I selected Nylander.
We know what we will get from the big 3. We know what we will get from the major support staff (Foligno, Hyman, Mikheyev, Kerfoot). We know what we will get from the aging vets, and no offence to them but they are probably not going to impact if we are winning or losing a series (a game, maybe, but not a series).
If Nylander can be an impact player both offensively and on the defenisve side of the puck that is a HUGE bonus to us. For all those other guys, I think if they equal their season result we'll be fine. I think we need more than what Nylander has brought to date (this season and past seasons). We need someone to bring it, who doesn't always with consistency.