Prospect Info: [2024 - 5th] Ivan Motherbleeping Demidov (RW), SKA St. Petersburg (MHL)

Tyson

Registered User
Mar 1, 2007
50,236
73,000
Texas
How entitled are you people? Good lord. Rotenberg should be trying to get him to stay, that's part of any GM/coaches job in any league.

But ultimately these guys will go to the NHL, as they should. Nobobys stopping them. All guys from SKA in recent years go to the NHL (Marchenko, Michkov, Askarov, Shestyorkin, Kuzmenko, Podkolzin, Groshev, Khusnutdinov, etc. etc.). Nikishin and Gritsyuk will leave after this year too.
What makes us entitled? We are fans who want our guy over sooner rather than later.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HabbyGuy and BLONG7

417

When the going gets tough...
Feb 20, 2003
52,487
30,390
Ottawa
How are we entitled? He has never shown any interest in staying in the KHL. He’s just there because he has to be there.

If anyone is entitled it’s Rotenberg with the way he talks about the AHL as if the star players are attacked every single game and they should worry for their lives. He’s full of shit and trying to publicly scare a kid into staying.

To say he needs to be a KHL 1st liner before going to the NHL 1st line is stupid. He’s not going to be a 1st liner here on Day 1, why would that be the expectation?
He's obviously laying it on thick, but probably isn't too far from the truth.

There's really no point for Demidov to leave the KHL to go play in the AHL from their perspective.
 

Zine

Registered User
Feb 28, 2002
12,362
2,480
How are we entitled? He has never shown any interest in staying in the KHL. He’s just there because he has to be there.

If anyone is entitled it’s Rotenberg with the way he talks about the AHL as if the star players are attacked every single game and they should worry for their lives. He’s full of shit and trying to publicly scare a kid into staying.

To say he needs to be a KHL 1st liner before going to the NHL 1st line is stupid. He’s not going to be a 1st liner here on Day 1, why would that be the expectation?

'Entitlement' meaning fans thinking they have exclusive ownership to a player.,,,and anything other than "get him to "Montreal ASAP!" is treated as something nefarious or shady. It's ridiculous.

I'm hardly a fan of RoRo, but what he's doing is normal. Every GM tries to get their best players to stay, especially young ones.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 417

le_sean

Registered User
Oct 21, 2006
42,051
45,265
'Entitlement' meaning fans thinking they have exclusive ownership to a player.,,,and anything other than "get him to "Montreal ASAP!" is treated as something nefarious, stupid, or shady. It's ridiculous.

I'm hardly a fan of RoRo, but what he's doing is normal. Every GM tries to get their best players to stay, especially young ones.
But we don’t claim ownership. He himself has the right to play out his current contract and go elsewhere without having someone trying to scare him otherwise.

He's obviously laying it on thick, but probably isn't too far from the truth.

There's really no point for Demidov to leave the KHL to go play in the AHL from their perspective.
There’s zero shot he would play in the AHL. I don’t even know why he brought it up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rapala

417

When the going gets tough...
Feb 20, 2003
52,487
30,390
Ottawa
There’s zero shot he would play in the AHL. I don’t even know why he brought it up.
I don't know if there's zero chance but regardless, i'm sure they'd love to keep him, so whatever PR stunt they can pull between now and then, i'm sure they'll use.

No biggie.
 

Zine

Registered User
Feb 28, 2002
12,362
2,480
But we don’t claim ownership. He himself has the right to play out his current contract and go elsewhere without having someone trying to scare him otherwise.

Higher level hockey is a multi-million dollar business. Leagues, teams, agents are always trying to influence players. It's typical.

That you feel the need to use the word "scare" just proves my point. Like someone said, Rotenberg is laying it on a bit thick, but what he's telling Demidov is no different than what tons of players hear all the time..... and probably worse behind closed doors. I mean I can only imagine the NCAA recruiting process.
"This league is great! That league sucks!" You should do this! You're developminet will stall there!"
 
Last edited:

le_sean

Registered User
Oct 21, 2006
42,051
45,265
Higher level hockey is a multi-million dollar business. Leagues, teams, agents are always trying to influence players. It's typical.

That you feel the need to use the word "scare" just proves my point. Like someone said, Rotenberg is laying it on a bit thick, but what he's telling Demidov is no different than what tons of players hear all the time.
"This league is great! That league sucks!" You should do this! You shouldn't do that!"
A bit thick? Who was the last star player in the AHL to have his limbs broken on purpose?
 

le_sean

Registered User
Oct 21, 2006
42,051
45,265
Do you hear/read the kinds of things NA's say about the KHL?

it's really no different.
In what context though? Quality of the league? I’m not sure what we are referring to here. The only thing I see that is said is preferential treatment for certain players which seems to be true.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: ryan callahan

Kennerback

Registered User
Jun 2, 2021
4,290
6,158
How entitled are you people? Good lord. Rotenberg should be trying to get him to stay, that's part of any GM/coaches job in any league.

