Matthews has been the most consistent Maple Leaf on the team this year and if he's second it's only to the man in the thread title. Matthews had a terrible giveaway and a mediocre three games, but holding him to ridiculous standards and treating him differently than all the others is foolish. Every single Maple Leaf has had bad games and made terrible plays this year. Tyson Barrie is a giveaway machine and crap defensively, yet he's playing 20+ minutes every night. Marner coughs up the puck, JT looks lost, Kerfoot sucks, all these guys are out there making mistakes and they're not getting benched or demoted, or shifted out of their playing spots. Matthews is playing like a Hart trophy candidate this year and a single bad giveaway does not mean that he needs to be treated like a rookie defenseman. He's been our best player by a goddamn mile this year, he should be given the C, not benched. Sheesh.