Who will end up as a better player: Bedard, Celebrini, Michkov, Demidov or Hutson?

[Bank Shot]

I'll take Celebrini first.
Michkov and Bedard.
Hutson.
Haven't seen Demidov enough to say on him.

 

[Kojo]

He seems like a nice kid but so far Hutson>>>>Celebrini

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

He seems like a nice kid but so far Hutson>>>>Celebrini

Celebrini is an 18 year old leading his team in scoring. No prospect is ">>>>" Celebrini.

I'm a big Hutson fan, but c'mon.

 

[Galchenyuk15]

5. Hutson. ok, at first it was a meme, but it went too far and it looks like people actually believed he would be a star. He is an offensive defenseman and can score some secondary PP assists. But he doesn't have the tools to make a real difference like Makar or Hughes and he's very average defensively. His ceiling is Tony DeAngelo with a better attitude. So No. 2 offensive D. Which is good, but not as good as Demidov and Celebrini. And obviously not even comparable to Bedard or Michkov

Since the 4 nations cup :

Makar 8-20=28 in 21 +13
Hutson 3-20=23 in 21 +18 with only 2 negative game in that run
Q. Hughes 2-11=13 in 16 -15 with only 3 positive game in that run

Tony DeAngelo thanks for the laugh! How to said I don't know my hockey without telling I don't know my hockey ....

PS: You need to watch some habs game with your eyes OPEN ...

 

[Patty Ice]

It says a lot you avoided the initial question when pressed, then re phrased the question so you could keep your answer

It was a simple question, who is the best of the group •right now •

Wasn’t who you’d take to build a team around, or who you think will be best.

Again. Since you are having a hard time comprehending, yes I read the question right and yes I think Bedard and Celebrini are better players this season GASP

You are truly are worthy of your username.

 

[Jurivan Demidovsky]

That includes this season. I read it just fine.

Says a lot that a good portion of the fanbase has to glaze/seek validation on the main boards for "their guy. "

What are you basing this season off of? Because now that's a Calder discussion. So what's your basis? Point production? Defensive numbers? Homerism?

 

[Patty Ice]

What are you basing this season off of? Because now that's a Calder discussion. So what's your basis? Point production? Defensive numbers? Homerism?

The fact that two teenagers are leading in production for a couple of shithouse franchises with minimal support.

But if you really want to go the LoOk aT THe NuMbeRs route.

.86 ppg > .83 ppg

 

[Favster]

1. Michkov. 120+ point player, will be close to Kucherov. Will probably have less assists, but more goals. Something like 50+70 is what you can expect from him regularly
2. Bedard. Not McDavid, not even MacKinnon, but still a 100+ point center easily.
3. Demidov. Offensive winger like Panarin. 85-100 point player.
4. Celebrini. PPG center with slightly above average defense. I have no idea where the myth came from that he is a defensive beast. It's based on nothing. -100 and gets undressed every other game.
5. Hutson. ok, at first it was a meme, but it went too far and it looks like people actually believed he would be a star. He is an offensive defenseman and can score some secondary PP assists. But he doesn't have the tools to make a real difference like Makar or Hughes and he's very average defensively. His ceiling is Tony DeAngelo with a better attitude. So No. 2 offensive D. Which is good, but not as good as Demidov and Celebrini. And obviously not even comparable to Bedard or Michkov

Tony DeAngelo with a batter attitude. LOL. This place is hilarious

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

The fact that two teenagers are leading in production for a couple of shithouse franchises with minimal support.

But if you really want to go the LoOk aT THe NuMbeRs route.

.86 ppg > .83 ppg

I think you could make the argument that Celebrini is better than Hutson right now, it's not a crazy thing to suggest.

But there really is nothing to suggest that Bedard is better than Hutson right now. He's been really really not good this year.

 

[Patty Ice]

I think you could make the argument that Celebrini is better than Hutson right now, it's not a crazy thing to suggest.

But there really is nothing to suggest that Bedard is better than Hutson right now. He's been really really not good this year.

My assertion is if you were to switch Celebrini for Hutson or Bedard for Hutson on their respective teams, do you think he would be as effective?

I'm not in the business of disparaging Hutson. He's an amazing talent. I think he makes some underappreciated defensive reads and will always be criticized for his defensive play as is the life of an offensive dman. I think he can be an effective defensive presence because of his smarts and vision and despite his size limitations. I enjoy watching guys like him succeed (I'm a huge Cagnoni fan as is obvious). I just don't think he would be producing as Bedard and Celebrini have if he was on either team.

