I think a common theme with Sweeney's UFA signings is they're almost always too long. Backes was good deal cap hit wise initially but was a year or two too long for term. John Moore was way too long; 5 years for a bottom pairing d-man? Mike Reilly's was too long, should've been a one year extension since he was clearly the last option for the blue line after they couldn't land an upgrade. Ullmark's deal looking like it was a year too long, should've lined it up better with Swayman's RFA status. Could keep going.Gryz was never a FA, and honestly was probably underpaid for half his contract, as much as he frustrated me.
I was of course thinking the Belesky, Backes and arguably Foligno (although he probably played close to value his second year). Not sure what we learn from these, Belesky certainly calls out the concern of overpaying for that one year wonder . Backes and Foligno bring concerns around overpaying for character/heavy game in older players