Proposal: Zegras for Guhle, 1 for 1

[Michoulicious]

Montreal needs another top 6 forward that fits their young core. Zegras is one of Caufield's best friends.

Anaheim needs another solid young D that can play on the right side and eat solid defensive minutes. Guhle is a LHD but played almost half the season on the right.

Who says no? Fair?

I think something happens at the draft for Zegras.

Click to read more...

 

[Legend123]

Habs: o hell na

U win with guhles in the playoffs not with zegras

 

[Mrfenn92]

I think it’s a solid deal for both sides

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

Habs: o hell na

U win with guhles in the playoffs not with zegras

Arguably one of the dumbest arguements on these boards.

The you can or can’t win with players that havnt played playoff games lol

 

[Rob Brown]

Habs: o hell na

U win with guhles in the playoffs not with zegras

To be fair, neither of them has any playoff experience in the NHL.

 

[RationalExpectations]

Habs: o hell na

U win with guhles in the playoffs not with zegras

First you gotta make the playoffs… that being said, I think as a Habs fan I don t want to risk another Drouin Sergachev

 

[Legend123]

Arguably one of the dumbest arguements on these boards.

The you can or can’t win with players that havnt played playoff games lol

I've seen too many flashy superstars do nothing in the playoffs and zegras isn't even a star yet

Meanwhile defensive 2 way beasts like forsling excel in high stake games

Give me the forsling over the marner without a doubt

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

I've seen too many flashy superstars do nothing in the playoffs and zegras isn't even a star yet

Meanwhile defensive 2 way beasts like forsling excel in high stake games

Give me the forsling over the marner without a doubt

Zegras isn’t marner
And
Guhle isn’t forsling

 

[Legend123]

Zegras isn’t marner
And
Guhle isn’t forsling

Similar type of players both lesser for sure

 

[Boo Boo]

Nah I’m good

 

[Jee]

Nah I'm good

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

Similar type of players both lesser for sure

I don’t even think they are similar types of players, but doesn’t change the fact that neither player has played a playoff game so we have no idea if you can win with them, or if they perform better in the playoffs.

There are plenty of 2 way dmen that don’t do much come playoff time, and there are skill guys that do well in the playoffs.

It’s fine to say you’d prefer to keep guhle as he fits more with what you want for the team, but making up reasons that don’t exist with the 2 players in question is what id consider dumb.

 

[Habsrule]

For the Habs it would be more of a draft floor type of trade.

If Demidov and Lindstrom are both picked in the top four then yes I would trade Guhle for Zegras straight up. Then go ahead and draft one of Levshunov, Dickinson or Buium.

Zegras and Levshunov / Dickinson / Buium

Or

Guhle and Iginla / Sennecke / Catton / Helenius / Eiserman

 

[anezthes]

No.

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

For the Habs it would be more of a draft floor type of trade.

If Demidov and Lindstrom are both picked in the top four then yes I would trade Guhle for Zegras straight up. Then go ahead and draft one of Levshunov, Dickinson or Buium.

Zegras and Levshunov / Dickinson / Buium

Or

Guhle and Iginla / Sennecke / Catton / Helenius / Eiserman

Ya I can’t see habs really making a move without seeing how the picks fall…. And honestly I’d say anaheims in same boat…. If Demidov is there at 3, might make zegras expendable for d help.

 

[Rob Brown]

I've seen too many flashy superstars do nothing in the playoffs and zegras isn't even a star yet

Meanwhile defensive 2 way beasts like forsling excel in high stake games

Give me the forsling over the marner without a doubt

Sounds like you're really mischaracterizing both Zegras and Guhle.

 

[Ducks]

Pass.

 

[Gliff]

Pass

 

[The Crypto Guy]

Nah i’m good.

 

[Legend123]

I don’t even think they are similar types of players, but doesn’t change the fact that neither player has played a playoff game so we have no idea if you can win with them, or if they perform better in the playoffs.

There are plenty of 2 way dmen that don’t do much come playoff time, and there are skill guys that do well in the playoffs.

It’s fine to say you’d prefer to keep guhle as he fits more with what you want for the team, but making up reasons that don’t exist with the 2 players in question is what id consider dumb.

Clearly I was talking in general and not specifics

No shit anything can happen

 

[My Cozen Dylan]

Seems pretty bad for Anaheim.

 

[Laphroaig]

I wouldn't take two of Zegras for one Guhle.

 

[FerrisRox]

Montreal needs another top 6 forward that fits their young core. Zegras is one of Caufield's best friends.

Anaheim needs another solid young D that can play on the right side and eat solid defensive minutes. Guhle is a LHD but played almost half the season on the right.

Who says no? Fair?

I think something happens at the draft for Zegras.

I think Guhle is more important to the Canadiens right now than Zegras would be.

 

[Benstheman]

For the Habs it would be more of a draft floor type of trade.

If Demidov and Lindstrom are both picked in the top four then yes I would trade Guhle for Zegras straight up. Then go ahead and draft one of Levshunov, Dickinson or Buium.

Zegras and Levshunov / Dickinson / Buium

Or

Guhle and Iginla / Sennecke / Catton / Helenius / Eiserman

At that point I would keep Guhle and trade the 5OA for Zegras

 

[McDonald19]

Can we lock this up? We already had a big thread filled with Montreal fans telling us how Zegras sucks and Guhle will be a Norris candidate in a year or two.