Herby
How could Blake have known?
Just wanted to stick up for my guy MacD.
Yes, he took a step back this season. The numbers don't lie. He sucked. That said, any of you that want to say the Kings are a playoff team if he didn't play at all have had a lot of air let out of that balloon by seeing this team play like trash without him as well.
Roy in his exit interview saying he gets excited being paired with MacDermid just once again reiterates my point that he is a real character guy on a team that seems devoid of character. He wasn't given the two year contract because he was going to be the key piece of a Cup contender: it was a reward for the work that he has put in for years and because that work is something that Management wants the young guys to see and be around.
Blake never expected contention this year so MacDermid playing a lot of games doesn't matter. I would hope that those crucifying MacDermid can now be at a point where they can see that this team's issue wasn't MacDermid playing instead of Clague but rather that it just isn't good enough top-to-bottom no matter who is playing in place of MacDermid. As a matter of fact, the Kings should have a better draft pick thanks to Kurtis and who cares if they won four more games? They finished 14 points out of the playoffs haha.
Guy has a cap hit of $875,000. We'll see what the off-season brings but I think the Kings will be perfectly fine to carry him again as the #7D that plays maybe 30 games or they send him down and have ZERO problems paying him that $875k to be a total professional and bad-ass down in Ontario. Captain material. I think the latter is a real possibility and, if that happens, there is real value to it and it is completely worth the contract and every goal against that can be pinned on him this past season.
When the Kings were fighting for that playoff spot when no one else seemed to want it the points he cost them (which I'd say are probably anywhere from 2-4 points on the season) were pretty painful. But you are right, this team was never good enough, it was a mirage of slight overachieving and the fact that the division sucked outside of the top 3.
No one has a problem with MacD in the lineup in situations where toughness is needed, I just don't understand why they can't just put him on 4th line LW. Throughout the history of the league plenty of goons have transitioned from playing D at lower levels to being wingers in the NHL because they just can't play the D position at an effective level.
MacD playing 20-40 games a year at 4th line LW is not going to piss anyone off. He can still provide the toughness but his mistakes aren't going to end up in the back of our net and if game situation arises where they need to sit him (say down a goal in the 3rd) the Kings can just double shift a different winger.
Why can't the Kings do that?
The way Athanasiou ended the season, with one goal in the last 15 games, is it really worth bringing him back? He completely disappeared after the Jeff Carter trade, and I feel like how he closed out the season left a bigger impression than everything else he did prior.
I'm lukewarm in regards to bringing him back, as I feel like he's another one of those redundant players who makes no real impact in the outcome of a game. He's really a bottom six forward who is very streaky when it comes to offensive production, and he is pretty weak in his own zone.
I put him in my potential lineup for next season because I figured there is no way Blake would have kept him at the deadline if he didn't plan to sign him. But honestly, I think maybe its best to move on. A lot of the things that my buddies who are Wings fans told me came to fruition as the year went on, he's just one of those guys who's only role is to be a 2nd line winger on a really bad team. He just has had a tendency to disappear to much in his career, if anyone follows the NFL he's like Kenny Stills. He will amaze you with a beautiful play that gets you excited, and then you won't notice him again until the next beautiful play 7 weeks later.
The Kings are just so awful on the wing so it's tough to let a proven albeit inconsistent guy go, but I think I'd rather have Kaliyev, Turcotte or one of the other younger players play one of those top 9 winger roles than AA.
Last edited: