I don’t think Quick is less capable athletically, at least substantially. I just think the league has figured him out and passed him by. For so long Quick has been great by being aggressive and playing bigger than he is. His lateral movement was excellent and he covered the bottom of the net by coming across in the splits. To beat him shooters had to elevate the puck on cross ice passes, which Quick would try to smother by getting as close to the shooter as possible.
Today more goals are being scored at the 15-30ft range. Just about every NHL forward has a very good shot and can elevate the puck at will. Quick is not able to smother as many shooters and he’s getting beat up high more often, as he’s not a particularly tall goalie. In the Flyers game, all three goals were scored over the same shoulder from distance. Instead of gloving the puck, Quick has his glove down and tries to shrug the puck, which might work if he were 6”3’. There’s no fountain of youth that will help him grow another inch.
I say this as a huge fan, but I think Quick is done at the end of this season. It’s time to hang them up. The Kings should not resign him unless he can manage to figure out a different style of play mid season.