But ultimately these guys will go to the NHL, as they should. Nobobys stopping them. All guys from SKA in recent years go to the NHL (Marchenko, Michkov, Askarov, Shestyorkin, Kuzmenko, Podkolzin, Groshev, Khusnutdinov, etc. etc.). Nikishin and Gritsyuk will leave after this year too.
Entitled here speaking. He’s awesome! I’m very selfish. I want to see NOW in Montreal!
 

417

When the going gets tough...
Feb 20, 2003
52,487
30,390
Ottawa
In what context though? Quality of the league? I’m not sure what we are referring to here. The only thing I see that is said is preferential treatment for certain players which seems to be true.
Everything!

Fans and members of the media, regularly trash the KHL and the quality of its teams or how the KHL operates as a whole.
 

Kennerback

Registered User
Jun 2, 2021
4,290
6,158
KHL players and hockey are high quality but the league organization has a dubious reputation. It comes partly from the fact the profit structure is different. A big chunk of financing comes from third party sponsorship. And then there’s stories of players being paid with a wad of cash out of the owner’s pockets.
 

Zine

Registered User
Feb 28, 2002
12,362
2,480
This.

His development is of utmost importance, and not to be messed with due to other agendas. This is a huge year for Ivan's growth.

His development won't be messed with, just like Michkov's wasn't. Rotenberg can be a dick, but he won't screw up Demidov's development. Demidov will get his minutes albeit KHL somewhere or VHL.
 

HabbyGuy

Registered User
Apr 10, 2003
7,775
13,045
Hamilton Ontario
Visit site
His development won't be messed with, just like Michkov's wasn't. Rotenberg can be a dick, but he won't screw up Demidov's development. Demidov will get his minutes albeit KHL somewhere or VHL.

Michkov was able to play in the KHL which was better for his development because they loaned him to another team. (something they can't do with Ivan) Demidov playing in the VHL is not ideal or the same at all.
 

The Last Red

Registered User
Jan 2, 2022
1,544
1,742
His development won't be messed with, just like Michkov's wasn't. Rotenberg can be a dick, but he won't screw up Demidov's development. Demidov will get his minutes albeit KHL somewhere or VHL.
Yeah, I'm not really too worried about it. He'll be fine, wherever he ends up playing this season.
 

Kennerback

Registered User
Jun 2, 2021
4,290
6,158
His development won't be messed with, just like Michkov's wasn't. Rotenberg can be a dick, but he won't screw up Demidov's development. Demidov will get his minutes albeit KHL somewhere or VHL.
Russian players in NA have thrashed Rottenberg. So it’s hard to know what’s true and what’s not. SKA’s best interest is not always Habs best interest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jrom and HabbyGuy

JIMVINNY

Registered User
Nov 9, 2007
721
294
His development won't be messed with, just like Michkov's wasn't. Rotenberg can be a dick, but he won't screw up Demidov's development. Demidov will get his minutes albeit KHL somewhere or VHL.
There are a lot of Habs fans that see how SKA has treated young players in the past, and are rightly concerned. Rotenberg has demonstrated that he's unwilling to give players like Demidov the chance to play top line minutes, even if they've more than shown that they deserve it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HabbyGuy

Zine

Registered User
Feb 28, 2002
12,362
2,480
Michkov was able to play in the KHL which was better for his development because they loaned him to another team. (something they can't do with Ivan) Demidov playing in the VHL is not ideal or the same at all.

The VHL is fine. As long as he's playing against men.

I don't think he's quite NHL ready just yet. As such, if he was born in Quebec he's be sent to the CHL, which isn't as good as the VHL. Nobody would think twice about that.
 

HabbyGuy

Registered User
Apr 10, 2003
7,775
13,045
Hamilton Ontario
Visit site
The VHL is fine. As long as he's playing against men.

I don't think he's quite NHL ready just yet. As such, if he was born in Quebec he's be sent to the CHL, which isn't as good as the VHL. Nobody would think twice about that.

He's may not be NHL ready, but he's KHL ready. That's the point. He's also AHL ready over the CHL. If born in Quebec if not ready for Montreal he'd be in Laval.

To be honest I'm not even sure the habs wouldn't keep him up like they did Slaf, who knows. Either way he'd be wasted in the CHL in my opinion.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Rapala

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad