GDT: Weaky Ducks vs Hawks, 19 Nov 2024, 7:30 PM CT

Blackhawkswincup

RIP Fugu
Jun 24, 2007
190,618
23,439
Chicagoland
They aren’t getting run over nightly. They can’t score, but they’re in games. I’m not defending him, I’m saying you can’t deplete the roster before Thanksgiving

Trading Murphy doesn't deplete much

This is last place team and he should have no future here

Holding onto Murphy given his injury history is not defendable and carries to much risk

Get on phones and get him out of here
 

Mrfenn92

Proud to be American
Sponsor
Nov 27, 2018
33,436
33,518
Chicago,Illinois
Guys IDK bout you....but I'm starting to see a very, VERY good chance developing with each passing game for the Hawks to land a top 2 overall pick. We're truly awful. And make no mistake we NEED that pick. BADLY. We need another elite level young forward talent. So this is good stuff. Still no need to worry about how bad we are when you consider how many of the players on the current roster won't be here/will eventually be replaced by the time things actually matter. Plus we'll have a new head coach. As long as Bedard and Vlasic hold true and continue to show promise we're on track. The vast majority of the remaining young core pieces are either still developing or haven't even been drafted yet.
Kaiser and Allan are going good also. Reichel has bounced back. Soderblom has been a completely different guy so far this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SimpleJack

Blackhawkswincup

RIP Fugu
Jun 24, 2007
190,618
23,439
Chicagoland
You can’t trade him at the deadline. You can’t trade him when your only other RD is hurt. He just played 25 minutes.

So your advocating f***ing holding onto Murphy? It makes no sense

Trade his ass already before he gets hurt

And call up Crevier to play 25 minutes. The team is in last place and is goin to finish among worst in NHL

What message does it send to have trash like Joey Anderson as your 1st line winger? Let alone on an NHL roster to begin with?

Your reasons for not trading Murphy make no logical sense
 

TLEH

Pronounced T-Lay
Feb 28, 2015
21,536
18,480
Bomoseen, Vermont
So your advocating f***ing holding onto Murphy? It makes no sense

Trade his ass already before he gets hurt

And call up Crevier to play 25 minutes. The team is in last place and is goin to finish among worst in NHL

What message does it send to have trash like Joey Anderson as your 1st line winger? Let alone on an NHL roster to begin with?

Your reasons for not trading Murphy make no logical sense
My reason is that you need players to play with the guys who will be here in the future and you cannot get run over for two seasons in a row. What’s Murphy gonna get? A 2nd? A third? Big deal.
 

Blackhawkswincup

RIP Fugu
Jun 24, 2007
190,618
23,439
Chicagoland
My reason is that you need players to play with the guys who will be here in the future and you cannot get run over for two seasons in a row. What’s Murphy gonna get? A 2nd? A third? Big deal.

We have Brodie and Martinez who were sold as those type of guys

This team is in last place in NHL and pathetic. They are getting run over and embarrassed nightly so spare me this nonsense that keeping Murphy is a must

Especially since we have this joke behind bench nightly
 

ChiHawks10

Registered User
Jul 7, 2009
28,732
22,621
Chicago 'Burbs
We have Brodie and Martinez who were sold as those type of guys

This team is in last place in NHL and pathetic. They are getting run over and embarrassed nightly so spare me this nonsense that keeping Murphy is a must
I don't think that keeping him is a must, but I also don't think trading him is a must, either. He's only going to return maybe a 2nd or 3rd.
 

Blackhawkswincup

RIP Fugu
Jun 24, 2007
190,618
23,439
Chicagoland
Since Murphy is so shitty we better get that 4th rounder 18 games in and f*** our roster construction while our only other RD is out.

The roster that construction consists of shit like Joey Anderson on 1st line, Smith/Maroon and other assortment of crap playing nightly?

That roster

Trade Murphy and call up Crevier and you will get same result no matter what with regard to on ice

Last place with Murphy = Last Place without Murphy
 

Ad

Ad

Ad