OT: 108th Obsequious Banter Thread: Nine dozen eggs and not one broken

The incredible edible egg, liked or not?


  • Total voters
    41
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

ellja3

Registered User
May 19, 2014
2,236
3,987
Ķekava, Latvia
It's a simple thing really.

1 - Buy adequate steak..ribeye is traditional. Slice thin or shave (if you have the means).

2 - Buy good long rolls. They should not be crunchy at all but can have a little bit of firmness to them.

3 - Buy good quality cheese. Not sure what you can get there. If you can get Cooper Sharp American that is the best to me but Provolone is also excellent. Swiss works. Cheddar is for burgers. No french cheeses.

4 - Onions, either fried or caramelized, are a good topping choice. Philadelphians do not put Bell Peppers on there but you'll see impostors like Subway offer that. Hot or Sweet Cherry Peppers are acceptable.

Cook the shaved ribeye to near completion, then put your cheese on top of the shaved ribeye while it's still on the cooking surface you're using so it can melt while the steak finishes. Then turn your roll upside down and put it on top of the pile of cheese and steak. Swallow up the ingredients with the roll, flip it over, and then roll it up right with aluminum foil to get it all shaped properly. Unroll and top with peppers and/or whatever sauce you prefer. A lot of Philadelphians use ketchup, some use mayo, and the true weirdos use both. I like mine with caramelized or grilled onions and then instead of adding cherry peppers at the end, I hit it with some Sriracha sauce.

<3 Thanks for the description. Sriracha sauce, btw, is true love.
 

Rebels57

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Sep 28, 2014
78,150
125,688
<3 Thanks for the description. Sriracha sauce, btw, is true love.

You'll love it on a cheesesteak but I would try one without sauce first to compare. Maybe just dip it in different sauces to experiment.
 

Kermit the Prog

Threadkiller
Sponsor
Feb 10, 2010
2,270
4,489
Greenville, DE
The only option of Provolone I found in store apps was a 1 kilogram ball that looks like a kettlebell, haha, goddam, this is fun.

Ok, in true outsider style, Imma tell you something others here will chafe at.

What you put on your cheesesteak is purely your choice. In college, when I was bartending, I had access to the grill at the end of the night. I'd cook the chipped steak and add American cheese on the grill. Then, I'd look to see what was still out. Bacon. I like bacon, so I chopped it up and threw that in there. Black olives? Yep, that, too.

Pat's and Geno's, which are loudly hailed as the "first" cheesesteak places in Philly (which I don't believe is accurate) and were the de facto standard bearers as to "what belongs on a cheesesteak and what does not," including the 'Whiz. This drove parochial definitions of what is "acceptable" and what is "not acceptable" for many defenders of this local delicacy. These places were established in the mid-1960s.

By comparison, I grew up near the Claymont Steak Shop (CSS), which pre-dates one, if not both, Pat's and Geno's, so it can also lay claim as to what belongs and what does not. Almost everyone ordered ketchup on theirs at CSS, whereas it is considered a sin to do so north of the Delaware border. CSS was, at one time, the greatest cheesesteak shop on the planet, when it was owned by the Dematratos family, and won numerous "Best of" awards, even outside of Delaware. The current incarnation, while still very good, is not as great. I get mine with EXTRA ketchup, so I can dip my steak fries in it. It's all personal choice, really.

tl/dr: Put whatever the hell you want in/on your cheesesteak*. It's YOUR cheesesteak. Just don't call it a "Philly cheesesteak." It's just "cheesesteak."

* - But don't skimp on the roll or the meat itself.
 
Last edited:

Young Sandwich

Trout & Hockey
Sponsor
Dec 13, 2015
5,830
20,201
Outerspace
Ok, in true outsider style, Imma tell you something others here will chafe at.

What you put on your cheesesteak is purely your choice. In college, when I was bartending, I had access to the grill at the end of the night. I'd cook the chipped steak and add American cheese on the grill. Then, I'd look to see what was still out. Bacon. I like bacon, so I chopped it up and threw that in there. Black olives? Yep, that, too.

Pat's and Geno's, which are loudly hailed as the "first" cheesesteak places in Philly (which I don't believe is accurate) and were the de facto standard bearers as to "what belongs on a cheesesteak and what does not," including the 'Whiz. This drove parochial definitions of what is "acceptable" and what is "not acceptable" for many defenders of this local delicacy. These places were established in the mid-1960s.

By comparison, I grew up near the Claymont Steak Shop (CSS), which pre-dates one, if not both, Pat's and Geno's, so it can also lay claim as to what belongs and what does not. Almost everyone ordered ketchup on theirs at CSS, whereas it is considered a sin to do so north of the Delaware border. CSS was, at one time, the greatest cheesesteak shop on the planet, when it was owned by the Dematratos family, and won numerous "Best of" awards, even outside of Delaware. The current incarnation, while still very good, is not as great. I get mine with EXTRA ketchup, so I can dip my steak fries in it. It's all personal choice, really.

tl/dr: Put whatever the hell you want in/on your cheesesteak*. It's YOUR cheesesteak. Just don't call it a "Philly cheesesteak." It's just "cheesesteak."

* - But don't skimp on the roll or the meat itself.
Bacon definitely works. Pepperoni is another hidden gem.
 

Jack Straw

Moving much too slow.
Sponsor
Jul 19, 2010
25,737
26,808
New York
One of my favorites though is a Teriyaki Chicken Cheesesteak...if done right they are incredible.
mmhm.gif
 

BernieParent

In misery of redwings of suckage for a long time
Mar 13, 2009
25,201
46,034
Chasm of Sar (north of Montreal, Qc)

Lord Defect

Secretary of Blowtorching
Nov 13, 2013
18,931
35,021
Re: Cheesesteak, I appreciate all the insight; thanks guys!

Picking a good roll - makes tons of sense.
Sirlon instead of ribeye - great suggestion!
I don't even know what the hell was the cheese you were reffering to, so probably won't stumble upon it, haha.
Bell peppers don't belong there - ok - but regular peppers? Not a Carolina Reaper surely, but some sort of Jalapeno-level thing?
Longhots. I’m sure you don’t have them amongst your multitude of peppers.
Longhots can range between 1000 SCO and 20,000 SCO. It’s all completely random. Use a pepper in that range that’s not overpowering in taste.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad