Guadana
Registered User
I didn’t.You went out of context. We were talking about Russian defensemen we drafted. Shakir was the only one who really amounted to anything so far and he isn't with this team.
If you want to dig back to drafts prior to 2019 that's fine because Zaitsev , Rykov etc never played a game here and Okhotiuk is back in the KHL. Let's see if aside from Silayev that any of those Russian/Belarusian players (Orlov , Karpovich , Barbosha etc...) amount to anything at the NHL level.
I'm not knocking on the picks and I actually like these prospects a ton. I like the fact that this organization is drafting players from there because historically that region has pumped out a ton of talent. We would be fools like some other organizations to stay away from drafting Russian/Belarusian players. The Senators are a team who never draft from there and you can see how bad their recent drafts are in part because of that.
Rykov was a part of the trade. Pick worthy. But bad career.
Zaitsev has career, better than most 7th rounders. May be not pick worthy, but in compare to Hellicksson and Chainey - he is hockey player.
Shakir was a big part of a big trade. Him, not Holtz. We know the price of Holtz.
Misyul is playing in ahl.
Okhotyuk played with organization, as ahler and nhler, was a part of big trade. Pick worthy.
Orlov is KHLer, played 63 games. He was drafted in 2022 and he is ahead of many players who was drafted before him.
Barabosha is near KHLer. Played 21 games. May be he will be more, may be Zaitsev level, still better than most 2022 drafters.
Karpovich was drafted in 2023. His next step is pro career.
Silayev is one of the best defensive defenseman prospect with best skating.
That’s what we have in Russian D prospects.
And we have Chainey, Hellickson, Bernard, Cheslock, McCarthy, Edwards, Davis, Smith, Hurtig.Vukoevic, Vilen, Leddy. Russia vs all the world(typical).
Chainey is nothing,
Hellicson is nothing,
Bernard isn’t even regular AHLer,
Cheslock is far away from pro career now in compare to Russian prospects
McCarthy isn’t bad prospect but he is nothing for organization now.
Edwards is in one step away from making the same. Hope he will sign the deal.
Davis was smaller part in Subbans trade, we can compare him to Okhotiuk. Who was a part of a trade for better player.
Smith isn’t NHLer, was a part for a trade for lesser player than Shakir. And Shakir now have better AHL and KHL career, have better potential to be NHLer or better NHLer.
Hurtig is nothing
Vukoevic isn’t regular AHLer, already isn’t a part of organization
Vilen - good prospect, pro career, NHL potential.
Leddy is somewhere between AHL third pair potential and McCarthy path
Everything is fine with Russian Devils prospects and what this organization have in them. Much more much better than what they had from other drafted defensemen. Like you said - it’s good that we don’t repeat sens way of drafting.
Last edited: