I don’t thjnk the change is as pronounced as people think it is. I’ve always been a big fan of warmups and one thing that struck me even as a teenager was how talented even the goons were. Jim Mackenzie could snipe a puck on the crossbar from 50 ft in warmups. So could Chris Dingman. AHL players could always snipe corners. Of course there’s improvement with each generation. Today’s fourth liners never would’ve made it in the earlier generations because the expectation would be that they could physically dominate, grind and fight when they had to. That’s the shift. We put skill players that never would’ve made it before on the fourth line, because today’s game has almost no physicality and now everyone has to be able to skate. These guys were always there, they just didn’t get a chance. Now they do. I think for stars we’re in a good time because we have elite players during a time where once again they can be elite. This is kind of like the pre-trap mid 90’s era. I do think the league is watered down. Elite players can tear up a league as it waters itself down. We elevate players like Mack and 97 but to be fair stars have never had it easier. People try to dismiss Mario and others because they say THAT time was watered down, but having watched both I don’t see a huge difference. Mario and co. played in an era where you could slash/hook/hold/interere all you wanted. If you couldn’t stop Jagr you could hold up his linemates so he didn’t have anyone to pass to.
To me it all evens out in the wash. I’m a huge proponent for saying Mcdavid should be amongst the greatest to ever play, yet I know he wouldn’t do half of what he does back then because they’d never let him or his teammates near the net. The times are different obviously. Skill is rewarded much more now, which I love. I think there’s always been minor leagues that could play in the bigs if it was ok to be a skill player on the fourth line. Chicago the last couple of years is no worse than many of the expansion teams stars in the 90’s supposedly ran their stats up against.
Except for that first Ottawa team. Woof. That was tough to watch.