 

[Frank Drebin]

Again. Since you are having a hard time comprehending, yes I read the question right and yes I think Bedard and Celebrini are better players this season GASP

You are truly are worthy of your username.

Sorry I offended you, just don’t dodge questions in the future we’ll have no problems

 

[Patty Ice]

Sorry I offended you, just don’t dodge questions in the future we’ll have no problems

FFS I didn't dodge the question. I'm sorry I didn't glaze your boy like you need me to.

 

[Frank Drebin]

The fact that two teenagers are leading in production for a couple of shithouse franchises with minimal support.

But if you really want to go the LoOk aT THe NuMbeRs route.

.86 ppg > .83 ppg

Age has nothing to do with who is a better player today

 

[Frank Drebin]

FFS I didn't dodge the question. I'm sorry I didn't glaze your boy like you need me to.

You did, and you’re still being dishonest.

You don’t have to glaze, you can just be quiet

 

[Patty Ice]

You did, and you’re still being dishonest.

You don’t have to glaze, you can just be quiet

Or you can go back to your echo chamber if opinions hurt your feelings.

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

My assertion is if you were to switch Celebrini for Hutson or Bedard for Hutson on their respective teams, do you think he would be as effective?

I'm not in the business of disparaging Hutson. He's an amazing talent. I think he makes some underappreciated defensive reads and will always be criticized for his defensive play as is the life of an offensive dman. I think he can be an effective defensive presence because of his smarts and vision and despite his size limitations. I enjoy watching guys like him succeed (I'm a huge Cagnoni fan as is obvious). I just don't think he would be producing as Bedard and Celebrini have if he was on either team.

Considering guys like Donato and Teravainen are pacing with Bedard, it wouldn't shock me at all if Hutson were still a 50+ point dman in Chicago, while playing a much more complete game than Bedard.

Bedard is 9th on the Hawks in 5v5 p/60, Hutson is 7th on the Habs (a much stronger team) as a defenseman.

 

[George Lebay]

This thread was doomed to turn into 'oh, he's a Habs prospect so I'll just say he sucks'..

 

[Jurivan Demidovsky]

The fact that two teenagers are leading in production for a couple of shithouse franchises with minimal support.

But if you really want to go the LoOk aT THe NuMbeRs route.

.86 ppg > .83 ppg

Hutson is a defenseman though... so what's the excuse for that? A defenseman out producing a forward, and doing that while being one of the best defenders in the league. I can't wait to hear this excuse..

 

[Frank Drebin]

Or you can go back to your echo chamber if opinions hurt your feelings.

This is my echo chamber. Guess what, you’re not the first guy who’s had an opinion on Hutson without actually ever watching a game of his. Those are the best ones

 

[JustAHabFan]

Can't wait until Hutson win the Calder this year.

 

[Penguin Suited Up]

My assertion is if you were to switch Celebrini for Hutson or Bedard for Hutson on their respective teams, do you think he would be as effective?

I'm not in the business of disparaging Hutson. He's an amazing talent. I think he makes some underappreciated defensive reads and will always be criticized for his defensive play as is the life of an offensive dman. I think he can be an effective defensive presence because of his smarts and vision and despite his size limitations. I enjoy watching guys like him succeed (I'm a huge Cagnoni fan as is obvious). I just don't think he would be producing as Bedard and Celebrini have if he was on either team.

I just want to understand whether there’s anyone out there tracking Hutson’s head fakes/60.

I’m surprised that guy hasn’t given himself whiplash yet.

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

My assertion is if you were to switch Celebrini for Hutson or Bedard for Hutson on their respective teams, do you think he would be as effective?

I'm not in the business of disparaging Hutson. He's an amazing talent. I think he makes some underappreciated defensive reads and will always be criticized for his defensive play as is the life of an offensive dman. I think he can be an effective defensive presence because of his smarts and vision and despite his size limitations. I enjoy watching guys like him succeed (I'm a huge Cagnoni fan as is obvious). I just don't think he would be producing as Bedard and Celebrini have if he was on either team.

I am sure he would. He only has 4 forwards with any offensive ability to work with now and he is racking up points. He is very smart defensively as well.

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

Can't wait until Hutson win the Calder this year.

The voters are usually idiots. Anything could happen.

 

[Johnny HFBOARDS]

Cele

 

[StrawHatEklund]

Celebrini
Hutson/Bedard
Michkov

Demidov (jury is out on him until he performs in NHL).