Proposal: Vegas and Minnesota

[AKL]

Exactly, we gave a 1st for Hanzal to be a 3rd line center as a rental. What a waste.

So your point is that we should make other awful deals like this one to...make up for it?

 

[Timj5304]

Let’s revisit this trade now

 

[AKL]

Let’s revisit this trade now

It’s still a no

 

[2Pair]

Let’s revisit this trade now

You're still allowed to post here after that proposal? Seems like a bad idea

 

[Jugitsu]

Let’s revisit this trade now

Even bigger no.

 

[elnewby]

The two things that Minnesota definitely doesn’t need are:

Left handed defenseman
Slow, bottom 6 wingers on the wrong side of 30

/thread

 

[ref19]

Vegas gets

Jonas Brodin
Charlie Coyle

Minnesota gets

Nate Schmidt
Ryan Reaves

What in the world

 

[FrodoBeggins]

Vegas gets

Jonas Brodin
Charlie Coyle

Minnesota gets

Nate Schmidt
Ryan Reaves

 

[PuckInTheNards]

This is horrific even by HF standards. OP is either a troll or a moron.

 

[Digitalbooya]

Let’s revisit this trade now

What makes you think this is worth revisiting?

 

[CupInSIX]

Let’s revisit this trade now

Not a chance in hell Vegas gives up their #1D for that package, not to mention giving Reaves as a throw in.

 

[nt3005]

Not a chance in hell Vegas gives up their #1D for that package, not to mention giving Reaves as a throw in.

Thats good that Vegas wouldn't do it, because this is atrocious for MN.

Schmidt is not a #1D on the Wild, and Reaves also brings minimal value. A team that has one of the highest scoring Defenses doesn't need to add another Scoring D Man. Also we struggle to score goals, how would Reaves help this team?

 

[gwh]

Let’s revisit this trade now

Jeez OP...

Did you necro your old relatively hilarious proposal for what exact reason? Relive the fun?

 

[CupInSIX]

Thats good that Vegas wouldn't do it, because this is atrocious for MN.

Schmidt is not a #1D on the Wild, and Reaves also brings minimal value. A team that has one of the highest scoring Defenses doesn't need to add another Scoring D Man. Also we struggle to score goals, how would Reaves help this team?

Imagine thinking a package of your #4 and a glorified 3rd liner would be enough to get a legit #1...

 

[nt3005]

Imagine thinking a package of your #4 and a glorified 3rd liner would be enough to get a legit #1...

I can't tell if your actually being serious or not. But your talking about the 27 year old, left shot D, with a career high of 5 Goals and 36 pts?

 

[AKL]

Imagine thinking a package of your #4 and a glorified 3rd liner would be enough to get a legit #1...

I lold irl

 

[Bazeek]

If Schmidt's Vegas' best defender it doesn't make sense to trade him for Brodin and Coyle.

Likewise, it doesn't make sense for Minnesota to give up Brodin and Coyle when they've got 3 defensemen better than Schmidt.

Not sure why this needed to get bumped.

 

[CupInSIX]

I can't tell if your actually being serious or not. But your talking about the 27 year old, left shot D, with a career high of 5 Goals and 36 pts?

Let me guess you wouldn't move Brodin for Ellis either .

Ellis never broke 40 points he must not be very good.

 

[gwh]

Let me guess you wouldn't move Brodin for Ellis either .

Ellis never broke 40 points he must not be very good.

5/5 for internet discussion ability.

I think nobody would trade Ellis to get Schmidt, if that was the question.

 

[llp]

And Brodin being our "number four" defenceman because he plays behind Suter means that he isn't very good either?

 

[nt3005]

Let me guess you wouldn't move Brodin for Ellis either .

Ellis never broke 40 points he must not be very good.

I'm guessing our GM might make the trade of Brodin for Ellis because he loves his Nashville boys. But if we did make that trade it would be a setup for a trade of Dumba or Spurgeon because Ellis Would be to expensive with his new contract.

Schmidt also doesn't get you Ellis.

 

[mikeyp24]

Reading through this thread only to realize on page 2 it was a necro made my day. Hilariously bad to start but to retread was even better. As the neutral fan in this situation and if I had to pick 1 or the other team I like more I 100% choose vegas but man this is bad for MIN.


I also love the idea that people think Reeves is worth stuff these days. Curse you Pens for that whole 1st rounder garbage you created.

 

[Dr Jan Itor]

Let me guess you wouldn't move Brodin for Ellis either .

Ellis never broke 40 points he must not be very good.

With the way our team is currently constructed, I don't think I'd move Brodin and Coyle for Ellis (and random Nashville 4th liner).