Beacon
Embrace the tank
- May 28, 2007
- 13,676
- 1,454
Alright, so here's a scenario:
Chytil's contract can slide again next year, if he plays fewer than 10 NHL games. What do we do if Chytil plays in the NHL but isn't good or bad but just average? Do we keep him in the NHL and burn a year off his ELC? Or do we send him back and save that very valuable ELC year?
An average NHLer is a 3C. You don't send a barely-19 year old (next year) to the minors because he's only a 3C. A full year in the NHL with real minutes per game is invaluable to a kid during his prime development years if he can keep up. The question is whether we burn his year if he can only play 30 games with 8 sheltered minutes per game.
If a kid can be a 3C in the NHL, he has NOTHING to learn in the AHL. There's almost no overlap between the 2 leagues (or else the AHLer would get called up or picked up off waivers), so anyone who is a 3C in the NHL would abuse the AHL while being bored. Look at Nieves: he's barely able to keep up as a 4C in the NHL, yet he's a great AHL player. Hrivik couldn't make it as a 13F in either New York or Calgary, yet he's a beast in the AHL.