Holden Caulfield
He's guilty
Bombers break from tradition. They take a guy with significant NFL capital invested in him. Giovanni Manu. He was drafted in Round 4 by the Detroit Lions. He's going to be in NFL for awhile probably.
OT: y - Winnipeg Blue Bombers 2024 Season Thread (12-7) - GAMEDAY! For a dynasty or for a footnote in history. Next Grey Cup vs TOR Nov 17 500pm
- Thread starter Holden Caulfield
- Start date
Holden Caulfield
He's guilty
Bombers took a 5'9'' 158lbs WR from U of Manitoba. I think they are basically done with this draft just taking some crazy flyers.
Nickel eye Heel hers
Happy thoughts
Is there anywhere I can find a write up on the Bomber picks or anyone knowledgeable enough for highlights?
Holden Caulfield
He's guilty
https://3downnation.com/2024/04/30/analyzing-every-pick-in-the-2024-cfl-draft/
Draft is still in the 7th round, but this has a little write up on each player selected.
Bombers take a crazy name in the 7th. OL Michael Vlahogiannis from McGill. Draft guys from 3Down Nation seem to think he's a decent depth guy who played better than his bad testing numbers.
Draft is still in the 7th round, but this has a little write up on each player selected.
Bombers take a crazy name in the 7th. OL Michael Vlahogiannis from McGill. Draft guys from 3Down Nation seem to think he's a decent depth guy who played better than his bad testing numbers.
Holden Caulfield
He's guilty
Bombers 2024 Draft Picks
13. WR Kevens Clercius, Connecticut
14. RB/FB Michael Chris-Ike, Delaware State
17. G Gabe Wallace, Buffalo
20. DT Kyle Samson, UBC
37. LS Ian Leroux, Laval
40. G/C Ethan Kalra, Waterloo
46. G/T Giovanni Manu, UBC
55. WR AK Gassama, Manitoba
64. C Michael Vlahogiannis, McGill
73. DL Owen Hubert, McMaster
The first 4 are the players to watch. After that we've got at least 3 players who are returning to school (Leroux, Kalra, Hubert), 1 who's NFL committed (Manu), and some long shots.
13. WR Kevens Clercius, Connecticut
14. RB/FB Michael Chris-Ike, Delaware State
17. G Gabe Wallace, Buffalo
20. DT Kyle Samson, UBC
37. LS Ian Leroux, Laval
40. G/C Ethan Kalra, Waterloo
46. G/T Giovanni Manu, UBC
55. WR AK Gassama, Manitoba
64. C Michael Vlahogiannis, McGill
73. DL Owen Hubert, McMaster
The first 4 are the players to watch. After that we've got at least 3 players who are returning to school (Leroux, Kalra, Hubert), 1 who's NFL committed (Manu), and some long shots.
Holden Caulfield
He's guilty
I'm far from an expert. It's a healthy mix of normal Bomber type drafts it would seem though. Bombers tend not to go "flashy". This is once again certainly not "flashy" other than the late Manu selection, but that's a huge long shot to pay off. The guys here I kept hearing/reading things like hard working, love contact, plays better than they tested (gamers). Pretty much what they always target.
I was a big fan of Clercius. He was the guy I was low key kinda hoping on at 8. Was hoping for some variation of Striker, Benedet, Brubacher, Wiebe, and Chris-Ike in the 2nd. So getting two of those targets is nice. Filled some key holes, IMO.
With Clercius they get a guy who honestly sounds so much like Bailey. Loves to engage from his WR position, great size, good hands, enough speed even if not a burner. I think he's a quality depth pick. With Demski, Wolitarsky, 2023 3rd round Jeremy Murphy and Clercius you have a real solid Canadian WR corps with plenty of depth. Clercius is a guy who can probably stick on the roster and contribute alot more on ST than a Murphy can so he's got good odds on being on the roster.
Chris-Ike just fills a huge need. They were so desperate to get a FB on the roster last year they used an American LS in Damien Jackson for many games. They needed someone who can come in and block just a little, catch out of the backfield a little, and add some value on ST. It sounds like this guy can do that, while adding some additional depth at RB in emergency situations. He seems like he could be a player like Ante Milanovic-Litre.
Gabe Wallace was the bottom of the "top" tier of OL available. Will need some time to adjust to the Canadian game, likely needs to cut some weight. But has upside and time in Winnipeg where he'll serve as the 7th OL this year.
Samson I don't know much about. Sounds like a pure interior guy. With Lawson, Thomas already on the roster and the fact that they made no move to replace Ricky Walker makes me think they might try to run 2 Canadians on the interior. They have Tanner Schmekel also returning, albeit I think they might be moving him to OL (EDIT: Sorry I might be getting Schmekel and Kornelson from last year mixed up as it might be Kornelson they tried to move to OL last year). So we'll see.
