Here's my take:
Goaltending:
Hank plays up to his old self, with .92+ svg thanks to a much better defensive zone scheme used by Quinn.
But the back-ups are not up to par. Rangers feel like they could have made the playoffs if it weren't for the rotating door of goalies with .890 svgs and 3+ GAA
Defense:
Pionk steps up as a legitimate NHL player with close to a 40 pt season, and a great transition game. Becomes that 4th option on the rush, and executes on the PP. Confidence grows, and is viewed as a Shattenkirk replacement by Jan.
Shatts, offense is there, but still gets beat wide. Quinn does him a solid and let's him play Number 1 minutes and role... but Rangers sag and lose in the 3rd period, and Shatts gets fatigued when playing past a softer set of 23 minutes. No 1 experiment ends by early November, and Shatts continues to provide great interview content to MSG. Talks a lot about his injury... comes across as an excuse maker.
Smith comes into camp as an NHL level skater.... still not the brightest guy, but takes on a leadership role as a walking life lesson. Plays a much more emotionally engaged game, and wins some fans over. Becomes a reliable PKer, and a solid 5v5 contributer. No offense, but doesn't flop around the ice as much.
Staal. Plays much better than anyone here would give him credit for, but is still a half ice contributor. New system suits him well, and he looks a lot like the Staal of old winning contained one on one battles in the d-zone. No offense.
Skjei takes a step forward, and is recognized as one of the better young defensemen in the game. Offense comes alive as he's that 4th option off the rush, and joins the cycle often. Plays really well, and the two way game becomes better as the season goes along.
DeAngelo starts the season in the minors, and people freak out here as expected. But Tony pairs up nicely with Hajek down there and they form a real deal all situations pairing that pushes for an NHL spot with good chemistry.
Hajek isn't ready to start in the NHL, but goes down in the AHL and plays real well. Plays the game similarly to Hampus Lindholm but the corsi points don't show up. Is underrated by Dec.
Claessen and O'Gara piss a lot of people off here by blocking the kids on defense. But both guys play well in the roles, while some of the veterans prove to be overmatched as the season progresses. The defense is altered mid-season after the kids make a strong push.
Forwards
Kreider responds well to Quinn in the sense that he plays with a greater sense of urgency. But only when trailing by 1. Still doesn't exert full effort, but his timeliness earns him a "KLUTCH" moniker that guys on here run with. Finishes the year with 21 goals and 27 assists, but a 45 point winger is lauded like a star on here because... well I just don't know.
Zucc proves that he's probably best served on a contender's 3rd line. Effort is there, as are the passes, but the legs start to give out. Is traded at the deadline for a disappointing return.
Zibs takes a step forward as a two way center. Still disappears for stretches, but those stretches are shorter. Embraces the role of a top line center and develops a power game where he and Kreider become a little more dynamic instead of trying to do the same things over and over again like they did under AV.
Buch becomes more confident and develops chemistry with Chytil. The two form a skilled duo that start to light it up, but it takes them a while to get there. The pressure is taken off of him a bit and he plays more instinctively. Skills are on display.
Vesey doesn't find a role, and is considered trade bait. Quinn tries to get him to kill penalties and play a defensive role, but Jimbo isn't great at it. He's one of the guys that benefits from not having an absentee coach, but doesn't live up to the role of a very good 3rd liner/
Fast becomes the defensive conscience and utility guy next to Zibs. Starts shooting more, and more accurately. Offensive confidence grows, as does his value. Teams ask about him in trades after running a 20 goal-40 point pace.
Hayes isn't a defensive center, but played one on tv last year. Doesn't play with the type of wingers to maximize his game, but the guy plays his ass off this year to cash in as a UFA. Rangers trade him for an above average return and get a very good prospect and a 1st for him.
Spoons surprises all on here with his offense. Sucks defensively, and is benched when the team is protecting leads, but the guy lights it up on the PP and scores over 50 points leading the team. Reality sets in after a few pats on the back that when Ryan Spooner is your scoring leader with 54 points, your team sucks. Ticket sales go down.
Names disappoints all with a low offensive total, but is complimented for a mediocre defensive game, and for plugging holes in the line-up.
Chytil cracks the line-up early on and becomes a scoring option with Buch. Offense is a bit dry at first, but then things click. Plays ~50 games and score 28 points.
Anderson also cracks the line-up, and becomes a leader on the ice. Shows tremendous compete level and a will to win. By the trade deadline he's given tough matchups but struggles shutting down top line players. Treats it as a great learning experience.
Holland earns a one-way contract.
Belesky gives you some solid games, plays a handful in a goon role, but takes a lot of penalties.
McLeod dresses against the Islanders.
One of Lindqvist/Meskanen pushes for a spot, and creates a lineup where the Rangers are icing 4 lines that can get shots and create chances.
Brett Howden starts to torch the AHL after a slow start and sees some NHL games. Rangers realize he's a much better utility option than Names and put Names out on the trade block.