There is no justifiable reason why Dowling is in the lineup. None.
There is no justifiable reason to come down of Dowling. Let me take up some space to explain why.
Justin Dowling is the result of terrible team building in the AHL. Dowling is a #2 center in the AHL. He is more of a defensive center than an offensive one. He's not going to be a big goal scorer but he can find ways to put pucks on the sticks of whomever is out there with him.
Now, let's bring him up because we have lost a center and the those below Jack and Nico are not very good. He stayed up because Haula and then Lazar went out of the lineup. Now take Jack out. Dowling has done what they asked of him. He is -3 on a line that flat out can't score. That says he has been on the ice for 43 games and very few goals have been scored against when he's out there. He has remained because Haula missed some games and then Lazar went down and now Jack.
What was the alternative?
Mercer was never and still isn't a capable productive NHL center if called upon to make up for the loss of a top level center. He did get pushed in there even when Dowling was in the lineup.
- Lazar is a 4th line center at best and 1 good season of 25 Points (his best ever) was far from repeated and injury took him out anyways. His return has been useless in terms of production. Another reason Dowling was playing on a regular basis
- Haula was never going to be productive in a way that would help replace Jack. Nope, instead he went on an extended scoring slump that was so bad he was close to useless in terms of helping to produce goals.
- Dowling did exactly what the Utica fan base could have told you he would do. He played his balls off to the best of his ability and that ability is not of an NHL center.
All of these guys together couldn't combine to produce the goals the Devils would lose when Jack went out.
If Fitz had spent just a few more pennies to sign a top level AHL center, that guy would have filled a call-up role in the middle a lot better than Justin in terms of production. It might also have been wise of an NHL GM to draft some potential Center prospects over his years in charge of NJ's draft selections. He didn't. Knowing he had nothing to fall back on he might have found a 5th center in the off-season rather than counting on roster players to play out of position.
Utica has been the NJ AHL affiliate for 4 seasons and he hasn't drafted a single center, signed an off-season good AHL center, or picked 1 up as the season progressed. Hockey offense channels through the middle. When you don't acquire guys who can facilitate that, you won't be very good. Right now he is paying the consequences of poor drafting, not signing NHL centers in the offseason, and poor Farm management regarding team building.
JUSTIN DOWLING was the best the minor league affiliate had to offer. He was counting on the likes of Mercer, Haula, Lazar to carry the load if an injury occurred.
Want any of the rest in Utica?
- Ryan Schmelzer who is always penciled into a preseason roster as #3 Center. He has been forced to abandon that role every one of Utica's 4 seasons and shoulder the role of #2 and then #1 in 3 of those 4 seasons. Last year's top scorer with 52 points. 52 points is not the kind of numbers a #1 scorer produces in any league which only goes to show you what Fitz has failed to provide them with, SCORING FORWARDS centered by a couple of better than adequate AHL centers.
- Filip Engaras - An ECHL callup who ended up getting an AHL contract after his first season here because Fitz didn't sign a better center and he has become a fixture on the 3rd and 4th lines. 3G/8A/11PTS/48GP.
- Jack Malone - An NCAA free agent signed to an AHL 2-yr contract. He is more of a defensive Center with a knack of finding space at the net front when things go his way. 9G/3A/12Pts/46GP.
- Shane Bowers - A $225K piece of crap. Was a NJ callup playing 4 games with 0Pts. In Utica he has played 54 of their 60 games recording 3G/12A/15 Pts. That's barely better than the 2 guys making minimum AHL paychecks on the 3rd and 4th lines.
- Dowling had put up 2g/2A/4Pts/7GP before his call to NJ.
This is why you have no center callups to NJ. A guy like Cody Glass should have been on Fitz's watch list in the off season rather than counting on piece mealing players into the middle when trouble arose. There should also have been 2 guys in Utica a lot more productive than Dowling, who finished as Utica's 5th leading scorer last seaon with 40Pts.
The Comets failed to qualify for the AHL playoffs both last season and again this season when they will finish dead last in their Division and currently stand at #29 overall out of 32 AHL teams.
If you want to put blame for the poor point production by Justin Dowling on someone, only Tom Fitzgerald can be held responsible. He put no one on the farm that could come close to putting up a respectable showing on an NHL roster. They weren't even capable of putting up competitve AHL numbers.