Right now I'd like to look at the Comets roster for next season based upon the current roster.
On D:
Misyul and Vilen will still be on ELCs
Hatakka and Vukojevic will be RFAs.
Unless the Devils are crazy and do some wild shit, these 4 likely return to Utica.
Wotherspoon becomes a UFA and I believe he has aged out of the reason for NJ to re-sign him. He will only be 31, but he has become too slow, coughs up the puck a lot, has become a weak passer., and there must be somebody younger to give a NJ contract. If MacKinnon works to re-sign him to an AHL deal it would mean no other NHL team has any interest either. The deal would be a 1-way AHL deal like Russo's.
Robbie Russo is in exactly the same boat as Wotherspoon except he is already on an 1-yr 1-way AHL contract. That could mean he'd be willing to sign for another year. MacKinnon loves to re-up guys who are already here as it saves the problem of having to hunt for new blood. That could mean we see Russo and Wotherspoon for another season when the Comets would be better served by younger players. They would fill veteran roles on AHL salaries. That would suck. The veteran contracts should go to more talented and preferably younger guys.
Cal Foote becomes an RFA at the end of this season and will turn 26 in December and is arbitration eligible. His qualifying offer is $997,500. I can't see where he has proven he deserves a new NHL 2-way beyond this ammount if the Devils are interested. He also will be a vet just like othersppon and Russo. They could simply not offer to qualify him and let him walk. He's up in the air as of now.
Right now it's Hatakka, Misyul, Vilen, and Vukojevic.
Foote is an arbitration eligible RFA. They probably give him a year to help the Comets younger guys.
Wotherespoon, Russo, and Foote are on the ledge. Keeping 3 vets on D is not the way to go. 2 should be the max and combine them with 4 forwards.
I don't see MacKinnon as a valuable commodity beyond what he got this year, a 2-way AHL deal where he is assigned to Adirondack.
In Goal:
Kallgren will be a UFA and I don't see any reason to re-sign him.
Schmid and Daws are RFAs and Schmid is arbitration eligible. I don't know what their plans are, but if neither is traded, I see both getting new contracts with the Devils. Who, if either, is in Utica I don't know.
After seeing how things went this season, I'd get Poulter under contract. At worst he is the Comets best bet for backup.
Brennan should be in the Adirondack regualr rotation. If he can't step in and become #1 or 1A there he shouldn't be considered for the AHL. He has only managed 5 starts in Adirondack thus far this season. Staying healthy should be the #1 goal for his future at the moment. Anything else would be gravy.
DIDN'T MEAN TO POST THIS YET. THE FORWARDS ARE LAST FOR THIS POST.
The Prospects:
The only forward prospects on the roster this sesaon are Clarke and Stillman. Both will still be on ELCs. I don't anticipater either cracking the NHL roster. Unless either or both are involved in trades, they will be Comets.
Halonen was signed out of college so he is actually a prospect. He becomes an RFA at season's end so I expect he will get a new contract. and get assigned to Utica.
Also on NJ contracts:
Durandeau will also be an RFA. He has been very good for Utica thus far, 8Pts/10 GP. He will be below the veteran number of games played. He would be a good guy to hold onto if he stays this hot. His overall AHL production is at .63 PPG as of today.
Dowling is already signed for next year. He will be back and will be a veteran.
Criscuolo has been nearly a PPG player for the Comets thus far, 22 Pts in 25 GP. He is a Veteran. He will be a UFA. I'd think seriously about him if he keeps up this pace.
Willman 16 Pts/20 GP will still not be a vet.
Bowers is under contract, but has not produced at the pace that makes him valuable to re-sign, 7 Pts/29 GP. I'd pass on him.
Laberge was given a 1yr-2 -way NHL contract after the season began. I doubt the Devils give hi m another. MacKinnon may offer him another AHL deal. I don't see any other NHL teams getting into a bidding war for his services. He won't have vet status. He likes it here and it's not like the money will be bigger elsewhere. I'd guess he's back.
There are 2 more on AHL deals:
Gambardella 19 Pts/32 GP
Schmelzer (C) #3 in scoring 24 Pts/34 GP
The roster vets would be:
Wotherspoon
Russo
Foote
Dowling
Criscuolo
Gambardella
Schmelzer
That's one over the limit. Schmelzer has more than proven his value in his time here.
Gambardella is a key piece on this team, but is only re-signable if 2 of those Vet D-men are gone.
This roster is wide open for some younger non vet forwards who can score. A center would be glorious vet or not.
Dowling
Criscuolo
Clarke
Stillman
Parent
Durandeau
Halonen
Schmelzer
Willman
Filmon will be here.
That leaves room for 3 really good additions. Laberge is a great depth guy. Gambardella may have to be let go along with 2 of the vet D unless they come up with a couple good centers that make Schmelzer unnecessary that are not vets. They let much better guys go after 2021-22. Would like a couple of that level again (DeLeo and Greer)