OT: Who Are Your Top 5 Rangers

[Glen Sathers Cigar]

Favorites right now:

1.Hank
2. Girardi
3. Richards
4. Zucc
5. McD

 

[Kokoschka]

Favorite, or the best?

Favorite:
Step
Stralman
Brass
Hank
McD

Best(hodgepodge of playoffs, reg season, and generally talent and skill):
Hank


Zucc
McD
Staal
Kreider

I know we're all still on the hype train, but no. Just no.

 

[mandiblesofdoom]

Favorites are

McD
Hagelin
Stralman
Zuccarello
many tied for fifth.

 

[Fletch]

top 5? It's funny, as I've gotten over I've become a lot less attached. If I had to throw names out I would say Staal, Kreider, Stepan, Lundqvist and Girardi. Maybe I feel that those guys are the keys and have the most talent (or whose styles I like the most) and I just root for them more than others to do well (outside guys like Nash, Richards and St. Louis for whom I just have high expectations).

 

[Flavius]

I know we're all still on the hype train, but no. Just no.

If you don't believe Zucc to be one of the best on the team I could see that. But seriously, not McDonagh?

 

[we want cup]

Lundqvist
Staal
Stepan
Kreider
Zucc

EDIT: Wait is this supposed to be favorites or best?

 

[JESSEWENEEDTOCOOK]

If you don't believe Zucc to be one of the best on the team I could see that. But seriously, not McDonagh?

He's referring to you ranking Zuccarello over McD.

Which I agree is silly.

 

[Wolfy*]

If you don't believe Zucc to be one of the best on the team I could see that. But seriously, not McDonagh?

The two you mention actually received awards this season...

McD is not only a damn good defenseman, he's one of the best in the league.

Zucc is our point leader, that makes him one our best players no matter what some people say.

 

[Siddi]

This one is tough. For example, regular season McDonagh and Zucc AINEC before Hank, in the playoffs, especially last series Hank AINEC is first.

Now i have seen it all

 

[Smur]

Zucc
Henke
Boyler
McD
G

 

[Bluenote13]

1)Pierre Larouche
2)Ron Duguay
3)Anders Hedberg
4)Jan Erixon
5)Per Djoos

 

[Siddi]

Judging by playoff performane my list would look like this:

1.Hank
2.Boyle
3.Staal
4.MSL
5.D.Moore

HM; Richards, Zucc, McD, Kreider

 

[Vinny DeAngelo]

1. Hank
2. Mcdonagh
3. Staal/Girardi
5a. Kreider
5b.zucc


Staal and Girardi both have their nights so I can't say who is 3 and who is 4.
Same with kreider... He's all over the place now(in a good way) but for a long while he was invisible during the regular season

 

[Miamipuck]

Judging by playoff performane my list would look like this:

1.Hank
2.Boyle
3.Staal
4.MSL
5.D.Moore

HM; Richards, Zucc, McD, Kreider

On playoff performance?

 

[Siddi]

On playoff performance?

I realise McD was playing sub-par against Philly and early in the Pitt series but game 5 and forward against Pitt he was looking like the old McD, hence the honorary mention.

 

[McDunna with Fries]

1. Miller
2. Fast
3. Dorsett
4. Carcillo
5. Klein

 

[Miamipuck]

I realise McD was playing sub-par against Philly and early in the Pitt series but game 5 and forward against Pitt he was looking like the old McD, hence the honorary mention.

What about your compatriot, Stralman? No love for a fellow Swede.

 

[Bleed Ranger Blue]

1)Pierre Larouche
2)Ron Duguay
3)Anders Hedberg
4)Jan Erixon
5)Per Djoos

Youre showing your age!

 

[NYR89]

My 1-4 are pretty clear cut in my mind:

Lundqvist
McDonagh
Zuccarello
Kreider

5 is a mix of:
Staal, Brassard, Stralman, Boyle, MSL and Poo.

I've got a Hank Winter Classic and McDonagh USA. Zucc is on the docket for next season

 

[Bleed Ranger Blue]

Current:

1. Lundqvist
2. McDonagh
3. Staal
4. Girardi
5. Boyle

All-time (since I've been watching):

1. Leetch
2. Lundqvist
3. Larouche
4. Graves
5. Messier (minus his 2nd stint)

 

[aufheben]

If Boyle isn't on your list, your list is wrong.

 

[Bluenote13]

Youre showing your age!

Just turned 40, all down hill from here.

 

[Bleed Ranger Blue]

Just turned 40, all down hill from here.

Happy birthday - see you in 10 years when you have another one that your friends/family care about.

 

[Don Chytil]

If Boyle isn't on your list, your list is wrong.

Brian Boyle top 5 dead or alive

 

[Bluenote13]

Happy birthday - see you in 10 years when you have another one that your friends/family care about.

Eww, If Sather is still GM when I turn 50.........