Was Mike Gartner underrated?

[Golden_Jet]

Not sure how they compare to today is really relevant to my point...

Well the first part is if you don’t like the second part.

 

[Albatros]

Larry Murphy has 18 40 point seasons

Bobby Orr only has 10 20 point seasons

Murphy also way ahead in career points.

Larry Murphy is also underrated, played for very good teams late in his career but was also a very good player. Played a big role behind each of the four cups he won. Orr won two in 12 years while also playing for very good teams.

 

[Run the Gauntlet]

Larry Murphy has 18 40 point seasons

Bobby Orr only has 10 20 point seasons

Murphy also way ahead in career points.

Are you trying to say that Orr was a 'flash in the pan' type player?

 

[Dingo]

Are you trying to say that Orr was a 'flash in the pan' type player?

no, i was using the same argument the guy above me was for why Gartner was a better goalscorer than Bure.... at least at the time i thought he was saying that. He has since clarified a bit.