Who is the 9th best player so far in the 21st Century?

[Xspyrit]

I mean MacKinnon is on the list, so I think Makar should be too. Their accomplishments are pretty much equal

A Cup, a Calder ok, but that's where it stops. Makar even has a Smythe than MacKinnon doesn't have

MacK in Hart voting last 7 years (when he was 22) : Hart 1-2-2-3-5-6

Makar in Hart voting : Hart 8-12

 

[Albatros]

 

[the_fan]

A Cup, a Calder ok, but that's where it stops. Makar even has a Smythe than MacKinnon doesn't have

MacK in Hart voting last 7 years (when he was 22) : Hart 1-2-2-3-5-6

Makar in Hart voting : Hart 8-12

I’m an Avs fan and don’t want to sound like a homer, but it’s just seems right to have Makar on the list but only if we gonna have MacKinnon, or neither one should be on the list. Just my opinion

 

[daver]

Toews in this picture is the equivalent of a seat filler at the Academy awards.

 

[Rafafouille]

Bergy. Cup, 3 finals, 6 Selkes.

 

[NyQuil]

 

[Xspyrit]

I’m an Avs fan and don’t want to sound like a homer, but it’s just seems right to have Makar on the list but only if we gonna have MacKinnon, or neither one should be on the list. Just my opinion

Only reason Makar is not on the list is because he only played 335 regular season games and 71 playoffs games. Re-do this poll in 10 years and he's going to end quite high in this ranking

MacKinnon will win the 9th place and could probably end up a little bit higher with a few more years of elite play.

 

[Bouboumaster]

Mackinnon

 

[wetcoast]

Mack won the last poll 25-10-10 over Pronger/Jagr time to move onto poll #10.

Who is the 10th best player so far in the 21st Century?

Just like in previous polls only use any players 2000-2001 onwards to project where they rank "all time" in the 21st century as though anything previous to that doesn't exist. Top 9 so far is here 1.Crosby 3. Ovechkin 3. McDavid 4. Lidstrom 5. Malkin 6. Brodeur 7. Kucherov 8. Kane 9. Mackinnon...

forums.hfboards.com