As for the rest, alot of futures picks. Not a bad strategy considering with how packed their roster is it's going to be hard for any later guys to crack the roster. A long term replacement for Benson is nice. It sounds like the U of Manitoba guy is an electric playmaker, but likely just too small. But if he can overcome that he could even be a player for them.
Only thing I'm a bit mystified about is that they didn't draft a LB/STer. With the Briggs retirement and injuries/retirements having held back some of their other recent draftees I felt there was a need to add depth there. They didn't do that here. They did draft 2 LB/DB STers in the Global draft which I know very little about, maybe they think one of them can step right onto the roster and help out there. Or they feel a returnee like Max Charbonneau can make the roster and contribute. Not sure. I watched Charbonneau in camp quite a bit (LB's seemed to be right in front of us when I went to camp each time last year) and he looked stiff and awkward so I'm not holding out much hope there, but we'll see.
Overall I'd say they did fine. But we won't really know until at least the start of the year. Ideally you'd like to see those top 4 all crack the roster.
Gabe Wallace is a project and ideally would need 1.5 - 2 years to become pro-ready as an OL. His current form would not be conducive in pass protection.
bustamente
Fraud Supporter
I would say successfull. I'd say top 3, after the Rider's, Stamps
Holden Caulfield
He's guilty
I respect your opinion, and hell you probably know better than I as I don't follow college/university sports. However based on everything I've read and seen this off-season...
I don't rate Sask's draft that highly myself. Hergel is a good gamble late in the 1st, but at 3rd? IMO Sask needed help along OL now, and Hergel has a decent shot to stick in NFL. Bombers took Gray a few years ago at 8 which is a more appropriate spot for a undrafted FA signee with under 100k in guarantees.
Wiebe is going to miss most if not all of his rookie year with an injury. Again 12 seemed high for that.
Straker in the 4th seems like great value, but him sliding that long tells me some teams just flat out removed him from their boards. Wonder why that is.
Ajou Ajou may as well just get a tattoo on his forehead of a red flag. Poorly testing, poor work ethic, can't stick in any program. It's a fine flyer in the 7th on a guy who was once considered in the same category as a John Metchie, but that was a LONG time ago, several teams ago in fact.
Calgary was just so-so as well, IMO. That DB they got seems to be highly thought of. Gotta like the upside there. I think they panicked with the trade up to reach for an OL at 8. Their 3rd rounder doesn't really grade out as a CFLer. St-Cyr appears to be a steal in the 8th, but again I'm naturally leary of sliders as that means alot of teams passed on him a bunch of times.
To be honest, my favourite draft was the Tiger-Cats. Dumoulin Duguay in the first looks like a real solid OL. Brubacher in the 2nd has massive upside, in fact many are predicting he'll be signing down south in a year or two. Like a Kongbo or Uguak. Various reasons had those NFL level measurable guys in CFL and after a year or two as depth guys in CFL they signed in NFL. Many predict that's what will happen with Brubacher and his elite testing, but needs more refinement in his technique. But the upside is drool worthy. Peterson in the 4th is a quality RB, one that has a strong possibility to outperform his draft slot. I think he'll carve out a nice career with a Johnny Augustine/Keenan Lafrance type career as a floor. Baker and Townsend were two UBC LB's I was hoping the Bombers would target in the late rounds as LB/STers.
And honestly the damn Argos had a good one. Mital in the 1st is a potential home run, then some solid potential guys, particularly all around the line. Only pick I didn't like in Dankwah as I don't think he'll ever adjust enough to be a CFLer, but otherwise looks like a solid class.
bustamente
Fraud Supporter
sipowicz
The thrill is gone
- Mar 16, 2011
- 32,260
- 43,252
Holden Caulfield
He's guilty
Enock Makonzo released by the Elks. Good position fit to backup up Redha Kramdhi. Makonzo made 10 starts at SLB over 2 seasons in Edmonton.
WolfHouse
Registered User
- Oct 4, 2020
- 10,741
- 16,665
Their is no guarantee that Hergel lasts with the Saints as a UFA. He could be another Hunter, or he could be up this season. BC just signed Covington, who spent 7 years in the NFL.
If it was a Manu, Johnson or Adams, then it would've been a questionable pick. The Rider's got the best all around guard of the draft though.
Wiebe is early on his road to recovery, according to an interview. Earliest return date could be mid season.
Straker could start for them at SLB, he is that good. Supposed the Bomber's didn't draft him as depth behind Kramdi.
Let's not forget Johnson from Purdue. Yes he has injury problems, but he has the ability to play tackle at the next level.
They could potentially get four good starters out of this draft.
