I'm surprised Vogt was AL Manager of the Year. His job was too easy, to steady the ship after Francona retired. He had a stacked roster given to him. Cleveland was never seriously threatened for the AL Central and routinely wins the division.
Meanwhile the Tigers had a single digit chance of making the postseason midway throughout the regular season and got so hot they snuck into the ALDS and even won a wild card round. AJ Hinsch should have been AL Manager of the Year by a mile over any other candidate.
Cleveland had a stacked roster? In what world? Most everyone expected them to be a barely .500 team. Our Opening Day lineup featured world-beater Ramon Laureano in RF and Tyler Freeman in CF. Our other right field and center field options on Opening Day included Estevan Florial, Will Brennan, and Gabriel Arias. Exactly one of them (Brennan) was on the roster at the end of the season.
We lost our ace (Bieber) to TJ surgery after two starts. Two other members of our OD rotation ended the season in the minors due to struggles (McKenzie and Logan Allen).
But please, tell me more about this stacked roster. This post is a perfect example of box score and Twitter watching and nothing else.