Harry Kakalovich
Like and reply
Pretty much the best part about the off-season (post-draft and UFA excitement) is the amazing prospect ranking polls by @Treb - but NO PEAKING!!
HF Habs: Your Pre & Post 2022 NHL Draft Prospect Rankings
- Thread starter WeThreeKings
- Start date
-
HF Sportsbook has been reset for the new season - Click here to play.
montreal
Go Habs Go
Team Strength Rankings (May 2023)
Welcome to the 2023 Hockey Prospecting team prospect strength rankings! Just like last year, the team strength approach we will be using at Hockey Prospecting is to use our own model, largely based…
hockeyprospecting.com
Mrb1p
PRICERSTOPDAPUCK
Imagine ranking Guhle 6th, Im such a f***ing clown.
Guhle saw this and said aight bet and became a 1D right out the gate
I hope you don't mind - I posted this on the main board; watch everyone freak out with habs ranked 3Team Strength Rankings (May 2023)
Welcome to the 2023 Hockey Prospecting team prospect strength rankings! Just like last year, the team strength approach we will be using at Hockey Prospecting is to use our own model, largely based…
SOLR
Registered User
Mrb1p
PRICERSTOPDAPUCK
SOLR
Registered User
Gaston Gingras
Registered User
Team Strength Rankings (May 2023)
Welcome to the 2023 Hockey Prospecting team prospect strength rankings! Just like last year, the team strength approach we will be using at Hockey Prospecting is to use our own model, largely based…
hockeyprospecting.com
DramaticGloveSave
Voice of Reason
- Apr 17, 2017
- 14,816
- 13,739
Mailloux, Hutson and Reinbacher are the clear cut top 3- all defenseman but all different- so the order depends on preference, but all 3 look like top 4 dmen. I’d have them in the order I listed them but it’s close.
Roy is our top forward prospect, followed by Beck and Heineman. Roy looks like a 2nd line winger and PP specialist, while Beck and Heineman look like quality 3rd liners.
I hope you're right with Roy. I am really concerned about his skating. That's why I had him at 7 on my list.
DramaticGloveSave
Voice of Reason
- Apr 17, 2017
- 14,816
- 13,739
He’s never gonna be a great skater, but that’s not his game. And he seems like the most logical candidate to eventually play with Dach and Newhook and both those guys are great skaters so that should offset it a bit.
26Mats
Registered User
- Jun 23, 2018
- 33,299
- 25,699
1. Reinbacher
2. Hutson
3. Mailloux
4. Beck
5. Roy
6. Heineman
7. Engstrom
8. Farrell
9. Mesar
10. Kidney
Assuming RHP, Ylonen, and Barron graduated.
CoopersFalls
Director of Armchair Operations
A quick list after the draft (my personal opinion):
1) Hutson
2) Reinbacher
3) Mailloux
4) Roy
5) Farrell
6) Beck
7) Ylonen
8) Dobes
9) Heineman
10) Mesar
11) Fowler
12) Engstrom
13) Kidney
14) Rohrer
15) Trudeau
16) Kapanen
17) Konyushkov
18) Guindon
19) Volokhin
20) Norlinder
Slaf, RHP, Barron excluded
1) Hutson
2) Reinbacher
3) Mailloux
4) Roy
5) Farrell
6) Beck
7) Ylonen
8) Dobes
9) Heineman
10) Mesar
11) Fowler
12) Engstrom
13) Kidney
14) Rohrer
15) Trudeau
16) Kapanen
17) Konyushkov
18) Guindon
19) Volokhin
20) Norlinder
Slaf, RHP, Barron excluded
Le Barron de HF
Justin make me proud
Quick top 20 ranking without giving a ton of thought and as a wannabe chairman scout:
1. Hutson (B. Campbell - Ghost)
2. Reinbacher (Hamrlik - Provorov)
3. Farrell (JP Dumont - Sam Gagner)
4. Beck (Backlund - Poehling)
5. Roy (J. Williams - Hudon)
6. Engstrom (Voynov - G. Olofsson)
7. Mailloux (Souray - Kostka)
8. Dobes
9. Kidney (Versteeg - Andrighetto)
10. Heineman (Zednik - De La Rose)
11. Mesar (Afinogenov - Palushaj)
12. Kapanen (Kampf - Nokelainen/Nattinen)
13. Trudeau (Savard - Lernout)
14. Fowler
15. Norlinder
16. Guindon
17. Struble
18. Simoneau
19. Rohrer
20. Tuch
HM Mysak
First name in parenthesis = comparable ceiling, 2nd name = floor)
1. Hutson (B. Campbell - Ghost)
2. Reinbacher (Hamrlik - Provorov)
3. Farrell (JP Dumont - Sam Gagner)
4. Beck (Backlund - Poehling)
5. Roy (J. Williams - Hudon)
6. Engstrom (Voynov - G. Olofsson)
7. Mailloux (Souray - Kostka)
8. Dobes
9. Kidney (Versteeg - Andrighetto)
10. Heineman (Zednik - De La Rose)
11. Mesar (Afinogenov - Palushaj)
12. Kapanen (Kampf - Nokelainen/Nattinen)
13. Trudeau (Savard - Lernout)
14. Fowler
15. Norlinder
16. Guindon
17. Struble
18. Simoneau
19. Rohrer
20. Tuch
HM Mysak
First name in parenthesis = comparable ceiling, 2nd name = floor)
I normally do my lists by positions, but it’s clear to me he’ll be first for defensemen and first in a consolidated ranking.
Riggins
Registered User
Surprising how bad our list looks two drafts into a rebuild and with no one left to trade.
Hutson and Reinbacher both have to be studs or we're sunk. We probably also need Dach to surpass what Suzuki is right now.
Hutson and Reinbacher both have to be studs or we're sunk. We probably also need Dach to surpass what Suzuki is right now.
Jaynki
Registered User
- Feb 3, 2014
- 5,858
- 6,029
I have the opposite opinion.
I feel our core has rapidly and clearly took place and although its still infant and need much more development, i think its promising as f***.
(Suzuki, Caufield, Dach, Slafkovsky, Newhook
Guhle, Reinbacher, Hutson)
Slafkovsky, Beck, Hutson, Dach, Reinbacher, Newhook.
Quite the f***ing haul in two years. We don't know how it will evolve but HuGo may have turned this franchise on a dime.
Mrb1p
PRICERSTOPDAPUCK
If Reinbacher isnt first on your list you tweakin..
This kid could play tomorrow and hold his own in the best league in the world.
HuGort
Registered User
- Jan 18, 2022
- 7,980
- 12,322
We really needed some skill forward prospects who aren't critically flawed in the physical department. Roy allegedly cannot skate too well, the rest are either shrimps who don't fit in our already small top6 or they're bottom6ers and therefore irrelevant for the time being. Maybe they'll overperform but it would be good to have a prospect or two who is a protagonist forward for his team... give us some hope.
1.) Reinbacher
2.) Hutson
3.) Mailloux
4.) Roy
5.) Heineman
6.) Engström
7.) Beck
8.) Farrell
9.) Kidney
10.) Dobes
Lots of mobile defence, very - and I can't emphasize this enough - speculative offence. Could be a couple really good forwards in that group, but it could also be absolutely nothing.
2.) Hutson
3.) Mailloux
4.) Roy
5.) Heineman
6.) Engström
7.) Beck
8.) Farrell
9.) Kidney
10.) Dobes
Lots of mobile defence, very - and I can't emphasize this enough - speculative offence. Could be a couple really good forwards in that group, but it could also be absolutely nothing.
