Blue Jays Discussion: 2024-25 Off-season: The free agent watch begins (and sometimes old baseball radio broadcasts)

[Hellcat]

No, I am suggesting that every other team you listed employed an inferior player as their primary CF. Judge was the runaway MVP and best player in the AL.

They employed inferior hitter's?

The lineup is a sum of its parts, lets say you accept that Varsho is a black hole inthe lineup but his defence so so elite, where he hurts you in the line up , his field far otweight's it. You keep Varsho at CF, how do you improve RF and LF production? Cause you cant have Varsho, Springer and Loperfido as our starting 3 and expect to compete for a championship.

Do you happen to know what any of those stats mean?

Yep.

The average OPS for an MLB CF was .708 in 2024. Varsho was at .700.

We have lots of holes on our team, but CF is not one.

Average OPS for an outfield was?

 

[Bjindaho]

They employed inferior hitter's?

The lineup is a sum of its parts, lets say you accept that Varsho is a black hole inthe lineup but his defence so so elite, where he hurts you in the line up , his field far otweight's it. You keep Varsho at CF, how do you improve RF and LF production? Cause you cant have Varsho, Springer and Loperfido as our starting 3 and expect to compete for a championship.



Yep.



Average OPS for an outfield was?

I don't think anyone disagrees with that.

In a perfect world, the outfield is something like bopper - Varsho - Springer so that it improves.

 

[Hellcat]

Judge only started in CF because their best CF (Grisham) couldn't hit anything. Even a semi-competent hitting CF means that Judge and Soto are the corner OF.

Sounds like the same problem the jays have a CF that couldn't hit for shit.

I don't think anyone disagrees with that.

In a perfect world, the outfield is something like bopper - Varsho - Springer so that it improves.

Springers best years are behind him, he is on the downhill slope of his career, he is no longer a top of the lineup player. So Bopper - Varsho- Bopper .. where are those boppers and how much do we spend on them?

 

[Discoverer]

With a reminder that Varsho had a .700 OPS this year while being the best defensive OF in the game:

In Game 5 of the World Series, with their season on the line, the Yankees had Torres and his .708 OPS in the leadoff spot. Then they had a 6-9 of:

Rizzo at .636
Volpe at .657
Wells at .717
Verdugo at .647

So don't try to tell us how Varsho would be a 4th OF on a contender because he would have been the starting CF and likely hitting 6th or 7th in the lineup of the World Series runner up.

The Jays need better bats at other positions so they can move Varsho further down in the lineup. They don't need a new player at a position where they already have a very good one.

 

[trellaine201]

Agreed. Need to shelter him at the bottom.

 

[Woodman19]

Why not sign Soto for two years at bonkers money. He would still be at an age for a large salary.

Unless bonkers is $600 million for 2 years I don't see any way it's to his benefit to take that deal.

 

[MK78]

Unless bonkers is $600 million for 2 years I don't see any way it's to his benefit to take that deal.

Exactly, he can suffer a career ending injury at any time. He's at a prime age for a huge long term contract, and he'll get it. I don't see anything under 10 years, and it's likely to be much longer in order to lower the AAV, and front loaded so at the back end it doesnt hurt as much when he will not be nowhere near as productive.

 

[Discoverer]

Exactly, he can suffer a career ending injury at any time. He's at a prime age for a huge long term contract, and he'll get it. I don't see anything under 10 years, and it's likely to be much longer in order to lower the AAV, and front loaded so at the back end it doesnt hurt as much when he will not be nowhere near as productive.

If anything, it's likely to be back loaded.

 

[Tony Romo]

Sounds like the same problem the jays have a CF that couldn't hit for shit.



Springers best years are behind him, he is on the downhill slope of his career, he is no longer a top of the lineup player. So Bopper - Varsho- Bopper .. where are those boppers and how much do we spend on them?

.. do you know how much it would cost to upgrade from Varsho in CF? It’s much easier to get a corner OF that can mash.

 

[MS]

.225 was average?

Take a look at his percentile rankings and tell me he was average: https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/savant-player/daulton-varsho-662139?stats=statcast-r-hitting-mlb

f*** me, I can't believe people are still posting stuff like this in 2024.

Varsho is a starter for basically every team in baseball. It isn't even debatable. He's a league-average hitter and the best fielder in the game at a premium position.

 

[canucksfan]

Varsho is a better player than Pillar was when he was with the Jays. Pillar was a fan favorite and Varsho doesn't get the appreciation he deserves. In some cases, he's called a garbage player or a fourth outfielder. Varsho gets treated unfairly because of the trade and bats too high in the lineup. As others have said, he should be batting around 7th like Pillar was.

 

[MK78]

Varsho is a better player than Pillar was when he was with the Jays. Pillar was a fan favorite and Varsho doesn't get the appreciation he deserves. In some cases, he's called a garbage player or a fourth outfielder. Varsho gets treated unfairly because of the trade and bats too high in the lineup. As others have said, he should be batting around 7th like Pillar was.

From what I remember of Pillar, that he wasn't a great outfielder and he had to make up for it with those spectacular dives which he was very good at. A great outfielder can simply run and catch them most of the time without diving or jumping.

The wall climb was epic though.

 

[MS]

From what I remember of Pillar, that he wasn't a great outfielder and he had to make up for it with those spectacular dives which he was very good at. A great outfielder can simply run and catch them most of the time without diving or jumping.

The wall climb was epic though.

Pillar was worth 7.7 dWAR from 2015-2017. He was legitimately outstanding and would have won multiple Gold Gloves if he didn't have to go up against prime Kevin Kiermaier who is probably a top 5 defensive CF of all time.

 

[Discoverer]

From what I remember of Pillar, that he wasn't a great outfielder and he had to make up for it with those spectacular dives which he was very good at. A great outfielder can simply run and catch them most of the time without diving or jumping.

The wall climb was epic though.

Pillar was absolutely one of the best defensive OF in baseball for 2-3 years, but I don't think he was on Varsho's level. He was probably flashier for the reasons you pointed out, but Varsho just gets to EVERYTHING.