two way effort and fight like a dog in the corner. Thats on top of displaying absolute elite talent.

Its more about that they havent scouted him live and havent met him and they p***yed out.

Not really… little ball of hate like Zito in Fla likes smash mouth hockey vs pousse caca ballerina style and needs players who embody that style & philosophy to be successful. That’s all.

There isn’t one way to construct a winning roster or win the Cup…

Also the picks of Sennecke & Solberg should once and for all explain why Zegras MAY potentially be available….

 

[CaptnNemo]

If Habs makes the playoffs we can see him this season

I believe he needs to have played 10 reg season games like Cole did in the last playoffs

Unless SKA falls short in the season or gets eliminated fast in their playoffs or for some other reasons I think he can't make it to 10

 

[Jaynki]

Not really… little ball of hate like Zito in Fla likes smash mouth hockey vs pousse caca ballerina style and needs players who embody that style & philosophy to be successful. That’s all.

There isn’t one way to construct a winning roster or win the Cup…

I understand and agree with your point.

Where i disagree, is when you imply that Demidov is a caca ballerina style.

I will link you one of his KHL game. Watch him forecheck, challenge the D and fight in the corner.

 

[Gally11]

Not really… little ball of hate like Zito in Fla likes smash mouth hockey vs pousse caca ballerina style and needs players who embody that style & philosophy to be successful. That’s all.

There isn’t one way to construct a winning roster or win the Cup…

Also the picks of Sennecke & Solberg should once and for all explain why Zegras MAY potentially be available….

There’s one way to mess up drafting though and it’s going for need vs BPA as we’ve learned lol