Proposal: VAN / EDM

[Jumptheshark]

You’ve posted a proposal between Vancouver and Edmonton and literally had everyone say it’s bad for one team.

These fanbases would get in a 6 page argument over whether a McDavid for OEL trade was fair and you found a way to get them to agree that a trade was trash for one side.

Congrats

As oiler fans we believe this deal should be done right...we will pay for the airplane and moving costs...in way shape or form is this such a bad deal for vancouver that everyone on their side would be fired on the spot

 

[Canucks LB]

for f*** sakes

 

[M Ace]

To Edmonton Oilers

Thatcher Demko
Brock Boeser

To Vancouver Canucks

Jack Campbell
Kailer Yamamoto
Jesse Puljujarvi

As an Edmonton fan. Canucks wouldn’t even touch this. Not even alone for Demko. We can keep our spare parts for the winter!

 

[Jumptheshark]

for f*** sakes

hey-one of your guys came up with the idea--So it must be a good idea? I checked the guys history and he aint an oiler fan----however if this trade does happen--he can be our leader for a year

 

[jackjohnson]

To Edmonton Oilers

Thatcher Demko
Brock Boeser

To Vancouver Canucks

Jack Campbell
Kailer Yamamoto
Jesse Puljujarvi

Canucks give up the 2 better pieces for 3 trash players? cmon, Poolparty is worst than Boeser and Jack Campbell would be 4th on Canucks goalie depth chart. Yams is what Canucks have plenty and better

 

[Paddys Pub]

Vancouver needs to add Hughes and a 1st

 

[Dr Awesome]

Oilers have to think about this one, as they will be waiting for classic Borat nooooooooot.
Oilers take this offer all the way to the bank.

 

[BannedFromCDC]

Wait a Canucks fan is posting this? Done deal form the Oilers. Demko has a longer body of work than Campbell and I have more faith in him turning it around than rotten Soup, and Boeser can't be thaaaat bad right?

Demko has played 1 more career game than Campbell. Campbell also has better career numbers. Demko is not that guy trust me.

 

[GOilers88]

Canucks give up the 2 better pieces for 3 trash players? cmon, Poolparty is worst than Boeser and Jack Campbell would be 4th on Canucks goalie depth chart. Yams is what Canucks have plenty and better

What three goalies would be ahead of Campbell if Demko went to Edmonton?

 

[jackjohnson]

What three goalies would be ahead of Campbell if Demko went to Edmonton?

he is 4th on depth chart after Demko, Martin and Silovs

 

[DingDongCharlie]

You could take Boeser out and I’d still do this for Edmonton.

No chance this is a real Canucks fan proposal. Has to be a troll account

 

[TheNumber4]

Demko really is the new Gibson. Elite value for shit performances.

 

[McVespa99]

To Edmonton Oilers

Thatcher Demko
Brock Boeser

To Vancouver Canucks

Jack Campbell
Kailer Yamamoto
Jesse Puljujarvi

Consider yourself accepted into my heart as an honorary Oilers fan

 

[Three On Zero]

he is 4th on depth chart after Demko, Martin and Silovs

It would be Campbell, Martin and then Silovs

Martin and Campbell are both unproven and could switch but you have to take the 5m guy

 

[Cogburn]

It would be Campbell, Martin and then Silovs

Martin and Campbell are both unproven and could switch but you have to take the 5m guy

Because a paycheque impresses the coaching staff into preferential treatment, or...?

 

[Three On Zero]

Because one guy has 6 career NHL wins, so you go with the guy who showed glimpses of being an nhl starter that got him a $5m/year payday

 

[jackjohnson]

It would be Campbell, Martin and then Silovs

Martin and Campbell are both unproven and could switch but you have to take the 5m guy

why you have to take the 5 million guy? would you take darnell nurse the 9 million dollar guy over Seider? obviously not, and Martin being cheaper and better is an advantage.

 

[jackjohnson]

Because one guy has 6 career NHL wins, so you go with the guy who showed glimpses of being an nhl starter that got him a $5m/year payday

lol you mean you are going with a goaltender that Holland severely overpaid? Same Holland that signed Nurse to 9 million dollars contract? By your logic OEL is definitely more suprior than Seider...I mean look at his contract and the fact he was also traded for 9th overall pick. OEL is definitely a superstar dman

 

[Three On Zero]

why you have to take the 5 million guy? would you take darnell nurse the 9 million dollar guy over Seider? obviously not, and Martin being cheaper and better is an advantage.

Because that's what the original trade has in it?

Do I want Campbell? No

lol you mean you are going with a goaltender that Holland severely overpaid? Same Holland that signed Nurse to 9 million dollars contract? By your logic OEL is definitely more suprior than Seider...I mean look at his contract and the fact he was also traded for 9th overall pick. OEL is definitely a superstar dman

Again... when the original trade has Demko and Campbell switching teams.....

 

[Bryanbryoil]

Are you going all in for Bedard? Otherwise this is a bad trade for YVR.

 

[AlainVigneaultsGum]

MOMMM!!!! Grandpa's drunk and posting trade proposals again!

 

[archangel2]

you know it is a bad deal when oiler fans tell ya it is in their favour

 

[604]

If the Oilers added their next two 1sts, I'd do it.

Start the tank! Campbell will be one of our generals.

 

[McSuper]

Ken Holland, is that you?

Nope. Mike Milbury is back with a vengeance.

 

[GreeningOil]

Yamamoto and Puljujarvi for Boeser, Campbell for Demko?

That’s laughable Edmonton gets 2 upgrades while Vancouver gets 3 down grades.

Might as well be Boeser, Horvat and Myers for Draisaitl and Kulak

Pls don’t mention Draisaitl in anything regarding Canucks