Who had the tougher competition for individual awards, Crosby or McDavid?

[daver]

BS. Crosby was not good enough in 2005-06 to compete with Jagr for trophies. So its not true that he did not have to compete with Jagr for trophies. He also beat a lesser version of Jagr post-shoulder surgery 2 seasons before Jagr left for the KHL, so he did face Jagr, even if it was not prime Jagr.

Jagr was not a realistic competitor for any seasons where Crosby was a favourite for the Art/Hart.