2019 Top 10 Redraft.

[HabsCode]

Feel like after close to 6 years we have a good idea of where this class ranks.

I’ll go:

1. Jack Hughes
2. Moritz Seider
3. Matthew Boldy
4. Cole Caufield
5. Dylan Cozens
6. Connor McMichael
7. Bowen Byram
8. Trevor Zegras
9. Kaapo Kakko
10. Mattias Maccelli

Click to read more...

 

[Viqsi]

Hi. I'm a Jackets fan.

 

[HabsCode]

Hi. I'm a Jackets fan.

That’s dope.

 

[newfy]

Hi. I'm a Jackets fan.

Unreal. I'm happy for you

 

[Felidae]

Feel like after close to 6 years we have a good idea of where this class ranks.

I’ll go:

1. Jack Hughes
2. Moritz Seider
3. Matthew Boldy
4. Cole Caufield
5. Dylan Cozens
6. Connor McMichael
7. Bowen Byram
8. Trevor Zegras
9. Kaapo Kakko
10. Mattias Maccelli

Pretty good top 4, I think mine would be the same.

I'd put Zegras higher despite his last 2 years, just cause he's had 2 consecutive 60+ point seasons. Only Matthew Boldy and Jack Hughes have 2 or more seasons above 60+ points.

I'd also make room for Thomas Harley, Dimitri Voronkov, Pyotr Kochetkov.

Dustin Wolf is on his first season so based on their NHL careers so far probably shouldn't make it.. I suspect he'll be a lock by the time the season ends though.

 

[Viqsi]

That’s dope.

Unreal. I'm happy for you

Heh. Well, I figured it'd be slightly more amusing than the standard "OMG how dare you not include $MY_GUY this list sucks and you suck".

There's a fair debate to be had; I just don't feel like Dmitri Voronkov gets anywhere near enough appreciation for what he does.

 

[Viqsi]

Voronkov too but I don't know who I'd switch out

You could always go with recency bias and swap out Maccelli.

 

[AlexModvechkin8]

Aliaksei Protas should be top ten I think. If not he’s right outside of it.

 

[HabsCode]

Pretty good list. I think I have the same top 4 too.

I'd put Zegras higher despite his last 2 years, just cause he's had 2 consecutive 60+ point seasons. Only Matthew Boldy and Jack Hughes have 2 or more seasons above 60+ points.

I'd also make room for Thomas Harley, probably replace Kaapo Kakko. Voronkov too but I don't know who I'd switch out

Yeah I changed Zegras a couple times, didn’t really know on what to base my evaluation on him whether it’s on the first half of his career so far or his most recent play. I think there is a point to be made he has a spot in the top 5.

 

[HabsCode]

Aliaksei Protas should be top ten I think. If not he’s right outside of it.

Good point. Didn’t really acknowledged this player until recently, but I don’t know who’s place he would take.

 

[Felidae]

You could always go with recency bias and swap out Maccelli.

I was actually considering saying something along those lines.. but I'd probably swap out McMichael first. Having a great season so far, but Maccelli produced at the same rate for 2 full seasons

 

[Our Lady Peace]

To date:

1. Jack Hughes
2. Moritz Seider
3. Matt Boldy
4. Cole Caufield
5. Dustin Wolf
6. Thomas Harley
7. Trevor Zegras
8. Bowen Byram
9. Kaapo Kakko
10. Dylan Cozens

HM: Alex Vlasic, Cam York, Matias Maccelli, Pyotr Kochetkov, Dmitry Voronkov, Connor McMichael, Aliaksei Protas, Shane Pinto

EDIT: Holy crap I forgot a few names. Wolf, Vlasic, Kochetkov

 

[Dead Coyote]

1. Hughes
2. Seider
3. Boldy
4. Caufield
5. Protas
6. Zegras
7. McMichael
8. Vorenkov
9. Kochetkov
10. Byram

 

[LemonSauceD]

I made a list a couple of weeks ago in a similar thread.