Holden Caulfield
He's guilty
Bombers got their entire draft class signed with 2 exceptions.
OL Giovanni Manu who will likely be signing his NFL rookie deal soon and is many years away from signing in CFL if ever.
And
RB Michael Chris-Ike who is currently doing the NFL mini-camp tour and won't be free to sign for a couple of weeks.
OL Giovanni Manu who will likely be signing his NFL rookie deal soon and is many years away from signing in CFL if ever.
And
RB Michael Chris-Ike who is currently doing the NFL mini-camp tour and won't be free to sign for a couple of weeks.
Holden Caulfield
He's guilty
Chad Kelly suspended for a minimum of nine games.
www.cfl.ca
Edit to add:
"According to the league, Kelly’s return to the field will be dependent on undergoing confidential assessments by an independent expert and attending mandatory counselling sessions conducted by an expert in gender-based violence. At the conclusion of that process, Kelly will be reassessed, with the league reserving the right to modify his discipline."
Based on his past antics, Kelly likely either takes this as a major wake-up call, or he believes he has done nothing wrong, and this is it for him. If he declines the mandatory counselling you gotta think he’s done.
The contract was stupid to begin with, but I wonder what kind of guarantees it has? I can’t remember. Toronto might try to get out of it.
Chad Kelly suspended minimum of 9-games for violating gender-based violence policy - CFL.ca
Toronto Argonauts quarterback Chad Kelly has been suspended for 2024’s preseason games and a minimum of nine further games for violating the Canadian Football League’s (CFL) Gender-based Violence Policy.
www.cfl.ca
Edit to add:
"According to the league, Kelly’s return to the field will be dependent on undergoing confidential assessments by an independent expert and attending mandatory counselling sessions conducted by an expert in gender-based violence. At the conclusion of that process, Kelly will be reassessed, with the league reserving the right to modify his discipline."
Based on his past antics, Kelly likely either takes this as a major wake-up call, or he believes he has done nothing wrong, and this is it for him. If he declines the mandatory counselling you gotta think he’s done.
The contract was stupid to begin with, but I wonder what kind of guarantees it has? I can’t remember. Toronto might try to get out of it.
Holden Caulfield
He's guilty
I'll be honest, I did not see a suspension this heavy coming. Thought the CFL was going to chicken out. I'm thinking they must know more than we do, cause the denials from Kelly and Argos have been so strong. Don't think CFL would have stepped out on a ledge this thin without knowledge that yeah there's for sure something to the allegations.
I agree with @snowkiddin that Kelly has a choice.
But Kelly doesnt seem the type to learn. Based on his history and the fact that his family is loaded so he doesn't need the money he might just flee to the US and never step foot back in Canada. That'd be a Chad Kelly move.
I agree with @snowkiddin that Kelly has a choice.
But Kelly doesnt seem the type to learn. Based on his history and the fact that his family is loaded so he doesn't need the money he might just flee to the US and never step foot back in Canada. That'd be a Chad Kelly move.
bustamente
Fraud Supporter
So Rourke is out of a job down south again and Kelly is now suspended and in all probability the Argos will seek relief might even try to void the contract. Argos really blew it with this idiot, even TSN tried to make him into the next coming QB. Argos should get no relief from the contract.
bustamente
Fraud Supporter
I'm dumb, what did Kelly do ?Chad Kelly suspended for a minimum of nine games.
Chad Kelly suspended minimum of 9-games for violating gender-based violence policy - CFL.ca
Toronto Argonauts quarterback Chad Kelly has been suspended for 2024’s preseason games and a minimum of nine further games for violating the Canadian Football League’s (CFL) Gender-based Violence Policy.
Edit to add:
"According to the league, Kelly’s return to the field will be dependent on undergoing confidential assessments by an independent expert and attending mandatory counselling sessions conducted by an expert in gender-based violence. At the conclusion of that process, Kelly will be reassessed, with the league reserving the right to modify his discipline."
Based on his past antics, Kelly likely either takes this as a major wake-up call, or he believes he has done nothing wrong, and this is it for him. If he declines the mandatory counselling you gotta think he’s done.
The contract was stupid to begin with, but I wonder what kind of guarantees it has? I can’t remember. Toronto might try to get out of it.
Holden Caulfield
He's guilty
A former Argos team trainer has sued Kelly and the Argos after her contract wasn't renewed.
She is claiming Kelly repeatedly harassed her and after she spurned his "advances" he orchestrated to make sure her contract wasn't renewed. Inappropriate comments and physical contact veering towards SA is included in the allegations.
Not Kelly related but she also apparently brought it forward to Argos management. Where again allegedly Argos told her basically to shut the f*** up.
WolfHouse
Registered User
- Oct 4, 2020
- 10,741
- 16,665
