Prospect Info: Your List: Top Ten 22 or Under

[Schemp]

If you’re his uncle, you can just tell us.

I don't think so. I don't know the promiscuity nature of my brothers though.

 

[MayDayMayDay]

1. Cooley
2. Guenther
3. Geekie
4. Moser
5. Maccelli
6. Lamoureux
7. Lutz
8. Soderstrom
9. Doan
10. Duda

This was hard. I didn't even include Hayton in here because it seems like he's been here for years now. I might slot him in at 8.

 

[Jagged Ice]

What about Fedotov?

 

[Vinny Boombatz]

We really do have more than 10...here is just a list of guys that are having good to great seasons
Cooley/Guenther/Geekie/Moser/Maccelli/Lamoureux/Soderstrom/Doan/Duda/Fedotov/Matikka/Lipkin

Notables: (not having good to great seasons, but younger than 22)
Jenik - lots of piss & vinegar, but need more production
Kolyanchonok - best skating Dman we have at any level, the dude can really skate and plays tough, should be a good bottom pair guy for long time
Lutz - not having a good to great season, but you can see the skill
McCartney - again, not the type of production we'd like to see, but most of the skill production is down in Tucson besides Carcone...is this a coaching issue?

 

[Kaizen]

If you’re his uncle, you can just tell us.

If I was a mod I would have changed his username by now.

 

[Schemp]

If I was a mod I would have changed his username by now.

You don't like the stooges?

 

[Arizonatah Coyetis]

You don't like the stooges?

They're great!

 

[Grimes]

They're great!

best band of all time.

 

[Freddy Sjostrom]

Another viewpoint, Feds in his top 10.

 

[rt]

Another viewpoint, Feds in his top 10.

Wild ass placement of Raty. But that’s cool with me. He’s having a big year. And he’s not that old. Feels like he’s been around forever. Maybe he will end up an asset.

 

[TheLegend]

Where our guys sit on Pronman’s current U23 list.

16. Cooley
37. Guenther
82. Geekie
87. Hayton
90. Moser
132. Jenik
139. Maccelli

For reference… Shane Wright is #26.

IMO he’s got Maccelli way underrated.

https://theathletic.com/4046339/2023/01/17/nhl-players-prospects-ranking-young/?source=user_shared_article

 

[Arizonatah Coyetis]

Hayton too high, Maccelli too low IMO. Even just among our players.

 

[Jakey53]

Where our guys sit on Pronman’s current U23 list.

16. Cooley
37. Guenther
82. Geekie
87. Hayton
90. Moser
132. Jenik
139. Maccelli

For reference… Shane Wright is #26.

IMO he’s got Maccelli way underrated.

https://theathletic.com/4046339/2023/01/17/nhl-players-prospects-ranking-young/?source=user_shared_article

What a dumb list.

 

[TheLegend]

Hayton too high, Maccelli too low IMO. Even just among our players.

Hayton is about right.

Moser should be above Hayton though. And Maccelli well above both of them.

I thought Cooley being 9 spots above Wright said something though. That our scouts nailed it.

 

[TheLegend]

What a dumb list.

You say that about every list.

 

[Jakey53]

You say that about every list.

Well, they are dumb.

 

[rt]

Well, they are dumb.

Make your own.

 

[Dead Coyote]

Oh boy, I see my list will be way different.

1. Guenther
2. Macelli
3. Moser

Clear top 3. Maybe should have Guenther 3rd.

4. Cooley
5. Raty
6. Mitakka
7. Fedotov
8. Geekie
9. Soderstrom
10. Koly

HM: Farinacci, Kirk (if you still count him as a prospect), Duda, Lamoreaux, Lipkin, Jenik, Lutz, Douglas

Raty has been criminally underrated his whole career IMO, same with Fedotov. It makes sense since they both play overseas and most people just don't watch them, but Raty, Macelli, Guenther, Cooley, and Fedotov are our best forward prospects. Geekie is really good too, don't get me wrong, but I have a lot more questions about him than I do any of the others.

 

[JasonDemersWasOkay]

Where would we consider placing Doan? Not having the best year this year but neither is ASU as a whole.

 

[Jakey53]

Make your own.

It would be dumber. These lists really serves no purpose.

 

[rt]

It would be dumber. These lists really serves no purpose.

Why would you open this thread and criticize then?

 

[Jakey53]

Why would you open this thread and criticize then?

Bored, and it's always good for a laugh.

 

[LittlePipes]

Why would you open this thread and criticize then?

armchair strikes again

 

[Dirty Old Man]

Where would we consider placing Doan? Not having the best year this year but neither is ASU as a whole.

I know it's just one game, but I saw him for the first time live last night, and...well...uhh...he didn't look special. Certainly not like the highest draft pick in that game (dunno if RIT had any)

I mean, I don't know what I was expecting, but I think I was hoping for something like when I went to Tucson and thought "man that little Garland guy is *good*. What's his deal?"

 

[Grimes]

I know it's just one game, but I saw him for the first time live last night, and...well...uhh...he didn't look special. Certainly not like the highest draft pick in that game (dunno if RIT had any)

I mean, I don't know what I was expecting, but I think I was hoping for something like when I went to Tucson and thought "man that little Garland guy is *good*. What's his deal?"

I've been to four ASU games this season. I thought Doan was very good in two of those and just ok in the other two. ASU has a pretty small team, I wonder if some games the plan for Doan is to just to focus on doing the dirty work and grind the opposition down. I felt like two games he played like a power forward and the other two a 4th line grinder. It's weird.