Which Team Has Best All-Time Lineup?

[EdJovanovski]

Taking players who’ve played for your favorite team, who would be on your all time line up & which team has the best all-time lineup?

Rangers:

Kurri - Gretzky - Jagr
Bure - Esposito - Lafleur
Dione - Messier - Bathgate
Robitaille - LaFontaine - Gartner

Leetch - Park
Greshnar - Horton
Harvey - Zubov

Lundqvist
Plante
Sawchuk

 

[SoldiersOfFilth]

not sure but I know Boston has the best D of all time. Orr, Bourque, Park, Chara, Shore, etc

 

[theicebox]

Vegas Golden Knights

 

[Tad Mikowsky]

Don’t know how it’s not Montreal

 

[96]

Dave Keon - Syl Apps - Ricky Vaive
Lanny McDonald - Mats Sundin - Frank Mahovlich
Charlie Conacher - Ted Kennedy - Eric Lindros
Daryl Sittler - Doug Gilmour - George Armstrong
Auston Matthews - Andy Bathgate - Vincent Damphousse

Borje Salming - Tim Horton
Ian Turbull - Al Iafrate
Brian Leetch - Babe Pratt
Larry Murphy - Tomas Kaberle

Turk Broda
Johnny Bower
Terry Sawchuk
Jacques Plante

godly

 

[oooooooooohCanada]

If you were to go only by players who played for the team during their prime, the Pens would be up there. Lemieux, Crosby, Jagr, Francis, Malkin, Murphy, among others.

A team like the Rangers has a bunch of guys past their best years because its NYC.

 

[MessierII]

Edmonton

Mcdavid Gretzky Kurri
Anderson Messier Hall
Simpson Weight Draisaitl
Smyth Nugent-Hopkins Tikkanen

Coffey Hamrlik
Pronger Steve Smith
Lowe Jason Smith

Fuhr
Plante

 

[Johnny HFBOARDS]

Taking players who’ve played for your favorite team, who would be on your all time line up & which team has the best all-time lineup?

Rangers:

Kurri - Gretzky - Jagr
Bure - Esposito - Lafleur
Dione - Messier - Bathgate
Robitaille - LaFontaine - Gartner

Leetch - Park
Greshnar - Horton
Harvey - Zubov

Lundqvist
Plante
Sawchuk

So then an old-folk home would probably win then huh?

 

[Abandoneduser]

.....

 

[Esq]

Not the hawks

 

[BigTruzz]

Montreal probably

 

[Jumptheshark]

when I see these topics

default is an original 6 team that has 100 years to pull from

 

[Ciao]

Taking players who’ve played for your favorite team, who would be on your all time line up & which team has the best all-time lineup?

Rangers:

Kurri - Gretzky - Jagr
Bure - Esposito - Lafleur
Dione - Messier - Bathgate
Robitaille - LaFontaine - Gartner

Leetch - Park
Greshnar - Horton
Harvey - Zubov

Lundqvist
Plante
Sawchuk

Not too many of these guys had their best years with the Rangers. Leetch, Park, Bathgate, Lundquist and some others stand out. Kerri, Gretzky, Lafleur, Horton and others are head-scratchers -- you don't really think of them doing much as Ranger.

Leafs Nation was treated to shadows of the former Leetch, Francis, Lindros etc in the twilight of their careers but I would not put any of them on an all-time Leafs team.

 

[Narow]

Im not knowledgeble when it comes to past players and rosters but would the nordiques (however thats spelt) rank quiet high?

Atleast sundin AND forsberg played there so my question is based mainly on that.

Despite only being in the league for such a limited time (which may well be their demise in this poll).

 

[AdamParrot]

Barber - Clarke - Jágr
LeClair - Lindros - Giroux
Propp - Forsberg - Voracek
Gagne - Brind'Amour - Leach

Pronger - Howe
Coffey - Desjardins
Timonen - Gostisbehere

Parent
Hextall

 

[Ciao]

Richard, Beliveau, Lafleur, Harvey, Robinson, Savard, Morenz, Roy, Dryden, Cournyer, Vezina and on asnd on. Who else?

 

[Eye of Ra]

Barber - Clarke - Jágr
LeClair - Lindros - Giroux
Propp - Forsberg - Voracek
Gagne - Brind'Amour - Leach

Pronger - Howe
Coffey - Desjardins
Timonen - Gostisbehere

Parent
Hextall

dude where is renberg? before he got injured he was a better version of voracek.

 

[AdamParrot]

dude where is renberg? before he got injured he was a better version of voracek.

Voracek had already two seasons with +0.95 ppg in this modern era. He is one of the best possession players and TOP10 playmaker in the league today. If Voracek played with LeClair and Lindros in 90's he would have had +90 points every season, maybe +100.

Voracek is really underrated on this board. But I will picked him every day over Renberg.

 

[Eye of Ra]

Vancouver Canucks:

Sedin - Sedin - Skriko
Näslund - Kesler - Bertuzzi
Bure - Linden - Mogilny
Courtnall - Ronning - Sundström

Öhlund - Salo
Edler - Jovanovski
Lumme - Hamhuis

Loungo
Mclean

 

[Eye of Ra]

Voracek had already two seasons with +0.95 ppg in this modern era. He is one of the best possession players and TOP10 playmaker in the league today. If Voracek played with LeClair and Lindros in 90's he would have had +90 points every season, maybe +100.

Voracek is really underrated on this board. But I will picked him every day over Renberg.

Renberg before his injury was 1.00 ppg while having elite speed, big size and grit level of the charts.

renberg was big part of the best line ever (legion of doom)

 

[VoluntaryDom]

oilers rangers red wings penguins canadiens leafs all up there. id probably choose habs.

 

[3rdLiner]

not sure but I know Boston has the best D of all time. Orr, Bourque, Park, Chara, Shore, etc

Yeah, throw in prime Thomas for an elite goalie and add some crazy offensive talent like:

Neely, Turk, Espo, Middleton, Bergeron, Marchand, Thornton, Chief etc..

 

[Legionnaire]

*Dionne

 

[Tripod]

dude where is renberg? before he got injured he was a better version of voracek.

This summers All time Flyers voting, Voracek was #11, Renberg #14.

 

[end]

Penguins


Stevens-Lemieux-Jagr
Crosby-Francis-Kessel
Kovalev-Malkin-Recchi
Mullen-Staal-Tocchet
(Kunitz)

Coffey-Letang
Murphy-Samuelsson
Gonchar-Carlyle
(Orpik)

Fleury
Barrasso
(Murray)