Still in recovery mode so haven't read the whole thread...but I'm strongly against trading Girard. Defensive depth is absolute gold. Injuries happen every single year on playoff runs. I mean, we lost Girard this year, I'm pretty certain Toews was also injured, and Tampa's D was gutted even though they kept playing. Keep all of Byram/Toews/Makar/Girard, and also try to bring back Manson if he'll sign something reasonable. Having a top four calibre defenseman on the bottom pairing during the regular season is absolutely fine.