Prospect Info: 2023-2024 Rangers Prospects Thread (Prospect Stats in Post #1; Updated 05.22.2024)

Status
Not open for further replies.

GAGLine

Registered User
Sep 17, 2007
24,322
21,244
I'm not sure I get it with McNamara. Every team in the CHL has several guys who aren't even really prospects who could show up at a house league game and make you think they're Wayne Gretzky, but then in real games, they're Brent Gretzky. McNamara who I saw a bit last season feels like one of them. Really nice skills but generally invisible save for the occasional flash-and-dash shit. Posting a donut in the playoffs last season--11 games--is always a red flag, too.

I'm always in favor of taking shots at UDFA players but it needs to be within reason. McNamara, he's one you keep on the radar for later, but not someone I'd invest in now.
Yeah, his production is very underwhelming. I'm guessing the combination of size and skating is what people are seeing. If he can figure it out, he could be a good player.
 
  • Like
Reactions: egelband and nyr2k2

nyr2k2

Can't Beat Him
Jul 30, 2005
46,162
34,209
Maryland
Oh, I agree on McNamara. I don't see the upside per se. I was just adding that the contract wouldn't affect our options.

Petrovski is a much more intriguing option to sign. I've seen more of him because he played with Othmann so perhaps that affects my opinion on him a bit. I really wouldn't mind signing him, letting him play 2 more years in the OHL and then join Hartford.


I doubt it happens but I would like to see it.
I would be fine with Petrovski for generally the same reasons you stated. I would also be fine with signing one guy like him each year; i.e. your 18-year-old undrafted camp players.

The practice of signing guys in that position, though, I wouldn't make it a major piece of my prospect acquisition strategy. The contract may not count up front, but it does count eventually, and then you're most likely stuck with a bunch of crappy guys that maybe fill out your ECHL team. There's so much unknown with these players and that I think is one reason you don't see a ton of guys being signed under these circumstances. Also the CHL leagues, particularly the OHL and WHL, are so heavily scouted, it's really rare for a guy from those leagues to slip through the cracks. If he isn't drafted there's usually a good reason.

I think the better bet is signing the traditional UDFA players particularly from the NCAA ranks or Europe. You lose the benefit of the contract sliding but gain those extra years of development and some additional "certainty" about what a guy is or isn't.
 

Amazing Kreiderman

Registered User
Apr 11, 2011
45,009
40,722
I would be fine with Petrovski for generally the same reasons you stated. I would also be fine with signing one guy like him each year; i.e. your 18-year-old undrafted camp players.

The practice of signing guys in that position, though, I wouldn't make it a major piece of my prospect acquisition strategy. The contract may not count up front, but it does count eventually, and then you're most likely stuck with a bunch of crappy guys that maybe fill out your ECHL team. There's so much unknown with these players and that I think is one reason you don't see a ton of guys being signed under these circumstances. Also the CHL leagues, particularly the OHL and WHL, are so heavily scouted, it's really rare for a guy from those leagues to slip through the cracks. If he isn't drafted there's usually a good reason.

I think the better bet is signing the traditional UDFA players particularly from the NCAA ranks or Europe. You lose the benefit of the contract sliding but gain those extra years of development and some additional "certainty" about what a guy is or isn't.

Yeah, but Petrovski is the first guy that qualifies for these parameters that we've had in our prospect camp in years.

He's more an exception. I wouldn't sign guys this way every year.
 

cwede

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Sep 1, 2010
9,988
7,942
McNamara not on training camp roster. Petrovski is.
3 rookie camp tryout undrafted CHL D and 3 Pack D in Camp

At F only rookie camp tryout McCue, and Pack Panwar invited, 4 other Pack Fs not
 
Last edited:

Amazing Kreiderman

Registered User
Apr 11, 2011
45,009
40,722
I thought he was pretty bad in game 1. Was he better in game 2?

He was struggling but the kid turned 18 just a few weeks ago. By far the youngest player on the ice in those games.

He's by no means a guy you should expect to become a top-pair D-man in the NHL but if he can develop into a solid 3rd pair D-man, that's huge.

Also, I just want the Rangers to sign an 18-year old UDFA because it's so rare and it would be a fun topic to discuss :laugh:
 

The Crypto Guy

Registered User
Jun 26, 2017
28,307
36,915
IMG-5471.jpg
 

nyr2k2

Can't Beat Him
Jul 30, 2005
46,162
34,209
Maryland
Tarnstrom was scoreless, -1, with 2 SOG and played 11 minutes in his debut for Brynas in Allsvenskan.

Rasmus Larsson was the story today: he had the primary assist on the game-tying goal for Green Bay with just over a minute to go, and then had the OT winner to boot. He finished 1+1, led all defensemen in the game with 5 SOG, and led all players with a +4. He played on the top pair with Avs pick Chris Romaine. Apparently, he goes by Moose:

 
Last edited:

egelband

Registered User
Sep 6, 2008
16,074
14,840
Tarnstrom was scoreless, -1, with 2 SOG and played 11 minutes in his debut for Brynas in Allsvenskan.

Rasmus Larsson was the story today: he had the primary assist on the game-tying goal for Green Bay with just over a minute to go, and then had the OT winner to boot. He finished 1+1, led all defensemen in the game with 5 SOG, and led all players with a +4. He played on the top pair with Avs pick Chris Romaine. Apparently, he goes by Moose:


Actually, coincidentally, Mike Mussina won the door prize at the local flea market. A pair of new Nike sneakers!
 

Amazing Kreiderman

Registered User
Apr 11, 2011
45,009
40,722
We might have found a real diamond in the rough with Larsson. There are a lot of indications that he's turned into a beauty of a late bloomer pick; I'm not even sure how to gauge his potential at this point.

Trading the rights to Jayden Grubbe may turn out to be a brilliancy by Drury.

The Jimmy Vesey trade tree is growing
 

nyr2k2

Can't Beat Him
Jul 30, 2005
46,162
34,209
Maryland
I wonder what happened with Simon Kjellberg. He was set to play his final year at Northern Michigan and then disappeared from the roster without a peep. His brother, Joel, was also committed to NMU for 24-25, and it looks like he may have decommitted.
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: egelband and cwede
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad