93gilmour93
Registered User
- Feb 27, 2010
- 19,533
- 22,970
this version is great but yet i still prefer the ccr version. fogerty sings great on it, and you can just bug out to it for over 11 minutes.Hard question because there are so many great answers.
I'm leaning toward Aretha. She can sing a terrible song and her voice still makes it listenable. If the song is good, her voice makes it legendary.
The male category is tough because there's a bit of a cluster at the top. Maybe Freddie Mercury.
My favorite single vocal performance is Marvin Gaye's version of "Heard It Through the Grapevine". He absolutely slays every line in that song with great vocal runs, performing every single syllable with intent, while somehow still making it sound as natural as casual speech. Showing off chops is one thing, seducing an audience is something totally different... he did both at the same time across an entire track.
Jim Morrison is a complicated pick for me. I absolutely LOVE his voice. It was fantastic. But I absolutely HATE The Doors so in order to hear it I need to listen to music I legitimately don't like at all.Difficult for me to get it down to one favorite male singer..
Layne Staley
G. Danzig
Jim Morrison
Elvis
Smokey for the male singer, but I forgot Billie Holiday who trumps everybody else.Smokey Robinson
So that means you prefer Morrison's solo records to his work with The Doors?Jim Morrison is a complicated pick for me. I absolutely LOVE his voice. It was fantastic. But I absolutely HATE The Doors so in order to hear it I need to listen to music I legitimately don't like at all.
You seriously can't enjoy a person's vocals even though they're singing songs you dislike? Really? I didn't think it was that out of the ordinary.So that means you prefer Morrison's solo records to his work with The Doors?
Kidding. I'm trying to figure out how you came to love a voice that is associated solely through songs you dislike.
It wasn't meant as a criticism. It just struck me as unusual to single out someone's voice while disliking the music the voice is associated with. For me, a singing voice can only be judged in context of the songs it sings.You seriously can't enjoy a person's vocals even though they're singing songs you dislike? Really? I didn't think it was that out of the ordinary.
i get it. a lot of doors songs have those keyboards all over the place, making it sound like you're attending a creepy crap carnival. but damn to despise them - aah okay.Favorite male singer for me would have to be Freddie Mercury. Female not sure.
Jim Morrison is a complicated pick for me. I absolutely LOVE his voice. It was fantastic. But I absolutely HATE The Doors so in order to hear it I need to listen to music I legitimately don't like at all.
Well... I really like Bon Jovi's voice (at his peak, not today - he could really play on different emotions, and with impressive range), but there's barely two or three songs that I think are "ok", the rest is just pure crap...It wasn't meant as a criticism. It just struck me as unusual to single out someone's voice while disliking the music the voice is associated with. For me, a singing voice can only be judged in context of the songs it sings.
Maybe a better question is: what music would you have liked to have heard Morrison sing?
Bianca CastafioreEnrico Pallazzo
Yes!Some of my favs that haven't been mentioned yet:
Howlin' Wolf