Toggle sidebar

Speculation: 2023-24-25 Sharks Roster Discussion

Juxtaposer

Juxtaposer

Outro: Divina Comedia
Dec 21, 2009
50,245
24,248
Bay Area
Lebanezer said:
Good problem to have.
Click to expand...
Obviously, but Matty Beniers getting a $50M contract with 100 career points feels insane to me. Like I totally get it from Seattle's perspective, you have to lock your 1C down as soon as you can, that's not the player to nickel and dime, it just feels crazy to get that much money with effectively one good season to your name.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sandisfan
sharski

sharski

Registered User
Jun 4, 2012
5,839
5,080
*3 years later*

JW: "So, should I print a couple copies of our 8 x 8 full NMC template? It literally works every time "
GMMG: *sigh*
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThePlanet
weastern bias

weastern bias

worst team in the league
Feb 3, 2012
11,741
8,763
SJ
Juxtaposer said:
Obviously, but Matty Beniers getting a $50M contract with 100 career points feels insane to me. Like I totally get it from Seattle's perspective, you have to lock your 1C down as soon as you can, that's not the player to nickel and dime, it just feels crazy to get that much money with effectively one good season to your name.
Click to expand...
Unfortunately that risk on a long term contract coming off the ELC is the meta for team building right now

Sometimes it sucks, but sometimes you get Jack Hughes for $8M long term, if Celebrini doesn't have an otherworldly first 2 seasons and we can lock him up to like $9.75M per for 8 years you do it ASAP, it's just way better to take the risk on an early overpayment than to regret it once he does break out and he makes like $12M+
 
  • Like
Reactions: vortexy, ChompChomp, Sandisfan and 1 other person
matt trick

matt trick

Registered User
Jun 12, 2007
10,123
2,093
weastern bias said:
Unfortunately that risk on a long term contract coming off the ELC is the meta for team building right now

Sometimes it sucks, but sometimes you get Jack Hughes for $8M long term, if Celebrini doesn't have an otherworldly first 2 seasons and we can lock him up to like $9.75M per for 8 years you do it ASAP, it's just way better to take the risk on an early overpayment than to regret it once he does break out and he makes like $12M+
Click to expand...

Pretty much this. Don’t know how it’ll play out but in 23 months id like to see a macklin 8 year extension at whatever it takes. There’s a chance that’s $9M, but I’d budget $10M. Paying Macklin won’t be a problem, but it will be interesting to see what Bedard, Carlsson, and Fantilli get before him. Bedard will set the new market for franchise players coming off their ELC.

Having a 21-29 year old Celebrini making $9-11M will actually give a decent amount of surplus value for the later 2/3rds or so of the contract.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vortexy, Sandisfan and weastern bias

Shark in Hockeytown

Registered User
Jul 18, 2021
245
356
TheBeard said:
Things completely unraveled post cup final appearance faster than any franchise I've ever seen. .... Maybe it was all smoke and mirrors, but the core was definitely at a place where they were competing.
Click to expand...

Montreal in 21 was a marginal playoff team that got lucky in the playoffs. They came back against the Leafs from 3-1 down in games. They went 6-1 in OT games in the playoffs that year, which is luck. They were outscored in regulation 52-45 in the four series. Yes, much of that was Tampa dismantling them in the finals, but they also swept the Jets in the second round. Because the playoffs are very random, it is not unusual for a marginal playoff team to make the final. But they almost never win.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sandisfan
matt trick

matt trick

Registered User
Jun 12, 2007
10,123
2,093
TheBeard said:
Are there any RFAs remaining to look at that would only cost a 2nd rounder?
Click to expand...

Core Perfetti would be a nice pickup, but as a recent 10th overall who's got two years of ~top 6ish production (when healthy), can't imagine $4.5M would scare them off. The Jets have $6M in cap space I believe. I feel like all it would do is piss them off.
 

gaucholoco3

Registered User
Jun 22, 2015
1,510
1,933
matt trick said:
Core Perfetti would be a nice pickup, but as a recent 10th overall who's got two years of ~top 6ish production (when healthy), can't imagine $4.5M would scare them off. The Jets have $6M in cap space I believe. I feel like all it would do is piss them off.
Click to expand...
I don’t get why these GMs are so concerned about pissing off other teams. If the Jets match then who cares. You then forced another team to pay more than they wanted to for a player.
 
