Where Does Mikko Rantanen Rank All Time among Colorado Avalanche Players

[wetcoast]

6th for me. Agreed with who is ahead of him:
MacKinnon
Sakic
Roy
Forsberg
Makar
(In no order)

This seems fair although not sure if Makar and perhaps even Roy have more in the longevity scale but Cal is passing him and the argument for Roy is pretty strong.

I wish my Canucks had an all time list as good as this.

 

[HFpapi]

OP should have made a firm ruling on whether or not we include the Nordiques. Doesn't make sense to have a poll if different people are answering two different questions.

Anyways, the consensus I think we could all agree is Avs only: Sakic, Mackinnon, Roy, Forsberg, Makar clearly ahead. Rantanen 6th. Impossible to argue Rantanen over any of those 5 and very, very hard to argue anyone else over Rantanen.

Including Nordiques: Stastny is a no-brainer bringing Rantanen's position down to 7th. Goulet is very arguable but I will give Rantanen the nod for a cup and amazing playoff performances.

 

[Connor McConnor]

Sakic
Roy
Forsberg
MacK
Makar
Rants/Foote
Hejduk
Blake

 

[KirkAlbuquerque]

Uwe Krupp >>>