1. Hughes
2. Seider
3. Wolf
4. Boldy
5. Byram
6. Harley
7. Vlasic
8. Caufield
9. Cozens
10. Maccelli
11. McMicheal
12. Protas
13. Zegras
14. Kochetkov
15. Voronkov
16. Broberg
17. Kakko
18. Knight
19. York
20. Spence
21. Dorofeyev
22. Dach
23. Pinto
24. Brink
25. Lacombe
26. Kaliyev
27. Korzcak
28. Parsinnen
29. Silovs
30. Podkolzin
31. Thrun
32. Hoglander
33. Krebs
34. Newhook
35. Turcotte
36. Tomasino
37. Beecher
38. Helleson
39. Leason
40. Struble
41. Kastelic
42. Harvey-Pinard

Only 42 legitimate NHL’ers and there’s a noticeable drop off in talent after top 10-13

 

[Tetsuo]

I made a list a couple of weeks ago in a similar thread.

1. Hughes
2. Seider
3. Wolf
4. Boldy
5. Byram
6. Harley
7. Vlasic
8. Caufield
9. Cozens
10. Maccelli
11. McMicheal
12. Protas
13. Zegras
14. Kochetkov
15. Voronkov
16. Broberg
17. Kakko
18. Knight
19. York
20. Spence
21. Dorofeyev
22. Dach
23. Pinto
24. Brink
25. Lacombe
26. Kaliyev
27. Korzcak
28. Parsinnen
29. Silovs
30. Podkolzin
31. Thrun
32. Hoglander
33. Krebs
34. Newhook
35. Turcotte
36. Tomasino
37. Beecher
38. Helleson
39. Leason
40. Struble
41. Kastelic
42. Harvey-Pinard

Only 42 legitimate NHL’ers and there’s a noticeable drop off in talent after top 10-13

Johansson on the Red Wings has a chance to be an NHLer, he's improved under the new coach quite a bit. Still too early to tell, but I think he's at least in consideration.

 

[Jumptheshark]

I will just do the top ten

Jack Hughes
Matthew Boldy
Moritz Seider
Cole Caufield
Dylan Cozens
Bowen Byram
Kaapo Kakko
Dmitry Voronkov
Mark Kastelic
Philip Broberg

There are a couple of goalies who are projected to take over the number 1 spot on their respective team in the next 2 seasons--until that happens they wont be in my top ten

[td]

​

[/td]​

 

[mphmiles]

Vlasic is very underrated in here.

That's probably expected as a defensive defenseman on a terrible team, though. Those guys really only get credit when their team is winning.

 

[pvr]

Vlasic is very underrated in here.

That's probably expected as a defensive defenseman on a terrible team, though. Those guys really only get credit when their team is winning.

Vlasic is a beast.

 

[olli]

To date:

1. Jack Hughes
2. Moritz Seider
3. Matt Boldy
4. Cole Caufield
5. Dustin Wolf
6. Thomas Harley
7. Trevor Zegras
8. Bowen Byram
9. Kaapo Kakko
10. Dylan Cozens

HM: Alex Vlasic, Cam York, Matias Maccelli, Pyotr Kochetkov, Dmitry Voronkov, Connor McMichael, Aliaksei Protas, Shane Pinto

EDIT: Holy crap I forgot a few names. Wolf, Vlasic, Kochetkov

Why do you have zegras over Byram?

 

[BlueMed]

Not a chance Kakko or Zegras go over Broberg.

 

[HockeyWooot]

Hughes
Seider
Boldy
Caufield
Harley
Vlasic
Byram
Wolf
Cozens
Protas

HM: McMichael, Voronkov, Broberg, LaCombe

Tricky list to put together, needing to balance out track record vs recent performance.

McMichael and Voronkov very well could be on here though short sample size, while I still have Wolf on here who has tracked well and is having a phenomenal year as a No 1.

 

[Taze em]

Hughes
Seider
Boldy
Caufield
Harley
Vlasic
Byram
Wolf
Cozens
Protas

HM: McMichael, Voronkov, Broberg, LaCombe

good list. Agreed all the way around.

 

[Our Lady Peace]

Why do you have zegras over Byram?

IMO he's played at a higher level than Byram has, who struggled decent amount in Colorado

Zegras himself is now going through it

 

[Coach Reggie Dunlop]

I will just do the top ten

Jack Hughes
Matthew Boldy
Moritz Seider
Cole Caufield
Dylan Cozens
Bowen Byram
Kaapo Kakko
Dmitry Voronkov
Mark Kastelic
Philip Broberg

There are a couple of goalies who are projected to take over the number 1 spot on their respective team in the next 2 seasons--until that happens they wont be in my top ten

[td]


[/td]​

There is no universe where a 6’4 seider who gives you 200 hits, 200 blocked shots and over half ppg is below boldy.