He’s one of the few (if not the only) Top 10 cost transfers that was an unquestioned successYes, to me VVD was a huge overpay. Turned out not to be.
I recently saw the top 10 EPL transfer honestly I couldnt pick out more than 3 successes lol.He’s one of the few (if not the only) Top 10 cost transfers that was an unquestioned success
The top 2 are as well.He’s one of the few (if not the only) Top 10 cost transfers that was an unquestioned success
Was Neymar a success? Without the CL I dont think so tbh. There's also no resale value.The top 2 are as well.
Rest of the 100M+ club is highly arguable though.
Yeah I was trying to find that but gave up. Figured someone else had seen it. It’s a pretty grim list (as of now)I recently saw the top 10 EPL transfer honestly I couldnt pick out more than 3 successes lol.
Yeah I was trying to find that but gave up. Figured someone else had seen it. It’s a pretty grim list (as of now)
Of that list I will say only one is a clear cut success. A good arguement can be made for pogba. The rest are either too soon to tell or complete failures
Of that list I will say only one is a clear cut success. A good arguement can be made for pogba. The rest are either too soon to tell or complete failures
Is it ? How long have you been paying attention forWow United has 5 of the 10 most expensive signings ever. Kind of hard to believe
I think he's being sarcastic.... what's more surprising is LFC having jjust as many as City.Is it ? How long have you been paying attention for
Yes he's a success. He brought tons of spotlight and sponsors to PSG. He has overall been a great player. PSG reached its first CL final.Was Neymar a success? Without the CL I dont think so tbh. There's also no resale value.
Makes sense - sorry @mmk786 if my sarcasm detector was turned off .I think he's being sarcastic.... what's more surprising is LFC having jjust as many as City.
I could see the argument but Mbappe brought that spotlight/sponsors. Regardless of him being a great player or not the objective was to win the CL. So far they havent done so. In footballing terms I could see the arguement for both sides.Yes he's a success. He brought tons of spotlight and sponsors to PSG. He has overall been a great player. PSG reached its first CL final.
That CL final was lost 1-0 after Mbappe missed a sitter in a tight game. I don't think that single missed strike by Mbappe defines Neymar's success or not.
I'd say he's been a bigger success for them overall than Messi, but not as big as Mbappe, or even Zlatan.Was Neymar a success? Without the CL I dont think so tbh. There's also no resale value.
Messi clearly hasnt been a success so that’s not saying anything.I'd say he's been a bigger success for them overall than Messi, but not as big as Mbappe, or even Zlatan.
Was Neymar a success? Without the CL I dont think so tbh. There's also no resale value.
Thats okay.Makes sense - sorry @mmk786 if my sarcasm detector was turned off .
not surprised LFC on there compared to City, but only one of those teams would prominently on the top sales list. The net spend gods must be appeased
City don’t have a ton of like MEGA transfers. What they do have in is a ton of volume in that 40-60m range. That’s where they clean up
Maybe? I think it was only like 65ish upfront though. Rest is bonus/add-ons, not sure if that’s accounted for or notThats okay.
Shouldnt Nunez be on that list? Didnt he go for close to 100?
If we are accounting for the commercial aspect, I would say that the response to that question would be much more favorable.Was Neymar a success? Without the CL I dont think so tbh. There's also no resale value.
So he's a Mbappe blunder away from being a success?Agreed. Can't call him a success until a CL
So he's a Mbappe blunder away from being a success?
Lol.
Ya, that's how I see it.He cost 200M+€
Has missed several games in each season. Has not won the CL that PSG bought him for. And his stats have been good but not unreal considering the cost and the league he plays.
Not a bad signing compared to most in the rank which are insane but not a slam dunk success, for sure