What are we at present.. #6 overall?
Karlsson, Ryan, Turris, MacArthur & Zibanejad.
Karlsson is a defenceman. So yeah he's usually on the perimeter in the offensive zone
Ryan is anything but a perimeter player... First goal yesterday was scored because he went to the net. And he score the second
goal from inside the crease so..
MacArthur has no dangles. He's always in the dirty areas.
Turris takes a ton of physical abuse and is always in the trenches. He's a two way center
Where does ISS have him ranked? Or Bob Mckenzie, and the 10 scouts that are currently employed with NHL teams that compiled TSN's rankings.
The fact that your citing Craig's List, is laughable.
Have no doubt crouse will be a good NHLer. Just isn't what we need IMO. We need a guy capable of doing things on his own. Some guy who can break a game open or get a goal when we get behind. Or kill a game when we are up.
You alluded to the fact that no professionals had him ranked as low as some of the posters who don't think he is a top 5 pick. I pointed out how wrong you were with a few examples, and then, followed that with sarcasm at the rationale you used re professionals. Which you missed, evidently. You then followed that up with another demonstration of ignorance. You are really on a roll. Bravo.
Have no doubt crouse will be a good NHLer. Just isn't what we need IMO. We need a guy capable of doing things on his own. Some guy who can break a game open or get a goal when we get behind. Or kill a game when we are up.
I think he's a guy we need. Can easily be argued we need strome more. But I don't see how that happens at all.
Lol.
I dare you to try and find a post where I said to take Crouse top 5.
I didn't allude to anything. I pointed out the facts. A majority of scouts have him ranked top 10, fact.
There's a reason for it, even if you don't see it.
Funny. I don't believe I said you'd take him top 5, any more that I said he wasn't' top 10. The majority of posters are simply saying we should focus on a higher skilled player, namely Strome, Marner or one of the other 2nd tier prospects. I've already said if we took Crouse between 9-15 that I wouldn't have a major issue with it. He'd be a safe, if unspectacular pick.
And I guess your point about all the professionals thinking he was a "stud" and all the poster thinking he wasn't, was probably the kind of empty and bland statement that should have been ignored. Why you're hell bent if some people have him ranked 5-10 spots different than someone else is beyond me. If you saw an actual draft ranking from an NHL team list, you would probably lose your mind with how different they are.
Crouse is mad overrated
Would be disappointing if we select him with a top 10 pick. If anyone drafts him top 5 overall, they will be very disappointed.
I want Barzal or Provorov. Zacha sounds impressive
If we end up with a top 10 pick and take a guy who is bigger than 97% of his league and still can't be a top 5 scorer on his OWN TEAM (Crouse), I will lose it.
The comparisons to Lucic and Neal are ridiculous. Crouse has nothing like Lucic's meanness and nothing like Neal's touch.
I really would like to hear why ANYONE thinks Crouse is a top 10 talent in this draft. He is big but nothing crazy. He is a decent skater by NHL standards (at best), but won't separate himself from ANY NHL defender. He has marginal hands right now; he won't dangle even an AHL defender as it stands. He has next to no vision (from what I've seen); his assist total speaks to that. He doesn't seem to be able to snipe from distance. I just don't get it. From what I've seen and read he doesn't seem to be notable for his defensive work either.
What am I missing?
This guy seems like a typical late 1st rounder who either plays on the third line or breaks out and becomes a 2nd liner.
Pass if we pick in the top 10.
Well if management believes that zib and Turris are our top 2 centers going forward then we are definitely going left wing with our pick (or D).
So it's crouse> Zacha/rantanen.
Personally I've been super impressed whenever I've seen Zacha and rantanen play.
Management doesn't think Turris and Zibby are our top-2 centers, I'm sure of it.
If they still somehow do, well, they're in for mucho disappointment.
zibby has 6 points in his last 7 games.
believe