who is your teams worst goalie in the last decades

[Breakers]

Spencer Martin in Vancouver

He would let in shots where the other team was looking for a whistle

No idea why he got claimed on waivers

 

[innitfam]

Collin Delia for Vancouver.

 

[SmoggyTwinkles]

Probably Sparks

He can light the fire that sends Optimus Reims to hell.

 

[Bizz]

Antti Niemi.

I still can't believe Doug Wilson wasted Thornton and Marleau's prime with this sieve in net.

 

[Gregor Samsa]

Flyers fan here

Statistically? Too many memories I block out. Bryz was terrible especially with his contract. Leighton gave up the worst goal and even though it was a cup winner in OT I’ve always wondered how it’s been framed on Blackhawk highlights

Worst in general? Hart for obvious reasons

 

[BlackAdam]

2022-2023 Samsonov was amazing. i dunno who showed up a year later but no way Samsonov was the worst leafs goalie when there were guys like kidd, toskala, sparks, hutchinson, mrazek and enroth

 

[TruePowerSlave]

Georgiev sucks big time.

To make it worse they play the guy all the time and refuse to upgrade. Even the coach licks his ass every chance he gets.

 

[torniojaws]

Aside from Price, all of them?

 

[Bowski]

As a "starter" Tristan Jarry.

He either has no confidence cause he sucks, or the D sucks and he's their suck victim, or he sucks cause Sulivan plays him too much. Either way, he sucks!

Come the new year, get the hospital bed ready for recovery and the eventual "playoff push" collapse. Last year Nedeljkovic took care of the later part so Jarry could sit on his fat farmer ass and not hurt his confidence.

A bunch of initial hype, but none of the accolades. At this point, a stiched-up corpse of Matt Murray would be preferable; at least it would be in position most of the time.

 

[Caps8112]

Justin Peters gets a pass for his time on the caps, as his contributions were irrelevant. If its the last 10 years, this is easily a tie between the dumpster fire of failure and disaster that is Samsonov and Vanecek, Together they wasted 168 games of Ovechkins career with their dumb****ery. They were so awful that the caps won 93 games in spite of their presence on the ice. In 10 playoff appearances they won 2 games. GMBM should have been fired for all of us having to endure these two. I remember smiling when the dumbass devils and leafs signed these buffoons. Both teams were desperate for goaltending and believed these two were the answer. Shocker they were horrible for those 2 teams also.

 

[tarheelhockey]

Spencer Martin is maybe worst goalie I've seen in long time

I try not to give goalies too hard a time, especially AHL callups, but Martin is actively working to disprove the idea that goalies are more or less the same.







You just can’t win hockey games with stuff like that happening routinely.

 

[Pokecheque]

Yeah I think it's gotta be Georgiev.

 

[Ceremony]

Watch tonight's Avalanche game to see him in action!

 

[blink]

Gillies or Domingue for the Devils....they were both horrible

 

[Zenos]

Silovs for the Canucks. Small sample, but most of it was during the playoffs last year.
Otherwise we went from Miller to Markstrom to Demko.

As an Oilers fan it angers me that the Canucks have managed to ship-out / let walk more quality starters over the last decade-plus than the Oilers have had at all.

Crawford, Luongo, Miller, Markstrom (and now Demko), is pretty wild. Meanwhile, "we‘ve“ had one good year from Talbot and a good showing last season from Skinner in that timeframe. And a whole bunch of garbage.

 

[HabzSauce]

I try not to give goalies too hard a time, especially AHL callups, but Martin is actively working to disprove the idea that goalies are more or less the same.







You just can’t win hockey games with stuff like that happening routinely.

Dear God my condolences he looks even worse than he did in VAN

 

[Bear of Bad News]

He either has no confidence cause he sucks,

They should have someone tell him "hey, you suck as a goalie. And also, you have no confidence." That's good coaching.

 

[Crow]

I can’t think of any that were too bad, not recently for a full season.

Forsberg maybe was the worst

 

[Mandar]

All our goalies have been pretty good lately.
My answer would be Weekes. Hated when he would be playing whereas pretty much every other backup I can think of I was fine with having in net

Weekes is definitely a good answer.....but I'm thinking the NYR honor goes to Marty Biron.....and Herlt would definitely agree.

 

[tarheelhockey]

Dear God my condolences he looks even worse than he did in VAN

Note in the first clip the commentator mentions 3 goals in 5 shots.

 

[Crow]

Flyers fan here

Statistically? Too many memories I block out. Bryz was terrible especially with his contract. Leighton gave up the worst goal and even though it was a cup winner in OT I’ve always wondered how it’s been framed on Blackhawk highlights

Worst in general? Hart for obvious reasons

Overwhelmingly as an amazingly well placed shot from an impossible angle. Lol

 

[Rants Mulliniks]

He can light the fire that sends Optimus Reims to hell.

Believe it or not, Reimer sits 79th all time in Games Played and 87th all time in wins.

 

[Ole Gil]

Scott Darling. And that's taking into account the Hurricanes had a zamboni driver play goalie.

 

[Kielbasa]

By the Numbers: Eddie Lack was diabolically bad for the Flames in the four games he played.

By the Vibes: Mike Smith absolutely stank, what a colossal tool.

 

[Suntouchable13]

For the Leafs: Sparks, sure. But Jonas Gustavsson and Jon Bernier were both f***ing awful compared to their hype.