That was a dumb mistake, but the way he intentionally handcuffed the Blackhawks with the Hossa contract was legendary and clearly what got him fired. It worked out, but it forced them into decisions they'd rather not have had to make.
It is widely believed and was reported that Tallon lost power struggle among a variety of reasons
Some notable friction
- Tallon didn't want to fire Savard , Hawks upper management/ownership forced him to do it and put in Q (Who upper management hired)
- Tallon wanted to bring back Havlat , Wirtz , Bowman (Scotty) and McDonaugh (Our Team President) decided to go after Hossa instead
- Tallon had been slowly losing power since Rocky Wirtz took over. Tallon was a Bill Wirtz hire (As was Savard as coach)
And it was actually Campbell contract that was problem not Hossa. Hawks were forced to overpay for Campbell and Tallon did so willingly (He coveted a defender like Campbell for years and made him #1 offseason priority)
After Tallon was fired it was that mess that Bowman had to clean up. Ironically it was Tallon who ultimately cleaned it up for Hawks after he became GM of Panthers
Dale's love for Campbell as a player helped (Campbell was big plus for rebuilding team), then hurt (That contract was crippling in summer of 2010) and then helped the Hawks again (When Dale traded for him)
It was a complicated little mess here in Chicago but if you look at Tallon's drafting it was very poor as was his handling of FA's
Those coupled with the new regime in Chicago (Rocky Wirtz era) quickly led to falling out
Also it should be noted that while Tallon did make some good moves (Sharp trade , Versteeg trade , etc) and he did get right the two most important picks in Hawks history (Toews #3 and Kane #1) he also inherited a system deep in future NHL talent
Future NHL talent to play over 100 NHL games that were prospects when Tallon took over Hawks organization (Bolded = Future Allstars)
C Dave Bolland
C Jake Dowell
LW Chris Porter
LW Bryan Bickell
LW Tuomo Ruutu
RW Troy Brouwer
RW Adam Burish
D Anton Babchuk
D Lasse Kukkonen
D Cam Barker
D James Wisniewski
D Brent Seabrook
D Dustin Byfuglien
D Duncan Keith
G Craig Anderson
G Corey Crawford
G Michael Leighton
When Mike Smith was fired he was halfway thru what he planned as a strategy of rebuilding team from net out
That is why the Hawks prospect pool was so deep with regard to goaltending and defenders and so light when it comes to forwards when Tallon took over (Also the big 2000 draft was flop with Yakubov failing miserably and Vorobiev despite showing promise being chased back to Russia by Tallon regime)
Mike Smith drafted 5 guys who would go on to be allstars and often goes under radar for his contribution to future Hawks team (Guess that is life of a GM fired before team turns it around)