Signing the contract was fine.
The only thing I objected to was the idea that anyone could reasonably predict this kind of scoring and/or using it as evidence of a sound process. But now I also object to the “at worst he’ll be a key player on LHV” take. Because we have to get carried away with everything for some reason. He could turn back into a pumpkin at any point. You won’t hear me hold that against them if he does.
You can say that for virtually any player, all it takes is one injury . . .
Now the harder call is whether a player is progressing or it's just an outlier season, b/c they generally look the same, especially over SSS.
I didn't take Gaucher seriously earlier in the season, but the last two games I saw, the Gaucher line with Lycksell and Wisdom passed the eyeball test. In the AHL, my basic test is if I watch a game, does the player look like one of the best players on the ice. If I have to look for his number, meh.
Of course, if you could predict the small number of marginal prospects who will turn out to be late bloomers, they'd get drafted much higher.