ChompChomp

ChompChomp

Can't wait for Sharks hockey to return someday
Jan 8, 2007
11,515
2,380
El Paso, TX
Thomas Harley as well, but the Stars have cap space to match and he's a left handed D anyways, which we have too many of. Nice young player though.
 
TheBeard

TheBeard

He fixes the cable?
Jul 12, 2019
18,413
21,321
Vegass
ChompChomp said:
Thomas Harley as well, but the Stars have cap space to match and he's a left handed D anyways, which we have too many of. Nice young player though.
Click to expand...
We'd either offer him in the 4.5-7 range and it would cost a first and a third or we offer him less and Dallas thanks us profusely.
 

gaucholoco3

Registered User
Jun 22, 2015
1,510
1,933
TheBeard said:
Are there any RFAs remaining to look at that would only cost a 2nd rounder?
Click to expand...
It is still difficult to find a suitable offer sheet candidate. You would need to find a player who is worth the compensation with a team that doesn’t have the cap space to match.

Looking at current RFA’s Perfetti might be worth the 2nd but Winnipeg has the space to match. The best RFA’s on teams that don’t have cap space to match are Robertson and Tomasino but are either of those players worth a 2nd round pick.

Next year the best target is Askarov if he isn’t traded, since I doubt Nashville would want to pay their backup $4.5 million. He would absolutely be worth a 2nd.
 
tiburon12

tiburon12

Registered User
Jul 18, 2009
5,113
5,208
matt trick said:
Core Perfetti would be a nice pickup, but as a recent 10th overall who's got two years of ~top 6ish production (when healthy), can't imagine $4.5M would scare them off. The Jets have $6M in cap space I believe. I feel like all it would do is piss them off.
Click to expand...
They don't value him as a top 6 though. They would match but not be happy about it.
 
TheBeard

TheBeard

He fixes the cable?
Jul 12, 2019
18,413
21,321
Vegass
gaucholoco3 said:
It is still difficult to find a suitable offer sheet candidate. You would need to find a player who is worth the compensation with a team that doesn’t have the cap space to match.

Looking at current RFA’s Perfetti might be worth the 2nd but Winnipeg has the space to match. The best RFA’s on teams that don’t have cap space to match are Robertson and Tomasino but are either of those players worth a 2nd round pick.

Next year the best target is Askarov if he isn’t traded, since I doubt Nashville would want to pay their backup $4.5 million. He would absolutely be worth a 2nd.
Click to expand...
See, this is where I can see Grier wanting to weaponize cap space. Build good will with enough GMs and screw over the others.
 
ChompChomp

ChompChomp

Can't wait for Sharks hockey to return someday
Jan 8, 2007
11,515
2,380
El Paso, TX
spintops said:
Does offer sheeting really ruin relationship? Didn't STL-Edm complete a trade the next day?
Click to expand...

Yes. I think ruining relationships is overblown. I do think GM's "remember" and will seek revenge through offer sheets at another time. That seems to be the extent of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sandisfan
STL Shark

STL Shark

Registered User
Mar 6, 2013
4,408
5,476
matt trick said:
Core Perfetti would be a nice pickup, but as a recent 10th overall who's got two years of ~top 6ish production (when healthy), can't imagine $4.5M would scare them off. The Jets have $6M in cap space I believe. I feel like all it would do is piss them off.
Click to expand...
Bigger issue is that Perfetti wouldn't sign a deal for $4.5M. If he would, then WPG likely already sign him. To offersheet someone, you have to vastly overpay for 1 year with hopes that it's so much more than the current team is offering that it's worth the drama. STL paid Broberg and Holloway double what they were asking from Edmonton in order to get them to sign. Carolina did something similar with Kotkaniemi to lure him from Montreal.

If a guy already has production over a full season or more, it's insanely hard to offersheet them without getting into the 1st round pick or more range.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sandisfan
You must log in or register to reply here.

Ad

Latest posts

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom
X